Home > Politics, News & Issues > US Law & Justice > Justice System
Results so far:
| Yes | 68% | 185 votes | Total: 271 votes | |
| No | 32% | 86 votes |
Yes
Created on: July 24, 2011 Last Updated: July 26, 2011
Racial profiling, to an extent, is necessary for the efforts of homeland security to be effective. Racial profiling is most effective in the sense that officers would be able to easily identify potential foreign criminals and threats to the United States. In present time, our greatest foreign threats come from the drug trade with Mexico, and threats from Middle Eastern extremists. In addition, some may either argue that we live in a so-called "colorblind society", or that we should adapt all policies to fit such a philosophy.
First and foremost, many Americans realize that there is the issue of immigration and a drug trade with Mexico. U.S. Border Patrol within the States bordering Mexico deal with smugglers on a daily basis, and know who to look for. Now, picture a Mexican man and the average American white male. Anyone can easily make distinctions between the two men. Border Patrol knows who to look for, because most of the drug smugglers are Mexican.
Thus, if racial profiling is used, officers will be able to identify smugglers much more easily. In addition to this, there is also there major issue of immigration with Mexico. Each day, dozens or Mexicans cross the United States-Mexican border illegally various reasons. There have been several news-breaking instances with Mexican immigrants, especially in Arizona, that have been affiliated with racial profiling. In 2010, out of Arizona's population of approximately 6.6 million people, an estimated amount of 500,000 were said to be illegal immigrants. In order to decrease these numbers, racial profiling would be necessary, so that illegal immigrants do not take up residency in United States territory.
Mexico is not the only foreign threat. There are still threats towards the United States from Middle Eastern extremists. As you may recall, airports have recently begun to search every man, woman, and child for explosives and other sorts of weaponry. Because of these measures, airports are becoming increasingly unpopular. The TSA (Transportation Security Administration) has created policies that slow down airports in order to search everyone. However, many of these threats are made by Middle Eastern extremists, not the average looking American citizen. The TSA does not discriminate, which seems fair, but it severely hinders the efficiency of airports. Most suspects in bombing threats and attempts are either distinctly Middle Eastern or occasionally African.
To conclude, a bit of racial profiling would be necessary to make homeland security more effective. If homeland security would look for Mexicans or Middle Easterners more frequently, daily life could possibly be more convenient for the American citizen, while potential foreign threats and criminals may be dealt with more effectively.
Learn more about this author, Dr. Knowitall.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
No
Created on: July 25, 2011
Racial profiling, like torture, is an illegal and reprehensible practice that needs to be stamped out with gusto. Any Homeland Security officials who engage in racial profiling should be investigated with the possible consequence of losing their job and privileges for life.
There is no security that can be obtained through the practice of singling out anyone for scrutiny or harassment because of their race, appearance or ethnicity.
Racial profiling is a complete fraud because all of the racial and ethnic groups in the United States are hosting individuals who have both the potential and the desire to commit acts of terrorism, mass killing, treason and violence.
If racial profiling was a legitimate practice in support of a legitimate agenda, then White people would be as likely as any other ethnicity to be yanked out of line, searched, harassed and investigated.
Yet Homeland Security is suspiciously unlikely to racially profile for White supremacists, homegrown terrorists, powerful drug cartels, or psychotics who are as much a threat as anyone else on the planet.
The Oklahoma city bombing victims, the neighbors of the rising number of right wing extremists and psychotics who follow a violent agenda, and the most recent victims of the Oslo Norway attacks could easily confirm that racial profiling would be a stupid waste of time and money, especially if the goal is to prevent more terrorist attacks or mass killings on US soil or elsewhere.
Americans and citizens of other nations need to wake up and realize that only so many freedoms are water soluble. Once the serious freedoms are willingly given up under the misguided belief that "the latest security plot will not affect me or mine", then it will be too late for anyone to stop a downward spiral into erosion of all freedoms and rights.
In a diverse society, the society thrives in a circular fashion because of the diversity of thoughts, capacities, gene pools and cultural contributions. But when a small segment of the population gains excessive media attention, wields excessive influence and power over government, or threatens violence in exchange for undeserved, unearned and superior rights and privileges, it is time for a major backlash by the majority of the diverse population.
The bottom line is that Homeland Security is inherently incompetent and ineffective if the agency has to violate the constitution and break the law based on the demands of the same hysterical political extremists who are the real threat to American security interests.
This is not the time to tolerate easily abused security tactics that target specific people based on ethnicity or appearance. If such a program is already going on, then national security is already is already so compromised that there is no security to begin with.
The Homeland Security agency should actually be dissolved and reorganized into a much more accountable, leaner, less self serving, and much more rational security force that answers to all Americans, and this should be done before it is too late.
Learn more about this author, Elizabeth M Young.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.