Home > Relationships & Family > Marriage & Divorce > Marriage > Married Life
Results so far:
| Husbands | 33% | 432 votes | Total: 1301 votes | |
| Wives | 67% | 869 votes |
Husbands
Created on: June 01, 2009 Last Updated: June 02, 2009
I chose "husbands," over wives for 1 reason. Unfortunately, and I am a woman, statistics show that women are more likely to be shopaholics than men. I am sorry. But, that is it. I knew that many would choose the "wives," because, probably, 1 they are the wife, and 2. it was the politically correct thing
to do. To claim "husband," would symbolize your descent into the stone age for many. It seems that some women are afraid to submit anything to the husbands: unless it is unfavorable characteristics.
However, Honestly, if only one controls the finances, it is not an equitable marriage. there must be communication and compromise where finances are concerned.
Most Americans are in debt. This is not just because of the stereotypical spending habits of the wife, but for that vacation, extra car, house and many
other things that we buy when we are spending outside of our means. Our society is quite busy and we also eat lots of fast food and spring for those other conveniences that make life easier, but eat up our budget. I am not saying that men don't spend. Of course they do and many times, also outside of their means.
But, if there is not communication where finances are concerned and an agreement as to how and where the money is spent, then economic challenges will be exacerbated. The bank accounts and such are probably in the bread winner's name, but that does not mean that you should leave all of the decisions up to him or her. Even when one is better at managing finance! s than another: both need to be making decisions. One person said: if the wife had an MBA, then, of course, she should. I disagree.
You don't need a MBA to be a good manager of finances. I know some people who never stepped foot in a college and they were quite good at managing their money. It does not have to do with education, rather common sense. And, even if the one with more managing savvy is the leader, he/she needs to help the other learn these techniques. After all, no one knows what tomorrow will bring. I have seen many women who knew nothing about finances and business and when their husbands died, they were clueless and vulnerable.
Some have suggested separate accounts. I disagree with this concept because it tends to polarize the partners. And, it only puts a bandade on the issue. The problem might be that one person is spending more than the other. It might be that one person is more frugal than another. Thus, these issues need to be discussed and compromised upon. I know women who have said: "I should not have to ask my husband to spend our money." and husbands who say: "Why should I consult my wife if I want to buy something?" Some women say: "If my husband is going to give me a credit card, I'm going to use it: after all, he does want me to look good, so I am doing it for him."
Likewise, some men say: "I make the money, I should be able to spend it how I choose." But, this issue is not about "freedom." It is about respecting your partnership and your marrital finances. In this way: both partners should be consulted when a substantial purchase is being considered. Both should have an active part in the financial decisions of a marriage. It is too bad that this debate pitted men against women. It is too bad that there was not a "both," or question about how a plan would look that had both husband and wife managing the finances. But, this will get lots of responses and probably some knee-jerk reactions.
Learn more about this author, Jan Wright.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Wives
Created on: July 22, 2010
When discussing whether the husband or wife should control the household budget, the question should be which of them is better with money. If the wife is bad with money then certainly the husband should be the one to care for the finances of the home. However, since the wife is at home, if they are both equally responsible, she should be responsible.
The reason that the wife should control the family budget is because she runs the home, especially if she is a stay at home mom. If she works then they can share the responsibility. Women usually are the ones that know what the house needs and what the family should have. She usually keeps track of the bills and how much each extra need will cost.
If she is a stay at home mom, she usually knows how much she needs to take care of the house. She can tell you how much she needs for groceries, how much it will cost you for little Jimmy to take Karate, how much you need to clean the carpets. She knows when children need new clothes, when to replace worn and defective merchandise, and usually does all the cooking.
If he is able to balance work and keeping a household budget, he may want to do it. Most men would prefer to just let her take care of it especially in the case of a huge family. It requires an intimate knowledge of the budget, and what is needed to care for a large household.
A huge consideration is hourly employees, those who work by the hour, may want to create a budget around their work schedule, to do this they will need to be in charge of the budget. In most cases, men and women will choose the person who can decide how their hourly pay will be spent on household requirements
Another consideration for who would be in charge of the household budget would be the background of the man and woman. In some situations, families expect the man to budget the household and the woman to do the shopping only after receiving a house allowance from the husband. Some men have the belief that if they allow the woman to have complete control of household finances, that they will be giving up their ability to wear the pants in the household. Therefore in this situation, the woman buys the stuff that she needs for the home, but the husband is in charge of the actual budgeting.
Learn more about this author, Katherine Johnson.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.