Home > Politics, News & Issues > US Politics > US Economy
Results so far:
| Doomed | 39% | 162 votes | Total: 412 votes | |
| Comeback | 61% | 250 votes |
Doomed
Created on: September 25, 2007
Every American will hate the word "doomed" in this debate. Of course, we hope and pray that the auto industry will recover, and once more be the world leader in both quality and economy of its products. However ... and it is a big and growing however ... the nation's carmakers and their employees have been on a self-destructive downward spiral since the 1960s.
First, at this moment, with all the problems and killer foreign competition they're facing, the last thing the US auto industry needs now is a major work stoppage. So, to make the self-destructive situation worse, for the first time in more than 30 years, 73,000 clueless General Motors workers went out on strike. On the day the walk-out was called, a news photo seemed to summarize the problem. It showed a grossly fat union guy with a strike sign, and nearby a grossly fat plant guard closed the factory fence.
I don't know all the demands of the strikers, but seeing those two guys certainly doesn't indicate GM is paying starvation wages. Statistics show American auto workers get as much as five times the wages of Mexican and Asian automakers, and it may be debatable, but many consumers believe the foreign workers are more quality conscious, take their jobs more seriouosly, make lower demands on employers, and just maybe, make better cars.
As an American, I certainly don't agree that our workers make inferior products. However, no matter how I feel or how people in the auto industry can prove, their reputation has been damaged by consumer reports and public opinion over the years throughout the world. Going out on strike for more money will do nothing but cause further injury that already wounded image.
I don't know how this strike will affect the already crushing foreign competition on American automakers, but it also comes at a time when China is about to market its subcompact Cherie extensively in the US. The small car, expected to sell in the US for about $12,000, has been successfully consumer tested in Asia and Europe for two years. Their stubby looks and economic performance records remind older folks of the success of the Beetle in the 50s and 60s. And we all know how the VW succeeded in securing a dominant position in the US market.
Considering the relentless foreign competition in both car production excellence and quality, the US auto industry, already badly damaged by two decades of inferior products, has an enormous challenge ahead. What it doesn't need at this critical time is a a crippling strike that could serve as a death knell for the entire US automaking industry.
Learn more about this author, Ted Sherman.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Comeback
Created on: August 26, 2007 Last Updated: September 25, 2009
Now that the U.S. auto industry has taken its pain of vast financial losses and bankruptcy in the case of GM, it can start picking up the pieces of its broken industry and reemerge once again into the global auto making industry as a leaner, fuel efficient, cost effective, product friendly and more environmentally friendly set of businesses. Whether or not the new American Auto industry will be in Detroit alone remains to be seen as operational costs may be lower in other locations.
Some of the encouraging news prior to the collapse of General Motors proved to be overly optimistic and was not an accurate reflection of things to come. The American auto industry has a tough path to climb as a number of auto industries that didn't collapse are far more advanced and evolved. Edward Demmings, a U.S. innovator exported his operational methodology to Japan a long time ago, but the U.S. didn't want to change its existing operational model until it was too late. This article will discuss the U.S. auto industry in terms of conditions before and after its decline. In such it will become apparent that not only can news be misleading, but that the U.S. auto industry is in for a change long over due.
I: AUTO INDUSTRY NEWS PRIOR TO GM'S BANKRUPTCY:
"General Motors Corp.'s second-quarter profits of $891 million were viewed on Wall Street as an important sign of progress in the automaker's comeback bid." (1) The worst is over for Detroit's major automobile manufacturers. For the last year prior to August 2007 General Motors, Ford and Chrysler have been exercising aggressive measures in many fronts to ensure a competitive future for their Global and Domestic market positioning. One need only look at recent developments to realize U.S. auto manufacturers are in the automobile market for the long haul and aren't going to just give up their legacy of Global automobile market positioning. Both General Motors and Ford have been taking drastic but essential measures that will ensure both their survival and competitiveness in the future of automobile manufacturing. A few of these efforts are illustrated in the two following corporate summaries:
General Motors:
*General Motors is already positioned in the Worlds top two auto manufacturers
*Union negations with the Union of Auto Workers (UAW) could lower Health care costs
*Aggressive sales incentives could boost car sales
*Capital restructuring of GMAC and other parts of GM improves cost accounting numbers
*New developments in Energy Efficient automobiles enhances competitiveness
*International profit margins have recently performed well for General Motors
Ford Motors:
*European profit margins have improved for Ford and an 8.2% share of European market
*Niche car markets such as Jaguar, and Mustang have strong brand equity and appeal
*New small sub-compact auto designs could further boost European market share
*Fuel cell technology research such as hydrogen pellets allows Ford to compete with leading auto manufacturers in the future
II: THE NEW AUTO INDUSTRY LANDSCAPE
Traditionally as Japanese automobile manufacturers have rivaled the U.S. in auto sales and innovation U.S. Auto manufacturers have consistently stepped up to the plate to compete. The current situation is no exception. While the effects of widespread plant shutdowns and layoffs seems daunting this is a necessary step for U.S. car and truck companies so they can adjust for current conditions. The business environment is competitive and the restructuring events of the recent past have reflected that. What they do not reflect is these companies lack of ability to succeed in the future.
To say Detroit is doomed because of restructuring is like comparing apples to oranges. Steps taken to ensure market positioning is the key to these companies reemerging to be global auto industry leaders. The U.S. auto industry has sold off less profitable product lines, restructured its debt and begun the path to a new business model that replaces an outdated antiquated one. The U.S. has the technology, know how, engineering capacity and financial infrastructure necessary to bring itself back into the forefront of the auto industry. This comes at a time when the U.S. is facing challenging competition internationally and confidence in the U.S. economy has wained. What this doesn't have to mean is that the game is over.
Understanding the U.S. and International auto market is also key to rebuilding the U.S. Auto industry. According to auto industry statistics from the Wall Street Journal, the signs of a declining auto industry became increasingly clear in years past. Japanese manufacturers have gained an ever increasing piece of the U.S. market share. Apparently, many American consumers prefer more reliable, efficient vehicles from overseas. This has to be for a reason and it is these reasons the U.S. Auto industry should consider when re-branding, and re-designing future models. Internationally, the same story is important, obtaining market share means providing quality, reliability, efficiency and vehicle models that match the financial and social characteristics of new generations.
Sources:
1) http://www.detnews.c om/apps/pbcs.dll/art icle?AID=/20070801/A UTO01/708010343/1148
2) http://biz.yahoo.com /ap/070824/gm_techno logy.html?.v=4
3) http://www.reuters.c om/article/marketsNe ws/idUKN243497012007 0824?rpc=44
4) http://online.wsj.co m/article/SB11879037 6498007050.html?mod= yahoo_hs&ru=yahoo
5)http://phx.corpora te-ir.net/phoenix.zh tml?c=84530&p=irol-SECText&TEXT=aHR0cDovL2NjYm4 uMTBrd2l6YXJkLmNvbS9 4bWwvZmlsaW5nLnhtbD9 yZXBvPXRlbmsmaXBhZ2U 9NTA5MTc1NSZhdHRhY2g 9T04%3d
Learn more about this author, A.W. Berry.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.