My Helium | Join | Log in Where Knowledge Rules

Politics, News & Issues:

Environment

Debate_icon

RSS RSS Feed

Get a Widget for this title

Should people eat only locally produced, organic food?

Results so far:

Yes
41% 145 votes Total: 357 votes
No
59% 212 votes
Yes

I think it is just better all the way round for us to buy local and organic food. I will try to explain why below.

I think that the concept of locally grown must be dealt with to explain why it not as difficult to access local crops as some imply. I like to define locally grown in terms of time rather than distance. I look at locally grown as the time it would take a farmer round trip from home to the market to sell his goods in a eight hour work day. Thus in a country with a good road network local could be one hour at highway speeds say 50 miles. In a country with a poor road network it may be only two miles. The energy cost and carbon dioxide produced in long distance transport will be reduced when we buy local.

Organically grown crops are also better for the environment. Why? Organically grown crops do not
have pesticides that kill or maim beneficial insects or other soil organisms. There is no fertiliser run-off to pollute waterways. The use of nitrogen based fertilisers also release nitrous oxide a potent green house gas. Locally grown organic crops will use less energy to be grown and will generate a less of a carbon foot print as a result.

The soil quality in organically managed farms is better than those using artificial methods. Ancient soils called Terra Preta de Indio or Amazonian Dark Earth's are soils that were created by ancient societies in South Americas. Terra Preta soils are very bio-active and self-regenerating and actually absorb carbon dioxide out of the air and release no nitrous oxide. These organically maintained ancient soils are key to organic agricultures benefits to the earth and us as well.

Organic crops do not use pesticides thus there will be no pesticide residues that could harm us the consumers. Pesticides and other toxic by products from their use tend to concentrate up the food chain. And since we are at the top of the chain we will store the most toxins. Feed the animals we eat organically grown fodder and we will get less toxins as well. Organically reared animals are also healthier to eat as there is artificial hormones and antibiotics used in their growth.

Genetically Modified or GM crops are food crops that have been modified at the DNA level to enhance or create features not present in the plant naturally. The safety of these crops is questionable as the test done to prove their safety are usually small sample sizes and often lack critical peer review. Since organically grown crops are not Genetically Modified in any way they are inherently safer to the consumer.

So why are organically grown food stuff so much more expensive? Well economies of scale, there are less farmers growing organic crops so the cost will be higher. We need to encourage farmers to get into organic farming if we are to see cost reductions. It should be noted that organically grown crops will always be a little more costly as organic farming is labour intensive.



More info on Terra Preta soils.
http://www.css.corne ll.edu/faculty/lehma nn/terra_preta/Terra Pretahome.htm

More info on Organic Farming economics:
http://en. wikipedia.org/wiki/O rganic_farminghttp:/ /en.wikipedia.org/wi ki/Organic_farming

Or ganically Grown food healthier?
http://fin darticles.com/p/arti cles/mi_m0ISW/is_200 1_Oct/ai_78900839

Learn more about this author, Garvin Nelson.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

It would be so nice to vote "yes" on this subject. The key word in the question is "only." If it were possible, then yes, people should eat "only" locally produced, organic food. However, in the United States, in our current society, it's just not possible.

I speak from experience as a homemaker. It is my desire to feed my family wholesome, healthy food. As much as possible I try to avoid cooking unprocessed "manufactured" food - try not to fill up my cupboards with boxes and cans. As a consumer, it is my desire to support local farmers who do grow with organic practices, and this includes meat products as well as produce. As the "health monitor" for my family, it's my desire that the food I buy be free of pesticides and other potentially harmful additives. However, it's just not possible to purchase locally produced organic food in exclusion of any other source.

The first reason why not is availability. In my area there just aren't enough growers to produce the variety needed. I tried one of the new services that offer organic produce trucked in from other areas, but often the quality was hit-and-miss and the prices were high. I don't like to buy produce I can't pick out for myself.

The second reason is also availability. In order to give my family a good diet, I have to shop at the local grocery store in addition to what I might be able to find at local growers. My area does not grow oranges, for instance. To have them I have to go to the grocery store and amazingly, one of the best varieties available this winter was actually from Australia! The flavor was incredible.

Another reason is price. There just aren't enough local organic growers to support the surrounding population and that results in high prices. In the summer, I love to drive around and get the best variety of peaches I can find, but the price makes them a summer luxury, not a staple.

The 21st century is an interesting mix of very large populations and an increasing desire to return to the basics of "home-grown" produce. It's an awesome idea but just not practical. Having said that, however, a caveat is that it behooves us to support local organic farmers as much as possible to help them and to help ourselves.

Learn more about this author, Linda Smith.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA