Home > Health & Fitness > Diets > Diet & Weight Loss
Results so far:
| Exercise | 45% | 30 votes | Total: 66 votes | |
| Dieting | 55% | 36 votes |
Exercise
Created on: October 01, 2011 Last Updated: October 02, 2011
It is no coincidence that “diet” is a four-letter word. Those planning to partake in a diet should heed the caveats of feeling deprived, nutrient restrictions and yo-yo tendencies associated with certain weight-loss programs. Certain diet programs—particularly those touted by entertainment media and celebrities—not only leave individuals feeling deprived but pose serious health risks.
Diets known as “cleanses” have been peddled as a way to not only drop weight quickly, but as a detoxifying formula to bolster health and immunity. The Master Cleanse" is a diet that actress and singer Beyonce Knowles made headlines for using to lose 20 pounds for her role in the hit movie “Dreamgirls”. Such a rapid weight loss may seem unfathomable until reviewing the stipulations of such a diet. According to MSNBC, this particular cleanse is "...a starvation diet whose adherents swallow nothing but a concoction of lemon juice mixed with maple syrup, water and cayenne pepper, as well as salt water and a laxative tea for 10 days." The dangers of such restriction outweigh the benefits of shedding some love handles.
Most diets are not nearly as extreme as cleansing. However, all diet programs designed to shed weight quickly involve some sort of food group restriction. According to Dietitian Lisa Di Fazio, when food intake becomes restrictive, “The main nutrients that are lacking are potassium, iron, B-12, vitamins A & C." According to the American Dietetic Association, a healthy diet can be achieved by choosing a variety of foods in accordance with the five basic food groups of the food pyramid (grains, fruits, vegetables, meats and dairy).
Other risks involved in dieting involve the proliferation of body image issues resulting from a preoccupation with weight. According to the National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI), restrictive dieting and preoccupation with weight and body image are often precursors for eatings disorders like anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa. Echoing those sentiments, the National Eating Disorders Association (NEDA) notes that there are "…as many as 10 million females and 1 million males [in the United States]...fighting a life and death battle with an eating disorder such as anorexia or bulimia." Up to 20% of individuals with eating disorders are college students. Eating disorders are considered the most deadly of all psychological disorders and the secretive nature that most often accompanies eating disorders like anorexia and bulimia makes them all the more deadly.
If an individual desires weight loss at the request of a physician and not for cosmetic reasons, approaching nutrition through a lifestyle perspective—where one aims to consume food in ways outlined by the USDA’s guidelines—as opposed to going on a fad diet, they will be provided with results that are long-lasting and avoids the risks associated with yo-yo dieting.
Good nutrition cannot maintain health alone. A sedentary lifestyle increases health risks and can also lead to emotional ailments such as stress and lack of motivation (Insel and Roth 2010). By exercising regularly, individuals can decrease stress, improve immune system health and maintain an ideal body weight. One does not have to run a triathlon or qualify for Olympic gold to maintain health and weight. Reasonable amounts of exercise involve 30 minutes of moderate exercise each day (such as walking) and a total of 75 minutes of intense exercise.
Sources:
Back to Basics for Healthy Weight Loss. Eat Right. American Dietetic Association. n.d. (accessed May 17, 2011) Insel, Paul M, and Walton T Roth. Core Concepts in Health Eleventh Edition. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2010. Learn basic terms and information on a variety of eating disorder topics. National Eating Disorders Association NEDA. n.d. (accessed May 15, 2011) Mental Illnesses. NAMI National Alliance on Mental Illness. n.d. (accessed May 15, 2011) Moores, Susan R.D. "Experts warn of detox diet dangers." Chew On This MSNBC.com. May 18, 2007. (accessed May 16, 2011)
Learn more about this author, Tracy Dye.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Dieting
Created on: October 20, 2011
While it is true that exercise and diet always comes along together, one can't deny the fact that most obese people overlook the very reason why they fail in their very goal of losing weight.
Before concluding what plays the key role in weight loss, there are two main equations one might want to take a closer look at :
* Exercise = energy expenditure
* Diet = energy source for proper nourishment
So how does exercise help in weight loss?
Many people would definitely agree that exercise would really nail your extra pounds away. It's a fact, extra energy when unused is stored as fats and eventually adds up to one's weight. When one performs sets of exercises, the body uses up all the energy it needs to perform such physical activities and when it has consumed most of it, it gets to use extra stored energy and eventually burns fats. That's simply how it works.
Now what causes someone to earn extra pounds in the first place?
The most effective way of solving a problem is finding the root cause of it and eliminating / controlling or preventing it. In the same way, understanding the system how the body gains weight is a "must know" thing not only for overweight people but for those targeting a specific body form they want. We eat food for energy and we quantify it through calories. Take a closer look at the figures.
Fat: 1 gram = 9 calories
Protein: 1 gram = 4 calories
Carbohydrates: 1 gram = 4 calories
Food consists mainly of fat, protein and carbohydrates. Notice why food high in fat makes you gain more weight - because just one gram already has 9 calories! So if one takes in food adequately and not "excessively", gaining weight is less likely to be a problem. Dieting doesn't mean depriving oneself of this and that or whatever you want to eat. It's nourishing your body with the right nutrients you need.
So how does proper diet outweigh exercise?
Most people concentrate on strenuous exercises and yet stick to eating the usual "all-you-can-eat" routine. This method results to a continuous loop of loosing and gaining weight until nothing happens and all the efforts exerted are wasted.
Proper diet on the other hand plays the key role where the source energy itself is controlled. Consume calories more than what you need and you gain more weight. Consume adequate calories for your daily needs and you'll relevantly get the weight that you want.
Learn more about this author, Roel Soriano.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.