Results so far:
| Yes | 62% | 1135 votes | Total: 1837 votes | |
| No | 38% | 702 votes |
Yes, I believe so, as what newborn child does any evil deed? As a human being, it possesses the qualities of goodness. I keep in mind the words from an old Abba song - "I believe in angels, something good in everything I see" and try to apply their meaning to everybody I meet or connect with. But I am a realistic, and relatively intelligent adult, so I understand that goodness at birth may not extend so easily to the later stages of life, for whatever reason.
Experts in many fields have examined goodness in terms of ethical behaviors, social norms and moral values that individuals use to shape their lives and interactions with the world. Religions might attribute goodness to the presence of God, or gods, in the person's soul. For the purpose of addressing the question under debate, I prefer to leave the more scholarly aspects alone, and express personal ideas for saying "yes."
Just look at very young children, who, without prompting, will share food, toys, kisses and hugs, all good actions that many parents will praise and encourage. Sadly, not all adults respond this way, which is where goodness can become blurred and diluted. By nature, we start off good, but nurture and adverse circumstances may push these better impulses under and out of the normal behavior patterns. A deprived child, whether emotionally or physically bereft, might have to become selfish or grasping in order to survive; at least in Western, more affluent societies. Yet consider those form the poorest of beginnings, who go on to give back to others, to show inherent goodness in practice. An example of this are the African immigrants with British citizenship. They may have belonged to a colony, or been granted asylum and many are in low paid jobs. They have a better life and more wealth than those left behind in the home country. They get together to send money back to endow schools, keep hospitals going, support others less fortunate. If that is not evidence of altruistic, inherent goodness, I don't know what is.
The other side of the argument might ask that we look at the terrible crimes that have destroyed lives and filled prisons. Yes, there are flawed human beings who have abandoned morality, betrayed their goodness. But I believe there are far more prison inmates who would show kindness, help another or wish to do so, than there are truly evil people. Bad deeds get more publicity than everyday evidence of goodness.
In the wider world, there are many instances to give proof of this belief. We may obey the rules of the road because the law demands that we do, but watch how people consider others, treat them with consideration and politeness. If an accident occurs, look how people stop to offer help - that is a fact of everyday life. Such impulses may arise from the belief that this is "the right thing to do", but it is inherent goodness that turns belief into action.
Some might argue that good acts come from the morals of the society in which we live. I would say that a look at those who helped the Jews during the Holocaust would partially refute that notion. No, those people risked their lives to follow the dictates of conscience, because they were inherently good. In times of danger and disaster, goodness shines out. I think of 9/11 and the bravery of the rescue workings. That was pure, unselfish goodness.
None of us is perfect, "good" days and "bad" days happen to us all. Yet I think more evidence exists for the presence of inherent goodness in the vast majority of mankind. It is just a matter of believing it is there, looking for it, accepting its presence and offering it back at every opportunity. Yes, we are good, let us just practice harder at being so.
Learn more about this author, Dolores Moore.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
This question "Are people inherently good?" is not a well-phrased question because from my perspective people are not inherently good or inherently evil. So if the question had been framed "Are people inherently evil?," I would have voted no. Much of my opinion comes from observation of the adults and children around me.
So for purposes of this discussion, I view people as inherently selfish. Please hear me out. When you watch a roomful of small children, you will begin to notice that these children do not know how to share. Once they have a toy or toys, they will not give them up for anything except for something interesting like outside play (running, screaming, etc.) or another brightly colored toy. I have seen cases when one child will want another toy so badly that she will bop the boy on the head to get the toy. Of course, the other child will bop back until you have a small war on your hands.
When an adult tries to take away one of these toys, the child will scream unless the adult has something more interesting in his or her hand. Trading a wooden block for a brightly colored toy can be a good distraction for a small child.
These reactions and behaviors found in small children can also be found in adults and even in macro situations like politics. Even though the US is one of the most giving countries, our nation looks at foreign policy as how it affects this country.
And I am sure you have heard the saying: I'll scratch your back, if you'll scratch mine.
I am not saying that being selfish is bad or even evil. All I am saying is that as an inherently selfish individual, I am more interested in the survival necessities for my family such as food, home, and clothing. Also, I have to deal with chronic illness, which makes me more interested in supporting causes dealing with this disease. For instance, if I gave my extra money for cancer research, which is a worthy cause, I would not have enough money to pay for medications and treatments for my illness. So in this case, it is wise to be selfish.
Further, most people are neither really bad or really good, but a mixture of both. It takes a lot of bad decisions to make it in the top ten list of evil people such as Hitler. In the case of good, there are very few Mother Theresas out there in the real world.
So my advice is to do the best you can for yourself and your family. It is the little choices that show our true characters.
Learn more about this author, Cyn Bagley.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.