Home > Pets & Animals > Pet Ownership
Results so far:
| Yes | 73% | 113 votes | Total: 154 votes | |
| No | 27% | 41 votes |
Yes
Created on: August 17, 2011
If you have lost your dog you may be wondering if it is right to replace it, or not. To be totally fair, the word “replace” is not a good word to use here, you can replace an old car, you cannot replace a pet. As such it is better to look at it as though you are getting a new dog, rather than replacing a previous one.
The loss of a beloved dog leaves a hole in its owner's heart. If you have lost a dog you probably feel as though you want to fill that hole but may have some guilt. You need not worry, dogs are pack animals, they know how important companionship is. If it were possible to find out what your dog would have wanted, very likely he, or she, would have wanted you to have another companion.
When to Get a New Dog
The trick to getting a new dog, after the death of another one, is not to rush it. You must allow time for yourself to grieve. The grieving period can be different for each person. Only you will know when you are ready to get a new dog. For some people this might be within a week, for others it could be a couple of months.
Before you Get a New Dog
If your dog passed away from a contagious illness, such as parvovirus, it is very important to take the time to clean your home and yard. Bleach is an effective cleaning agent against most viruses, but you can also talk to your veterinarian about any other cleaning tips they may have. If you had a wooden dog house, it should be destroyed, and all plastic bowls, and toys that cannot be washed, should be thrown out.
What Dog to Get
While you may want to rush out and get one that looked just like the one you lost, this is not a good idea. If you get a dog that looks too much like the one you lost you may find yourself unfairly comparing it to your deceased companion. You should select one that is either a different breed, different color, or at least a different gender, from the dog you had previously.
If you lost your dog due to illness you will want to make sure any new dog you bring into your home is fully vaccinated first.
New Dog
When you have your new dog do not consider it as a replacement for the one you lost. You will always have memories of your earlier dog, and now have a new dog to build new memories with. Remember that this new dog is not the same as the one you lost. It does not know the same things your last dog knows, and will be unfamiliar with your expectations for it. Try to find some ways to bond with it, such as going to obedience lessons, or playing in the park. Remember every dog is different, love this one for who it is rather than always comparing it to the one you lost.
Learn more about this author, Brenda Nelson.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
No
Created on: March 18, 2011
Should You Replace Your Dog After It Dies?
When a beloved pet dog dies, one must take the time to mourn the passing of the family pet. To a lot of people, a dog is considered a close member of the family who cannot be so easily replaced. Some families even go to the point of having a private mourning ceremony to bury the dog, complete with a prayer and a grave marker. In some cities there are pet cemeteries that offer you a final resting place for your dog's remains. This can be an alternative when there are rules and laws about pet burial, if you are a renter, do not have a yard or are not physically able to dig the necessary depth needed to keep other animals from digging up your pet's remains.
To some people, dogs are considered man's best friend. The thought of replacing their pet dog can give them the feeling they are being disrespectful to the memory of the special bonding times they spent with their dog through the years. Just like when a human family member passes away, each dog is unique. Finding one with the same type personality may hard to find. Since all dogs have different personalities, their reaction to the same situation will vary. This is why a person or family must take the time to complete the mourning process before even thinking of getting another dog. Otherwise, they will always be comparing the new dog to the dog who passed on.
One way to enjoy the company of a dog when one dog passes on is to have two dogs with at least five years difference in age. Some people believe this helps soften the grieving time. Of course you must be able to take care of the dogs personal and medical needs to do this. Veternarian medical bills can put a large dent in the family budget.
Though my first reaction was a definite no to the question of replacing the family pet dog after it has passed on, I now feel after an appropriate length of time of completing the grieving process it would be acceptable. Just be sure the family is in agreement that the timing is right to do this. Be sure to include the feelings of any other household pets, especially cats. Some cats can be quite territorrial about accepting a new dog into the family group.
Learn more about this author, Carolyn Teasley.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.