Get a Widget for this title
RSS FeedWhich makes a better pet: A dog or a cat?
Title endorsed in part by:
Results so far:
| Dog | 62% | 2632 votes | Total: 4219 votes | |
| Cat | 38% | 1587 votes |
Dog
by Tim O'Dell
Write now
Print
Invite a writer™
Add to FavoritesDogs are such loyal creatures. When you come home at night they act as if you're the only person in the world they want to see, and when you leave in the morning they look as if their hearts would break. Where in the cat world can you find this kind of devotion?
From the daily walks, to the cuddles by the fireside, dogs will show more love and affection than a cat ever will. Yes, a cat will sit in your lap, allow you to stroke them, but will be off to pastures new as soon as the whim takes them. A dog will stay by your side through thick and thin. A dog will never let you down.
Cat's may be intriguing, but they are loyal to nobody but themselves. They are haughty, feckle creatures that march to their own drumbeat. They will often chase, and catch, other animals, bringing them home as a prize. They are closer to the feral, untamed beasts that all pets once were. While this may be part of their attractiveness, and certainly doesn't make them unsuitable as pets, it makes it harder to create that warm bond that characterizes a human/dog relationship.
There is a reason dogs are called 'man's best friend'. Dogs will love their owner's no matter how they're treated. A dog can be treated most cruelly, and, even though it breaks our hearts, they will still remain loyal to their owners. This is a devotion that will never be found in cats.
For a loving owner, life with a dog can have no comparison. To be welcomed home, to be treated like a king, to be loved and adored by the friendliest of animals; this is the joy of owning a dog. What can a cat bring to your life that compares with this?
There are so many instances of dogs remaining loyal to their owners, even when they have died, that their devotion could never be doubted: Greyfriars Bobby, who stood vigil over his master's barely discernable grave for fourteen years. Or Hachiko, who waited each day for 10 years at a station platform, waiting for his master to come home, not knowing he had died. How often have cats shown that kind of loyalty?
Dogs will come joyfully to the call of their name. Dogs will obey their master's command. Dogs can be trained to do extraordinary things. Dogs can, and have, saved lives. Dogs are unequalled when it comes to intelligent, domesticated pets. No other animal in the world can be as intimate with their owners as dogs can.
In the animal world there are only two species that are domesticated enough to truly become part of a human family; cats and dogs. Of these dogs are the most loyal, most devoted, most friendly companions. There can surely be no competition; dogs provide everything you could ever need in a pet and can become true friends. This can't be said of cats, which is why dogs will always make the better pet.
Learn more about this author, Tim O'Dell.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Cat
As much as I love dogs, I think a cat makes a better pet. Of course, not every cat makes a good pet, but the average cat beats out the average dog every time. From cost to cleanliness they are cheaper and easier to care for.
Most house cats are mixed bred. You can find them on the street, people give them away in the paper every day. Animal shelters practically give them away. Dogs, on the other hand, cost money. You can find them on the street but then you're probably looking at some medical or social issues the dog must overcome. People don't normally give dogs away either. Purebreds cost money, even mix breed dogs will lighten your wallet a little. Animal shelters still charge more for a dog than a cat, no matter what the breed.
Cats are almost instinctively housebroken. Show them a box full of litter and away they go. The only time they mess elsewhere is when their owner neglects the box or the animal is sick. You only need to clean the box every other day or so. Dogs must be housebroken. This can be a long, messy procedure and nothing guarantees the dog will stay that way if you move, or introduce another pet into your home. They have to be let out constantly. Just finished feeding them...out they go. Your pooch gets excited? Out it goes. In the morning, in the evening, no matter what the weather. When they come back in, they often track dirt. Sure, cats and dogs can be outdoor pets but what's the point of a pet that stays outdoors?
Some people say that cats are aloof while dogs are always eager to please. In truth, cats are more independent than dogs because they do not have the "pack" instinct that dogs do. This pack instinct has several bad effects. It can cause them to roam, which is the least of your problems. The biggest being pack animals thrive on a hiearchy, with each member of the pack jockeying for a higher position with the other dogs. When dogs do that with humans, the results can be dangerous. A dog doesn't simply attack its owner, with the winner of the fight as the alpha male. This dominance is done through small things like him going through a door before you. Or blocking your way up the stairs. When that dog wins enough of these little "battles", it becomes aware of its dominant position in the pack. When you hear stories about how someone's dog suddenly turned on them in the kitchen, its often for that reason. Cats don't care if your the leader or not. Besides, a dog's bite is a lot worse than a cat's.
Cats live longer. An outdoor cat will only live an average of 3-5 years. Indoor/outdoor cats can live a little longer. Strictly indoor cats have been known to live 22 years with good care. Dogs aren't so lucky. The larger the breed, the shorter their lifespan. Some tiny dogs can live about 20 years. Great Danes are extremely luck to live 9 or 10 years.
Cats are cheaper to feed. This isn't even a close contest. A 12 pound bag of cat food will last my three cats well over a month. A single small dog would finish the same bag in a few weeks while a large dog would empty the bag in two or three meals. Add the fact that a cat will stop eating when it isn't hunger while a dog will eat until it pops. If I leave a weeks worth of food out for my cats, in one week they'll be tidily finishing up their last meal. Put a weeks worth of food in front of the average dog and watch. In 30 minutes that dog will be groaning on the floor, overstuffed with 7 days of food.
I could go on about how cats take up less space. How they require less attention. That they're cleaner and smell better than dogs, but you get the idea. No matter how you stack things, cats make better pets than dogs. Strangely enough, I still really want a dog because cats don't fetch.
Learn more about this author, Mark Murphy.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Difference of opinion? Debate now.
- Pet Ownership
- Should you allow your dog or cat to sleep in your bed?
- Should a pet be used to teach a child responsibility even at the cost of the pets life?
- Does having pets in the home create or relieve stress?
- Should pet owners be charged additional fees if they live in an apartment?
- Should pets be given "people" names?
- FlexPetz: Is having a part-time dog responsible ownership?
