Search Helium

Home > Society & Lifestyle > Ethnicity & Gender > African-American Issues

Should America pay restitution to the descendants of slaves?

Results so far:

No
49% 1610 votes Total: 3283 votes
Yes
51% 1673 votes

No

by Jason Young

Created on: June 08, 2007

I'm a 30 year-old black man living in Oregon. This year my grandfather turns 80 and for his birthday he wanted all of his children, grandchildren and great grandchildren to gather at the place of his childhood in rural North Carolina. I am just finishing grad school so packing my wife and two daughters on an airplane was no small or inexpensive feat. North Carolina held many revelations for me as we visited what for lack of a better term are my "ancestral grounds". I saw the house where my Grandfather grew up. I saw the place where my own father was born. I walked through cemetaries filled with my ancestors, some of them slaves or children of slaves. I walked on a plantation where, stories have it, my people toiled and bled and sweat. It was a blessing to walk on all of these sacred sites with my sisters and cousins and my daughters and my wife who, by the way, is white. I felt deep gratitude to my grandfather for bringing us all to this place but also to the people who came before me.

Black nationalists and seperatists talk about returning to the "motherland" or making a "pilgrimage". As I stood in the tobacco fields and listened to my family's history unfold from the mouths of those who are old enough to remember it, I realized that Warren, North Carolina is my motherland. I'm an American, but not because I deserve it. This privilege was purchased for me with the lives and vitality of my ancestors, who were property when they came here. They purchased their freedom with their perseverance, spirit, and will. Why would I need repairations? If anybody owes a debt it is me. I live in the healthiest, wealthiest and most promising country in the history of the world. I understand that America still has a long road to travel until we respect each other equally but that change won't come overnight nor will it come in the form of a check from the government or white people or anybody.

I'm paying my repairations to my slave ancestors by being the best man I can be. That is what they purchased for me and I'm not going to waste it.

Learn more about this author, Jason Young.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

Yes

by Sonja Romnus

Created on: February 09, 2009   Last Updated: February 16, 2009

"Should America pay restitution to the descendants of slaves?", I believe shouldn't be a question in this day in age, but a chapter in a current history book sitting on desk across the United States whose subtitle reads: "Why and How Restitution to Slave Descendants Came to be in the US". If we take one moment to allow ourselves to be stripped of the misinformation taught in schools across America we could view this question with our "eyes wide open". Answers between whites and blacks of America will vary significantly, and this is not due to lack of compassion or oversight, but simply that of "ignorance".

First and foremost, there are disparities that currently exist in the United States due to slavery. Slavery didn't just enslave the body of the slave; but the mind of those belonging to the black and minority groups. Whether, applying for employment, a mortgage, or a personal loan the divide amongst applicants belonging to the black or a minority group although the line is invisible is clear to see. This is mostly due to education, employment, health, and familial disparities that still separate the two groups some 200 years after slavery.

It is impossible to conceive what it is like to wake up as a black man, woman or child daily unless you are that man, woman or child. From individual to institutional discrimination blacks and other minorities are on the receiving end almost daily. We live in a society that allows for the socio economic landscape to exist as such almost if out of necessity to maintain a balance. If challenged to list 20 Advantages of Being Black/ Minority in America I am sure the list would not surpass five. However, if challenged to list 20 Disadvantages of Being Black/ Minority in America it would take less than five minutes to complete.

When deciding whether or not and how restitution should be extended to descendants of slaves, there are many factors that come into play. Deciding who the descendants are is a challenge in itself, but one that can be overcome with thorough examination and record keeping practice and appointment of a counsel to do such. Once in action, this is no easy task as it will open a floodgate. America will be on record for turning back history by admitting to the wrongdoings of their ancestors. Arrogance is one reason that slavery and reparations is not a topic for much discussion today. It is that same arrogance that has not led to a formal apology by the United States Government, but rather a few Health Care Companies and other Corporations whose empires were founded and raised upon slavery. Can we only hold the U.S at fault when so many other allies were alongside America in the slave trade? What would be their joint financial responsibility?

After deciding who the descendants are, and who owes what; a form of distribution would need to be set in place. Lump sum payments would have an immediate affect on the U.S and world economy, so therefore a structured socio-economic service would have to be formed. Many have proposed the formation of an independent group to oversee and carry out the distribution. A group separate than that of those that assisted identifying the descendants. This group would form an umbrella under which services to descendants would exist. This would lessen the gap of disparities and the plight of the descendants of slavery.

Imagine, if you would inner city schools receiving funds that would allow for the same education afforded in a suburb, trust fund and endowment programs for health care, post secondary education, housing development and obtainment, small business loans, education loan forgiveness programs, daycare, and preschool programs that are substantial extended to descendants of slaves. Would this change the ever widening gap between incomes, housing, education and health? There are many that believe it to be so, but if it is never attempted the narrower the margin for success.

Learn more about this author, Sonja Romnus.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA