Search Helium

Home > Arts & Humanities > Philosophy > Ethics

Is it acceptable to rejoice at the death of a human being, however evil they may have been?

Results so far:

Yes
42% 38 votes Total: 90 votes
No
58% 52 votes

Yes

by Anthony Megna

Created on: May 06, 2011   Last Updated: November 22, 2011

This whole title relates to the killing of Osama Bin Laden. It's a difficult thought to digest, rejoicing at the killing of a human being, even someone as evil as him. But the fact remains that people are thrilled with the result of his demise. Let's look a bit deeper into the issue.....

The amount of pain and agony this one man has caused throughout the world puts him on par with Hitler. Although Hitler may have exterminated more people, the sheer terror that Bin Laden and his minions have caused doesn't make him any less evil. So the fact remains that many, many people around the world are very happy he's gone.

How can people rejoice with the killing, the assassination of another human being? Looking at the question framed in the context of war makes it a bit easier to digest. The United States, as well as many other countries are at war with Al Qaeda, and achieving a victory such as the death of the enemy's leader will cause celebration. Even though another human being is dead, and will never take another breath, his terror has diminished, at least for the terror that he orchestrated. Maybe someone else will step into his shoes, but it's awfully difficult to imagine another human being that can be so horrific! I know they exist, and that is reality, but I believe rejoicing at his demise is important, not only for America, but for the world.

It's important to realize that it's not the death of another human being that is being rejoiced as much as what he stood for. Bin Laden had made it very clear, crystal clear, that he wanted to kill as many Americans as humanly possible. Let's repeat that statement...Bin Laden wanted to KILL as many Americans as humanly possible! Should we be sad that he's gone? This piece of trash deserves what he got, and there are many people who would stand in line to pull the trigger that one of our Navy Seals so bravely did. We are rejoicing the fact that his "mission statement", if you will, has failed. That is what people are rejoicing, not the fact that he won't be able to live another day. Even though that is part of it, his not living another day on this Earth. The main point is that we achieved an extremely big victory in the war against terror.

Unfortunately, there are thousands of people who died on 9/11, and many thousands more that were related to those who did. They are rejoicing with Bin Laden's death, they are certainly not sad about it. This is the reality that we all have to live with each and every day of our lives. Is it a bad thing to celebrate? We didn't ask for this war, it came to us, so if one of my loved ones died on that infamous day, then yes, I would be celebrating even more than I am today.....

Learn more about this author, Anthony Megna.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

by Dexter Dextrose

Created on: May 03, 2011

As a human, death is an ultimate and inevitable consequence. There is no way to dodge the end of one's life, nor can one predict when that fateful day will arrive. As such, death should be treated with an air of respect and solemnity, or, at the very least, a cognizance of its finality. Taking pleasure in the end of another human's life is akin to wielding the sickle yourself. It is a primal, visceral response lacking the trappings of reason and humanity. To be fair, there are many people this Earth would almost certainly be better off without, at least at face value. However, regardless of how evil or wicked a person is, rejoicing in their death is never a good thing. The old adage, "Two wrongs don't make a right" rings like a bell of righteousness in this scenario.

By relishing in the fall of another, one is actually contributing to their own demise. To say that it is good that someone else has died is to ignore that which separates humans from animals. The vengeful soul that celebrates the death of Osama bin Laden does not much differ from the lion who rejoices in a fresh kill. The lone difference is that the lion killed to survive, while the human merely takes pleasure in what he or she feels is right and just. However, life is a precious and delicate balance, one that should not lend itself to vigilantism, but one that should be held with gentle hands. This is not to say that someone who is a threat to the overall well being of the human race should be allowed freedom to continue to harm, but it is to suggest that when such a person meets their end, it should not be viewed as a cause for celebration.

Instead of celebrating when an evil person passes, humans should reflect on their own lives. Reflect on what we are doing wrong and try to remedy it while we are still alive. Humans should also reflect on what is being done right, and try wholeheartedly to encourage its continuity. These are two productive measures one can take in the wake of another's death. Reveling in someone else's decease accomplishes nothing of a positive nature. It does, however, serve to commemorate the wicked individual of whom the celebrators are happy to have seen pass. It provides for an environment where these people can focus on negative aspects of a negative person. There is absolutely no way such behavior can breed anything but further negativity. Such negativity may not be immediately obvious, but it will find it's way into the fragile balance of this world somehow.

Death is something that every human fears, whether or not they will admit to it. It is something everyone must face. It is cyclic and unknown, much like many other aspects of the universe we reside in. Instead of rejoicing in the death of a wicked individual, humans should rejoice in the remaining life we have left. Use the time in a way that creates a better world, no matter how small of a step one takes. A million tiny positive steps are much better than a million vengeful jeers.  


Learn more about this author, Dexter Dextrose.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA