Politics, News & Issues >
Baseball
Get a Widget for this title
RSS FeedWhich baseball team has the most loyal fans: The Boston Red Sox or the New York Yankees?
Results so far:
| Yankees | 39% | 206 votes | Total: 524 votes | |
| Red Sox | 61% | 318 votes |
Yankees
Write now
Print
Invite a writer™
Add to FavoritesYankees fans have a reputation for being a tad overbearing, but hey, those are the local fans. Yes, I remember the way they treated some of their own, like Reggie Jackson, and how they have treated opposing teams playing in Yankee Stadium. Even so, I never go anyplace that there isn't at least one Yankee fan - in Texas, in Oklahoma, even in Atlanta, Georgia.
There is something very charismatic about the Yankees and their stadium. Their colorful history is incredible. They had The Babe, Mickey Mantle, Roger Maris, and they have Arod and Derrick Jeter. The list is interminable, and whether you like the players or not, many of them are and have been through the years more than a little interesting and a lot talented. As for the stadium - just to say you have been to a game there makes people green with envy. A shining example of this is the home run derby this year. Josh Hamilton invited his seventy-one year old high school coach to pitch to him in Yankee Stadium. The two of them put on quite a show with Josh hitting more than thirty home runs, the coach said, "wow, I made it to the All-Star game at Yankee Stadium, and I only got one vote, Josh's". I still can not believe they are tearing it down. It epitomizes baseball history.
This is not to say there are not several great teams, with the BoSox being among them, but none can touch the indominitable Yankees who, without a doubt have the most interesting owner. George Steinbrenner has made some really strange decisions in his personal history with the team, but he always comes out smelling like a rose. I mean, how many times did he hire and fire Billy Martin as a manager? When the Seinfield Show did a parody of him, he took it all with a grain of salt, and it was a hilarious part of the show.
The American League Yankees have played in thirty-nine of the one hundred three Series through 2007 and have won twenty-six World Series championships. No other franchise has come close. In the National League, the Dodgers hold the top number as a participant, and that is only nineteen.
I do not live anywhere near New York, but I've rooted for that team all of my life, except when they have played my local favorite, which is also an American League team, so the Yankees come to town occasionally, which is always cool. The Yankees keep it exciting, and they are one reason baseball is still popular. I keep reading that it's dying on the vine, but when I attend a game, the stands are full, and teams are building bigger stadiums all the time. I know lots of little boys who play little league and dream of playing in the "Big Leagues", and to get to go to a Yankee's game would thrill every one of them.
While most sports have become almost brutal, baseball has retained some semblence of sanity. Granted, a broohaha breaks out occasionally when a pitcher brushes a batter back too often, but for the most part it is a display of personal skill with many of the players displaying charm and charisma. The Yankees hold the top spot for that.
Learn more about this author, Linda Burleson.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Red Sox
If you live in Chicago and are a Cub fan you may qualify as even more loyal than some of the front running phonies who have jumped on board the fan base of either glorious team in the American League East. The respective fans of either the Red Sox or the Yankees have been spoiled by their recent success so I would ask if the teams were not as successful would this even be a subject for serious discussion. Yanks versus Red Sox is a great rivalry but both teams have won World Championships relatively recently and so the fan base has been fed and knows what it likes to win and has ownerships and players that know how to play and win.
I think it is easy to be loyal to your team if it wins championships, has a long and proud history of success and legions of good players
Several years ago before the Red Sox broke their streak of bad luck, beating the Yankees and going on to win the world series that year, I would have agreed that the Boston Red Sox had the most loyal fans in the country.
Fenway Park was and is still an old, quaint ballpark, the curse of the bambino, Ted Williams,Yaz, Buckner, Manny being Manny and Johnny Damon getting a hair cut and plying for the Yankees are all subjects of conversation for the faithful. The team is surely colorful but I think you have to go back to the real glory days of the Red Sox say 1929 when they finished in last place for the fifth straight time and seven out of the last eight years.
In 1932 I'm not sure if it could have gotten worse as the Red Sox finished 43-111, 64 games behind the Yankees, lead by Babe Ruth to their fourth championship since being sold to the Yankees. If attendance was any measure of loyalty, those 182,000 fans were either rabid fans or came to see the visiting team.
This level of ineptitude breeds a form of character that burns very deep into the soul of a baseball fan and as result you start judging your life by the results of your team. Superiorty or inferiority, joyous or despondent, optimistic or pessimistic, the sports page told the story as you lived your life from spring training till the time that the team was mathematically eliminated from participating in post season play and the cry of wait till next year was the charge for the future.
The catharsis for Boston after winning the championship in 2004 was something that even the most hardened non baseball could understand.
Baseball is changing. I thought this year I would start following the Tampa Bay Rays as the fan base was being tested in a manner I thought would leave them in such a funk that they would ask to be switched to a less competitive division as they would forevever be out matched by the large market teams with larger fan bases and histories of success. In their history they have only been out of the cellar one time.
The playoffs are approaching and the baseball world is almost upside down. The Cubs have the best record in baseball, and the Rays are in first place way ahead of the Yankees and 4 games ahead of the Red Sox.
Maybe this debate should have been which team has had the most improbable season.
Learn more about this author, John Asgeirson.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Difference of opinion? Debate now.
