Search Helium

Home > Relationships & Family > Communication > Communication Issues

Should couples discuss everything?

Results so far:

Yes
57% 40 votes Total: 70 votes
No
43% 30 votes

Yes

by F.J. Sharp

Created on: September 12, 2011   Last Updated: September 14, 2011

Should couples discuss everything? This is surely just one of those questions to which there can never be a definitive answer. Every couple is different, and while some may choose to communicate every tiny detail of their respective days, others are more than happy to maintain a comfortable silence, perhaps seeking to leave some of the 'mystery' within their relationship.

Rather the real point of debate should not be whether couples 'should' discuss everything, but whether an individual, as one half of a couple CAN discuss everything with their partner.

Many people may feel, due to a number of factors such as cultural influence, religion, upbringing and so forth, that it is simply not appropriate to discuss certain matters with a partner or spouse. This is quite understandable, however a reluctance to broach a certain subject with a partner for fear of repercussions could reasonably indicate a serious underlying problem in the relationship itself. At the risk of playing devil's advocate... consider the following example:

A couple have been married for some 20 years. In this time, the female partner has never ever discussed anything pertaining to 'women's problems'. This may seem unremarkable to some, but consider what this lady's reasons may be for withholding such information from the person with whom she is sharing the majority of her life? Is it simply because both partners consider that this is something which is 'just not done'? Is it due in part to embarrassment? Or has the woman simply resigned herself to the fact that her husband simply does not care and is likely to make matters worse rather than better?

This example shows how the motives for not discussing certain topics can range from the perfectly reasonable (embarrassment on a personal level) to something more sinister (possibility of sexism or an underlying problem with the marriage itself).

A rather extreme example perhaps, but when we consider the scope of discussing 'everything' we must be reasonable. In general terms, most people would interpret discussing everything with a partner as the discussion of everyday common issues, problems and news and so forth, not to mention practical considerations such as home finances, raising children and everything which is entailed in a partnership.

In conclusion, it is my humble opinion not that couples SHOULD discuss everything, but that couples SHOULD BE ABLE TO discuss everything and, indeed, anything. If not, then maybe the real question should be 'Should you really be part of this couple at all?'


Learn more about this author, F.J. Sharp.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

by Maria Yanicki

Created on: July 28, 2011

People think that everything down to the last detail needs to be discussed, and in my view, this is just not true. This is also what most men think, and even though I am a woman and as such, I feel a need to "talk" it out, some things just don't need to be said.

Do I really need to know where he's been all day, what he did at work/school, what he had for lunch? No. The little, everyday things don't need to be discussed. It's nice if he tells me on his own, but there's enough trust there that he doesn't need to be tracked.

So what about the big stuff? Who should manage the finances, buying a house, or moving to a different state? Sure, those need to be discussed. As a woman with traditional values, however, I'll let my man bring it up first. If he doesn't, too bad. We're staying in the house we have. He didn't say anything, so I figure we're staying here. Discussions, I believe, are things my man should initiate. I will always do my own thing, and if he talks to me, that's great. I'll drop what I'm doing and switch hats, from masculine (doing) to feminine (feeling). And I'll listen, I'll be as soft and self-aware (this is important) as can be, and present my ideas when he's finished talking in a calm, stately manner. It's important to listen to him as he's speaking, and be self-aware. If he doesn't offer you the same courtesy and walks away, tell him the next time you see him that you feel (present tense) very upset about before. Don't blame him, because he'll probably stop listening.

So what if you need to be the bigger person, and start the discussion first? How do you go about doing that? Starting a discussion on your own because it's bothering you is very different from just starting one because it might be needed. I'll still wait for him to approach me. When he does, I will tell him how I feel at the present moment, and tell him what's bothering me, trying my best to exclude the word "you", because usually that means you're blaming him. For some reason, men don't like to be blamed for anything, even if they're wrong! So the only way to get them to listen is to present it without blaming him. Perhaps you're trying to tell him that you need a lift to the garage because your car is done being fixed, and he's taking his sweet time. The next time he talks to you, wait for an opening, and tell him how you feel. It could be, "I feel confused because my car needs to be picked up from the garage." or "I feel upset because my car is fixed but it's not here." And then I'll usually ask him, this is what I would say, is "What do you think?"

That last part is important, because it invites him to express himself without worrying about criticism. It's really important not to criticize him. You'll probably get an urge to do so. Acknowledge it, and let it go. Nothing will make him stop listening to you faster than a barrage of criticisms on what he thinks.

After he expresses what he thinks, acknowledge it, and then ask him whatever you wanted to ask or tell him. "I need you to take me to the garage now."

That's it. It's not a big deal to discuss things with your partner, no big story. It's when the lady starts yelling that an argument starts. If the guy starts yelling at you, just say "I don't want to argue with you" and walk away. It's that simple. He'll eventually get the hint and go away until you're both calm enough to talk.

Point of this article being, yes, you should discuss things. But in a certain way, and only about certain things, mainly, the things that bother you. If things need to be spoken about and it's bothering you that he hasn't brought it up yet, say that. Express yourself. No relationship moves without a bit of well-meaning conversation. It's the way you converse that makes the difference.

Learn more about this author, Maria Yanicki.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA