Join | Log in

Channel Button
Debate_icon

Education   >

College Life

Get a Widget for this title

Should colleges ban firearms?

Results so far:

Yes
80% 686 votes Total: 859 votes
No
20% 173 votes
Yes

I'm a firm believer in our rights as stated in the Second Amendment. In fact as a college student, I regularly hunted on weekends, but that was as a local who drove to school. If you asked me this question a year ago, I may have cast my lot with the other side, but the Virginia Tech incident has made things much fuzzier than before. Now, I'm afraid that college students who are target shooters or hunters should wait to go back home to practice their sport. Outside of the campus police, there really is no place on campus for a gun.

Heinous acts aside, some schools might even be chosen by students who enjoy the shooting sports, or at least partially on that basis. Schools like Virginia Tech and West Virginia University are a half-hour drive (or less) from shooting ranges and public hunting lands. It would be a shame if they weren't allowed to enjoy the great American sport, but there really doesn't seem to be much of a choice. Cho Seung-Hui's crimes were carried out with a .22 caliber rifle, which is generally considered a kid's first gun or a "plinker". However, it's really not all that hard to imagine what kind of damage he could have done with a hunting rifle or assault weapon.

In August of 1966, Charles Whitman climbed to the top of a tower on the University of Texas campus and killed 14 people while wounding 31 others. His weapon was a 6mm Remington hunting rifle, and the 6mm is an effective long distance killing machine. Anybody within 500 yards was effectively in Whitman's danger zone. An entire section of the university was held hostage for a couple of hours, and if it weren't for the heroic actions of the police, the damage this lunatic could have caused is unimaginable!

Believe it or not, there is one scenario that is even more frightening than the horrible deeds of Seung-Hui and Whitman. The idea of serial killer on a college campus isn't really all that far fetched. John Muhammed and John Lee Malvo had the entire mid-Atlantic region on alert for 17 days in the fall of 2002. Officials wondered just who these madmen were in light of the 9/11 disaster a year earlier, and their apprehension came about as a stroke of luck. It makes one ponder the possibilities! A disturbed individual with a plan could cause untold pain for a long period of time. Even as somebody who supports our right to bear arms, I am of the opinion that there really is no place for assault rifles in our society. They are illegal as a sporting arm, and for personal protection there is nothing better than a shotgun. Muhammed's weapon was designed with one purpose in mind: killing. It was built with a soldier in mind.

Like anything else, campus shootings really didn't sink in the first time around. Maybe we should have had this discussion in 1966 instead. The truth is that times have changed. As a kid, I can remember other students (fifth and sixth grade) bringing guns to school for show and tell. Here in West Virginia, it didn't even seem to be that big of a deal, but we now live in a different world. Some people no longer seem to be inclined to solve their problems with their fists or over a cup of coffee. There is only one way to prevent the Texas and Virginia Tech disasters from happening again: guns have to be banned on college campuses.

Learn more about this author, T.C Leonard.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

Our second amendment rights are being stripped away every day thanks to criminals committing armed robbery, mass murders, and various other crimes. On top of that, we have a nave government that thinks that regulation or prohibition is the answer. The truth is our law enforcement agencies are out numbered by criminals and unfortunately outgunned.

Another truth is gun crimes happen in all places. Even places like banks which are federally regulated against carrying a firearm on the premises'. This regulation does not stop armed robbery. It just makes the penalty more severe and a dangerous situation even more dangerous. So banning them on college campuses is not going to stop a tragedy like the terrible events at Virginia Tech.

How many lives could have been saved that day if a law abiding citizen carrying a concealed weapon would have stepped in. We will never know the answer. We can spend hours combing over the statistics but there is no point. The truth is that guns are necessary, prevalent, extremely difficult to regulate, and never going away.

Unfortunately, many campuses will not allow their security forces to carry firearms. They rely on local state and municipal law enforcement agencies to step into situations where seconds are vital. In the time it takes for law enforcement to respond to a shooting, many lives can be lost. A law abiding college student with carrying a concealed carry license and firearm can save time, in turn saving many lives.

Firearm usage is not just a question of morals but a question of intent. Human nature has and always will be to destroy each other for beliefs, values, and property. A firearm is a tool, similar to a hammer, knife, axe, or power drill. In the wrong hands, they are dangerous weapons. The only difference is how the law defines them.

For example, when a hammer, axe, knife, or power drill is used criminally to kill or harm a person, it is considered a dangerous weapon. This is because these instruments were designed for uses other than to kill or harm a human being. Firearms on the other hand are considered deadly weapons as they were designed to kill. The real truth is that, many deadly crimes are committed with instruments other than firearms. It doesn't matter what instrument is available, people will find a way to harm or kill another.

As US citizens we need to be able to defend ourselves from our enemies, neighbors, and government. Whether we are at the bank, school, grocery store, or in our own home firearms are the best protection. Banning firearms on college campuses is just another way our government and other establishments are chipping away at our rights and abilities to legally defend our lives, and the lives of others.

Learn more about this author, Christopher Howard.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA