Home > Politics, News & Issues > Environmental Issues > Climate Change
Results so far:
| Yes | 70% | 425 votes | Total: 609 votes | |
| No | 30% | 184 votes |
Yes
Created on: June 15, 2007
The issue is of the most pressing nature to all countries of the Earth. It is of paramount importance as the freshening of the North Atlantic by way of run off water from these melting glaciers does threaten the ability of the Gulf Stream to function and the increase in ocean levels threatens all coastal areas of the globe. We must all understand that the problem is hardly Greenland's alone, but is a very real global problem that threatens our ability to live in many places on Earth and as a direct result threatens the ability of the global economy to continue to function.
As fresh water runs to the sea from the glaciers of Greenland the Gulf Stream, which allows for temperate climates to exist in places like the British Isles, Norway, Finland, and Sweden, becomes weaker as the salinity of the North Atlantic lessens. If temperate climates are made colder year round in areas of the far north farming is dramatically affected in these areas and these countries will have a difficult time providing for their people. That would create greater demand upon foreign markets and allow for less available surplus crops for less developed nations. This strain on farming would in turn cause greater spending of gross national products and consumer spending just to keep a standard of living which existed prior to the ruin of the Gulf Stream. Which could easily cause the devaluation of any of these countries currency which, in turn, could cause other countries that rely upon the spending of these nations on their products to feel an economic noose tighten around their necks.
Rising sea levels are a threat to any and all coastal areas of the Earth. As all the oceans of the world are connected to one another any rise in North Atlantic sea levels are sure to be felt worldwide. Given a large enough rise in sea levels the areas that are built on coastlines anywhere are sure to suffer damage as the ocean reclaims beaches and low lying areas. This, of course, will mean the displacement of citizens, the destruction of infrastructure and the loss of millions in investments both by the government of affected countries, private citizens and foreign investors. Those losses would result in weakening of economies all over the world and, of course, the global economy as a whole.
The aforementioned reasons are enough cause for concern on a global scale, but there is, at least, one other extremely good reason for the world to be very worried about what is happening in Greenland. That is that the melting of these glaciers are an excellent barometer for measuring the rate at which we warm our planet. Measuring the run off and the rising sea levels show us the rate at which we are damaging the Earth. If we continue to warm the Earth at the rate we are at present we will see dramatic increases in the run off water from these glaciers and we will certainly see temperatures rise worldwide. When we have done a sufficient amount of harm we will see the Gulf Stream fail completely which will allow for the northern European nations to see short summers or no summers at all. At some point after that happens the snows that fall in the winter will fail to melt away during the summer months and the build up will begin, slowly at first, to reflect the Sun's warmth back into space. After enough time with no summers the accumulating snowfall will become glacier ice itself and we may well find ourselves in another ice age. This will certainly be a problem for every person that lives on this Earth.
It is a very safe bet that once we have seen the damage to the Greenland glaciers cause enough harm to citizens of other countries that there will be an outcry for some dramatic action to be taken to solve the problem. At that point in time, however, it will likely be too late for any action to be effective. Only if we take the time to be concerned now and do something that will have affect positive change on the situation will we have any hope of avoiding disastrous consequences in the future. This is a world problem well worthy of concern on the part of every nation and every person on Earth.
Learn more about this author, Nouri Arif.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
No
Created on: June 11, 2007 Last Updated: October 14, 2010
Greenland’s glaciers are melting, but should we be concerned? Some very intelligent people say that we should. Others, equally intelligent, say we should not.
A great level of concern has been generated about global warming and the problem of greenhouse gases in our atmosphere. While we should be good stewards of the earth, we must also realize that a limited amount of data has been collected concerning the global climate, that scientists don’t know everything, and that everyone interprets data according to his or her bias.
Issues with Data & Interpretation
The data from the past 150 years seems to indicate an overall trend of increased surface temperatures on Earth. Is this increase caused by greenhouse gases? Perhaps. But the tricky thing about data is you rarely have enough for conclusive arguments.
For example, according to 2010 research by NASA, previous estimates of glacial reduction are significantly too high—by half or more. The new estimates are based on a phenomenon called rebound (the deformation of the earth’s crust in response to fluctuating ice levels), which wasn’t considered in previous estimates.
Before including rebound into the equation, scientists were confident in their estimates about melting glacial mass. But they were wrong, and they convinced a lot of people that a great deal of ice was melting that wasn’t.
Is rebound the only variable scientists failed to identify when figuring glacial retreat? And how many more variable are involved with global climate? As much as scientists know, they only know in part.
Reasons not to Worry
Concerning Glaciers—Some glaciers around the world are growing. Most notable are those in Antarctica, which contains 90% of the world’s ice and 80% of its freshwater. According to a 2009 NASA article, Antarctica is growing. Why? Scientists have theories, but are uncertain.
Concerning Temperature—Should we be surprised that the trend of the available data shows an overall increase in global temperature and a resulting glacial melt? Climatology, history, and archeology indicate that the earth’s weather and climate seem to be cyclical. The global climate fluctuates over the course of decades and centuries, and while global temperature is currently on the rise, to say that the world is going to become an oven as a result would be fallacious.
Conclusion
Caring for the earth is important, and being aware of problems is integral to effectively dealing with them. And attempts to optimize efficiency and limit gas emission should be applauded, but this needn’t become the greatest concern for the world today.
Works Consulted:
Adam Voiland. “What’s Holding Antarctic Sea Ice Back From Melting?” NASA. January 9, 2009. http://www.nasa.gov/ topics/earth/feature s/antarctic_melting. html. Accessed October 2010.
Coby Beck. “How to Talk to a Climate Skeptic.” http://www.grist.org /article/series/skep tics/. Accessed October 2010.
Greg Roberts. “Antarctic ice is growing, not melting away.” April 18, 2009. http://www.news.com. au/antarctic-ice-is- growing-not-melting- away/story-0-1225700 043191. Accessed October 2010.
“Huge iceberg breaks off Greenland glacier.” CBC News. August 10, 2010. http://news.ca.msn.c om/top-stories/cbc-a rticle.aspx?cp-docum entid=25149714. Accessed October 2010.
Lewis Page. “Antarctic glacier melt maybe ‘not due to climate change.’” The Register. June 21, 2010. http://www.theregist er.co.uk/2010/06/21/ autosub_in_pig_melt_ clue/. Accessed October 2010.
Lewis Page. “Greenland ice loss rates ‘one-third’ of what was thought: New results ‘deviate sharply’ from established wisdom.” The Register. September 7, 2010. http://www.theregist er.co.uk/2010/09/07/ revised_ice_loss_est imates/. Accessed October 2010.
“Melting rate icecaps Greenland and Western Antarctica lower than expected.” Delft University of Technology. September 2, 2010. http://www.tudelft.n l/live/pagina.jsp?id =7a6c3d15-1c1e-4869- b378-840a000c6803&lang=en. Accessed October 2010.
Learn more about this author, Brandon Michael Davis.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.