Home > Religion & Spirituality > Religious Concepts > Religious Concepts (Other)
Results so far:
| Yes | 30% | 382 votes | Total: 1280 votes | |
| No | 70% | 898 votes |
Yes
Created on: November 24, 2007 Last Updated: November 25, 2007
Let's face it. The tree we call the Christmas tree has been a religious symbol, long before Christianity came to Europe, at least as far back as the first century CE. It may be older than that, but we know it is at least this old.
One of the most prevalent cultures during these ancient times was what we now call Germanic/Teutonic. Tribes which fit into this overall term spanned as far south as Northern Italy and as far east as Latvia and Lithuania and as far west as France. For the most part, these tribes spoke dialects of a common language and held certain common beliefs, with local variations.
One of those beliefs was that; if you bless the gods even in hard times- they would, in turn, bless you with peace, prosperity, and even a myriad of sons to protect the family farm. Now, the hardest season for humans to live in is winter. We don't have enough fur to keep us warm and we don't hibernate. We can't grow many vegetables during the winter and fruit-bearing trees are dormant. Food is scarce. Families were lucky to come out of winter alive.
This luck, they attributed to their protection by the gods. "If the gods want to keep us alive, we should thank them for it." But sometimes the gods have a way forgetting that our ancestors were still there waiting for spring. So, around mid-winter, it was customary to remind the gods by way of blessing them that they were still alive.
Remember I mentioned that the trees were dormant? Most trees shed their leaves and sleep all winter. But some trees remain green all winter, like the Pine, Spruce and Cedar. According to the ancient logic, these trees must have been associated with prosperity and longevity. For a tree to stay green in the hardest of times was recognized as a miracle, which could only come from the gods. If the gods are smiling upon such trees, they could be used as a focal point to leave blessings and remind them of a family's continued existence. So,families would troop out into the forests in the middle of winter, choose an evergreen tree and hang gifts of food on it.
Eventually, some ancestor got the bright idea that, because it was too cold to be outside for any length of time, the tree might just as well come in. After all, the gods like warmth as much as we mere mortals do. And the tradition was evolved. Gifts to the gods became gifts to each other and the sacred tree was burned to give warmth to the house. To keep alive the sacredness of the tree itself, part of it was kept until the succeeding year to start the new Jul (Yule) Fire.
By now, the Germanic/Teutonic tribes had split, reformed, renamed and migrated a number of times but the cultural and religious traditions remained,at least in any number of variations. But a new religion was being introduced in Europe, this being Christianity.
Try as they might, the believers in this new religion could not shake the ancient cultures of many of its old ways. The Church did the smart thing and said, "If we can't beat them, join them. There must be some way of redeeming' this ancient practice and use it to spread the word of our religion." And the Jul Tree traditions became part of the celebration of the birth of their god. But long before the Christmas tree was Christian, it was pagan, and very religious.
Learn more about this author, Bradley Murphey.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
No
Created on: July 30, 2008 Last Updated: August 13, 2008
"Oh Tannenbaum, Oh Tannenbaum"..."Oh Christmas Tree, Oh Christmas Tree"....regardless of our language or religious affiliation, orientation, or heritage, under no circumstance is the Christmas tree a religious symbol. None of the five major religions of the world have adopted the Christmas tree as one of their religious symbols. The houses of worship are not adorned with Christmas trees throughout the three hundred and sixy-five days of a year, so that its parishioners can use "the tree" in their worship service. Therefore, since the Christmas tree does not represent a religious symbol to any particular religion, as religious symbols are defined, supports the reason we often see the tree displayed in public places during a particular holiday season. The "tree" cannot violate the separation of church and state, since the "tree" is not a religious symbol. The good news is that it is just another tree that people decorate every year, in a particular way at a particular time.
There has been much discussion regarding the symbology of this tree. It originated a long time ago in Germany. Historically, the United States did not immediately begin to use the tree as a symbol....its presence evolved and later became fashionable and accepted in our society. The whole social aspect centered around a Christmas tree is this: who on a particular block can "out do" who this year....it's simply a very commercial aspect of a very expensive holiday season. Let's face it; there are so many forms of this tree depending on the fashion of the day. We can determine what decade we were in by the type or style of Christmas tree that was on display in stores, public places, and private homes.
People always seem to long for that "old-fashioned" Christmas, whereby they actually go out into the proverbial woods and cut down a perfectly fine tree, strap it to a huge gas guzzling SUV, and trudge on home only to find that its too big for the entrance to the garage door and must be shortened on the lawn. This was the Christmas tree of the 1940's and 50's. Next, we experienced the 60's with the sex, drugs, and rock and roll generation...peace, love, war....no more with a silver metallic Christmas tree in every front living room perched up in the front window with the electric circular colored rotating disk to illuminate the most fantastic tree around and a symbol of our religion, NOT. More likely a symbol of our drug induced trip of our minds as we all gathered under the fallen metallic branches.
Later came the 1970's and early 80's and the wonderful invention and the WalMart favorite, the realistic green fir tree with already attached twinkling lights of either plain white or color depending on our couth. For the refined consumer, the plain white twinklers flew off every shelf...how easy to decorate cutting the time we really needed to spend on such a religious symbol. Yes, the answer to the Christmas tree question was solved by the Chinese once again....new fake green pine and fir trees all around the town to show our true spirit of Christmas and when finished all can be easily packed away in their respective boxes one fake limb at a time.
Learn more about this author, K.D. Saffron.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.