Search Helium

Home > Politics, News & Issues > International Politics > War & Peace

We should be focusing military efforts on the Taliban, Al Qaeda and drugs in Afghanistan, not in Iraq

Results so far:

Agree
72% 343 votes Total: 478 votes
Disagree
28% 135 votes

Agree

by V. Kumar

Created on: June 05, 2007

If the recent events in Pakistan are any indication, the Taliban is far from dead, and the place from where Al Qaida may rise again is between Afghanistan and Pakistan.

There are some who take Nostradamus seriously, and though I am not one of them, I can not but agree with them that war on Iraq is just a small battle in a much larger conflict. What begun as 9/11 was thought to have been solved with attack on Taliban in Afghanistan, but the subsequent events have raised very very serious questions about the way this whole thing is being comprehended. Today, Iraq is burning, Iran is threatening and Afghanistan remains on the edge. If that is not enough, we have surging Islamic terrorists not only in countries like Thailand and Philippines, but also in many Islamic countries as well.

It is time to reconsider if our focus has left a blind spot somewhere. Right after 9/11, everybody knew that Afghanistan was the center of those threatening US and Anglo-Saxon civilization in the name of Islam. In subsequent years. Taliban was displaced but could not be destroyed, and inadvertently the root of the problem was left to survive. What we are seeing today are some signs of its renewed growth and spread.

Afghanistan's geo-political location makes it the single most important place in the world. It is a bridge between two Muslim civilizations. On its West is the whole of Middle East, the heart of Islamic culture, the holy places, and the major petro reserves that directly or indirectly finance the anti US terrorist groups too. On its East live the majority of largely liberal Muslim populations of the world, in South Asia and South East Asia. Afghanistan is the bridge between the two not only in terms of culture but also in terms of ideologies, sentiments and identities. Its militant history since the invasion of Alexander in fourth century BC makes it a unique bastion of courage, resistance and determination, qualities that are being brilliantly exploited today in the name of religion. No wonder then, that even after the devastation it faced post 9/11, Afghanistan continues to serve as the headquarters for all such forces.

The new center of gravity in this struggle has now emerged at the Afghan Pakistan border, and engulfed the North West Frontier Province. Events in the recent past show how little control any government has in this region, and how much the Taliban have rejuvenated. While they keep a low profile, and improve their networks with the rest of the world, both on East and West, the threats to US and many other countries in the world continue to rise. They can not attack US, but with their networks, it is next to impossible to prevent them from infiltrating. They have mastered the art of proxy war just too well. The only way to dislodge them is an all out open attack, for which military offensive will only be a small part. The main target need to be the networks created by them.

It is not that Iraq is not important, but violence there is running today in the form of a self-sustaining vicious cycle of destruction, that is receiving its impetus from outside. Fighting the symptoms may be important, but attacking the root cause is always the most effective strategy.

Learn more about this author, V. Kumar.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

Disagree

by David Kramer

Created on: December 08, 2007

Someone once said, "A great deal of what you see depends on what you are looking for." We are at war people! We only know what we have been told and to make assumptions or decisions based on limited information is a certain formula for losing a war.

There is much debate on where we should be focusing our military efforts. The question of whether we should be in Iraq when there is much yet to be done with Al Qaeda, the Taliban, and drugs in Afghanistan is one example. The news media, which now focuses on sensationalizing stories to sell airtime to advertisers, is going to purposefully stir up controversy for profit.

There are, however, still many sources of news that are unbiased and void of bringing two opposing views together so the one who is more skilled at debate can appear to have the right view. Turn off the TV and Radio. Talk to those who have been in the war zones.

Some will explain the atrocities committed by the former leadership in Iraq. Man-made lakes drained in search of weapons of mass destruction only to find thousands of bodies of young females pulled from college; raped, and murdered are some of them.

It is easy for the mainstream news media to bash a president and administration, especially in a nation where short-term memory is very short. It was both political parties that brought us into Iraq in the first place. Was the evidence insufficient or wrong? We will never know that answer.

The point is, we have a very limited perspective behind what goes on behind closed doors in Washington D.C. or the global arena. Not everything is published because during war information is critical. Disinformation is also a powerful too during these times.

At some point the people of this great nation of the United States must quit the political games and stand behind and trust the leadership or simply vote them out of office. This is not to say mistakes have not been made, or everything has been justifiably executed, but rather its time to stop debating it and to start taking action.

Should the U.S. military be better used fighting the Taliban, Al Qaeda, or drugs in Afghanistan? The answer is unknown and will likely be unknown for years to come.

Rather than debate the issue, take a stand and take action. Support the troops, blindly trust the existing leaders, write your representatives in leadership, run for office, vote, report fact, something that involves action instead of a separate war through endless debate over philosophical differences based on limited information.

Learn more about this author, David Kramer.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA