Join | Log in

Channel Button
Debate_icon

Sports & Recreation   >

NBA

Should NBA coaches be allowed to scout student athletes prior to high school graduation?

Results so far:

Yes
45% 177 votes Total: 393 votes
No
55% 216 votes
  • 1 of 18

    by Thos Robert

    Strictly speaking, NBA coaches do not scout amateur athletes. The office of a NBA coach is in charge of scouting opposing teams. It is the office of the General Manager and/or...read more

  • 2 of 18

    by David Brown

    The question or argument of whether NBA coaches are allowed to scout student athletes prior to high school graduation is a moot debate! This is going to happen! Money is invol...read more

  • 3 of 18

    by Stuart Kantor

    NBA coaches should have full permission to scout high school athletes prior to graduation. Scouting does not entail actually talking with or becoming friends with the player an...read more

  • 4 of 18

    by The Mom

    As a parent of an athlete / student, I feel that the opportunities available after high school should definitely be presented to students and parents. Having a child athlete...read more

  • 5 of 18

    by W Lowe

    Now this is a real give and go situation its hard to breakdown and vote for either side cause I see the advantages and disadvantages,but if you really stop and think about you w...read more

  • 6 of 18

    by A. P. Littleton

    NBA coaches should be allowed to recruit student athletes prior to graduation. There will inevitably be some high schoolers who are far superior in sheer talent and basketball ...read more

  • 7 of 18

    by TheTruth

    People will say this is insanity, but I say why not? Does it really hurt a child to have a coach look in on how their career in high school is playing out? Of course not. People...read more

  • 8 of 18

    by Erich Heinlein

    I think if a player is good enough to go to the NBA a player should be recruited by a scout. But not until his senior year. I think the NBA needs to at least make it a requireme...read more

  • 9 of 18

    by Phil Hill

    Turning a top athlete into a world class one takes time. Talent needs to be spotted young and then pushed in the right direction. It is not something that happens overnight. So ...read more

  • 10 of 18

    by Rex Teodosio

    Why not. The underlying question of this debate is the importance of a completed higher education. In today's world, especially with today's educational institution, it's ...read more

  • 11 of 18

    by Jaskaran Sangha

    Nba coaches have come a long way within the last few years. From the Phil Jackson days to the Sam Mitchell days there have been many changes. Coaches should be allowed to scout ...read more

  • 12 of 18

    by B. B. James

    Absolutely, NBA coaches should be allowed to have contact with student athletes who are in high school. The reason for this is that NBA coaches are better than the leeches who ...read more

  • 13 of 18

    by Brian Williams

    Athletes at any age should have the opportunity to participate in a paying sport. It's important to understand age discrimination. When we grow old, we are a threat to ju...read more

  • 14 of 18

    by Jamestowncalif.com

    Game 5 of the Eastern Conference Finals by jamestowncalif.com Sports 06/03/07 11:50:57 pm Sports News Sports Report: Lebron James and the Cavs Are on a Roll by jamestown...read more

  • 15 of 18

    by Dion Johnson

    It would appear that they should be able to, because they are going to do it in a form or another anyway. It may not be directly, but there are so many different avenues that th...read more

  • 16 of 18

    by Guy on the Internet

    NBA coaches should be allowed to recruit student athletes prior to high school graduation. Many athletes reach their prime at a very young age. Some these athletes burnout in ...read more

  • 17 of 18

    by Pat -Cricket- Jones

    I think that coaches should be allow to recruit student athletes prior to high school graduation. First lets face the fact that if some kids go to college, they are just takin...read more

  • 18 of 18

    by David Duncan

    NBA Coaches should be allowed to recruit student athletes. However, I believe they should be making their recruiting decisions with the help of parents, teachers, and high scho...read more

Join the Debate now.
Write your point of view.

  • 1 of 19

    by Jay Nolan

    There is no way NBA coaches should be allowed to go anywhere near high school athletes. Fortunately the current Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) prevents high school athlet...read more

  • 2 of 19

    by Zach Bigalke

    Given the current rule in the NBA that forbids any player entering the league prior to their nineteenth birthday or until they are one year removed from high-school graduation, ...read more

  • 3 of 19

    by Alexander Petrucelli

    The LeBron James story is one for the ages, but not every basketball athlete will follow in his footsteps. With that said, basketball athletes need to learn to harness their ego...read more

  • 4 of 19

    by butler123

    No, they should definitely not. Because of the new rule banning players making the jump from high school to the pros, there is no need for NBA coaches to talk with high school p...read more

  • 5 of 19

    by Julio Viskovich MBA

    Whether NBA coaches should be allowed to recruit high school players is a topic of great debate within basketball circles world wide. After all, some of the greatest players in ...read more

  • 6 of 19

    by James Clark

    Excuse me, but has the basketball world gone mad? Maybe the NBA would like to be known as the next thing to ruining sports as a recreational past time for kids that would rathe...read more

  • 7 of 19

    by Burt Steel

    No, NBA coaches should not be allowed to scout student athletes for various reason. One high schoolers cant come into the NBA anyway there is no need to scout them now. Studen...read more

  • 8 of 19

    by Master Turtle

    NBA TEAMS (coaches do not have sole responsibility in the draft) should be allowed to recruit any player they wish. To disallow a team from using a draft pick solely on age ofte...read more

  • 9 of 19

    by Ronnie Plaiscia Jr.

    I do not think it is fair to deprive high school students of much needed education. It is already a bad enough distraction to most students to be skilled at any given sport, but...read more

  • 10 of 19

    by Torry Jones

    NBA coaches and scouts should not be allowed to recruit athletes before high school graduation. The one thing that prevents them from doing this is the age limit set by the NBA ...read more

  • 11 of 19

    by Greg Palmer

    NBA coaches should not be allowed to recruit high-school athletes prior to the students graduation. The students do not need even more stress and decisions put on them on top of...read more

  • 12 of 19

    by John Neice

    When proffessional NBA coaches start involving themselves in recruiting high school students before graduation it is going to cause nothing but problems. I dont beleive high sch...read more

  • 13 of 19

    by Liana Campbell

    I don't believe coaches of any sport should be able to recruit student athletes prior to high school graduation, and if you are a fan of the movie Coach Carter you would underst...read more

  • 14 of 19

    by Mighty-Pen

    The NBA has already tried that experiment and it was not successful. I won't say it failed, because it wasn't a disaster, but it had its flaws. I know this is America the ...read more

  • 15 of 19

    by Michael Allen Carvell

    No basket ball coach's should scout players before they graduate high school there are not enough spots for the kids that quit their education to try out for professional basket...read more

  • 16 of 19

    by David Tarsitano

    I have gone back and forth on where I stand with this issue. On the one hand in baseball they draft players when they are 16, but they also have a farm system with multiple lev...read more

  • 17 of 19

    by Tori Somerville

    I do not feel that NBA coaches should be able to scout student athletes prior to high school graduation because with the prospect of being in the NBA the judgment of the student...read more

  • 18 of 19

    by Jonathan Stilley

    Absolutely not. One reason that the NBA coaches should not be allowed to recruit high schoolers is because the kids are just plain not mature enough to handle making an adult...read more

  • 19 of 19

    by Chels

    No NBA coach should be allowed to recruit student athletes if in high school, even if they are graduating. Those young adults need the chance to go to college and find themselve...read more

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10

What is Helium? | User Guide | Community | Link to Helium | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA