Home > Society & Lifestyle > Lifestyles & Subcultures > Subcultures
Results so far:
| Help | 38% | 109 votes | Total: 290 votes | |
| Hurt | 62% | 181 votes |
Help
Created on: November 11, 2007
There are a very few Italian-Americans still alive! I think this debate is directed more towards Americans of Italian decent.
I do not think the Sopranos show hurt the image of "Americans of Italian decent!" If anything, it hurt the first and second generation New Jersey Americans of Italian decent with bad accents, big hair and cheesy personas.
Any intelligent person understands the mafia speaks for a minute percentage of Americans of Italian decent. New Jersey Americans of Italian decent do not speak for the rest. Like any other filtered culture in America, there are good and bad, but as Americans, we are fixed on the bad, which in a weird way is romanticized. Thank you Hollywood!
What I did enjoy behind the Sopranos mafioso theme was the backdrop of family or was family the theme and mafia the backdrop? Regardless, the Sopranos love for family, pride in heritage and struggles in and passion for life struck a chord with me.
Movies, like "The Departed" do not hurt the image of Americans of Irish decent. It speaks for a small group of Bostonians from Irish decent, especially one who made fools out of the real American mafia, the FBI. This issue comes up every time another movie or show comes out about the mafia or gang related theme. We will be debating a similar issue after the media and public have absorbed the movie, "American Gangster?"
In brief, did the Sopranos help the image of Americans of Italian decent? I do not think we need the help.
Learn more about this author, Salvatore Oliva.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Hurt
Created on: January 16, 2009
I'm not exactly sure that the program "The Sopranos'" hurt the Italian-American culture in the Untied States, but taking a program like this one out-of-context and believing that there still is a managed structure such as the mafia in existence can be of itself a damaging image for Italian-Americans.
I actually saw the 'entertainment' value of the program and what I would believe to be extreme in vilolence and therefore unsuitable for viewing by children under the age of 17 years. But if Americans in general think that all Italian -Americans have some conection with a mafia-like subculture, then I would have to agree that it could be damaging to the image of the national pride in Italian-Americans.
I am of Italian American heritage, my mother was born and raised in Naples, Italy. When I watched the television show 'The Sopranos' I myself felt absolutely no connection to the characters in the show what-so-ever. I didn't even have a concept of identification with the characters, having never been exposed to such a criminal element which can be clearly linked to other nationally syndicated crime organizations such as the IRA; or Hamas; or any other violent criminal organization.
Many movies and television programs in today's society are full of violence, crime, and sexual content that I find highly disturbing, whether they be programs with any oriented nationalities; American; Irish; Italian; German; Leboneses; etc... the very context of which can be misleading and troublesome in our society.
With perspective on our growing economic concerns, I would say that these types of programs be viewed very carefully and considered a possible danger to people whom are concerned with say: homelessness; poverty; and joblessness. This country is on the verge of national crisis because of its toppling economy driven by the greed and averice of some corporate managemet executives who seem to be 'getting away with crimes' comitted against average American Citizens.
These CEO's and management executives whom have stolen pensions; IRA's; and set aside security incomes of the average American for college funding or retirement purposes should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law and be made to 'pay back' stolen funds. Now here is the REAL damage to image of ANY culture, be it Italian American; African American; Irish American; German American, etc....
Talk about hurting an 'image' of a certain culture, it is my belief that the AMERICAN image is being destroyed by its own element of organized crime in CORPORATE AMERICA!
Where are the law makers of our country to put a stop to the stealing? Where is our constitution that should be upholding the rights of the American people with regard to safety of identification and security of our money in banking establishments?
I'm appalled and frightened at what is happening in our own AMERICAN culture with the rape of average american citizens in plain view of authorities that should be protecting our rights and money.
The Sopranos program dosen't hold a candle to the agonizing death of watching your own savings being stolen right under your nose LEGALLY by Corporate Management Controlled Securities Organizations!
Learn more about this author, Leah Davidson.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.