Search Helium

Home > Relationships & Family > Dating > Dating Psychology

Is jealousy a proof of love?

Results so far:

Yes
38% 150 votes Total: 390 votes
No
62% 240 votes

Yes

by N. Owen Holme

Created on: November 12, 2011   Last Updated: April 27, 2012

If you are willing to consider that love is the state in life to which you are committed and attached to preserving, protecting, attaining or reacquiring a close relationship, then jealousy definitely proves love. While I am no psychologist, I have come to believe that emotions, including jealousy, are the prompts which drive our behavior. Without a profound link to something we care about, often deeply, a feeling like jealousy can never manifest or be acted upon. Look within. Have you ever been jealous over something you cared nothing about?

The problems associated with jealousy are not from the emotion itself, but in the thought processes which are the poisonous environment it needs to grow. At its base is the real or imagined threat of loss, essentially grief. This is especially evident in children and toddlers with their mothers. Children are heavily dependent for their personal welfare on their parents. They seem fanatical and histrionic if that continued support appears to be threatened by a parent's absence, lack of attention or attention given to a sibling. The panic they feel to their continued ability to survive by themselves manifests as jealous behavior.  As most people mature, they no longer feel threatened by extinction if mother isn't near and on call just for us.

There's another facet to the jealousy urge that lingers much longer into adults: the desire to control. The impulse to control fertilizes adult jealousy as surely as threat of loss is its soil. The control urge is still wrapped up in a survival strategy that perceives the loss of a specific intimacy as death. The feelings can't make the fine distinctions, only the thoughts. The control aspect is driven by foreshadowing and getting in front of the loss, thus preventing it. The sense of impending loss can also be driven by perceived changes in the quality of an intimate relationship and jealous behavior will try to prevent inevitable changes. If jealous behavior shows up as sulking, pouting or pleading, it can be perceived as weak. This can drive escalating behavior.

Without doubt, the most harmful and potentially life-threatening manifestations of jealousy are those which are retributive and punishing by intention.  Threats are made, abuse is common in all its forms and sometimes stalking occurs with all the menace that that entails. By the above definition, this still proves love, but it isn't a love that anybody wants. Our toxic plant is now a tangled, massive mess. 

And avoidable. By a change in thinking and also telling your emotions they do not have a license to drive your life. Love, by itself, can make anyone giddy, goofy, and senseless. We automatically associate the person and the relationship with the feeling. But we become quickly lost and disoriented when the person and relationship are objectified, in our minds, made into things that are responsible agents to producing this feeling, and that without the objects, we may lose; lose our reason to live, lose our reputation, lose the justification for the time invested.

The feelings aren't the problem. The immature thinking process is. 

Learn more about this author, N. Owen Holme.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

by Roman Del Bosque

Created on: March 16, 2011

Jealousy is more a case of personal insecurity, than it is a proof of genuine love.  To genuinely love is more about letting go than holding on, more a case of giving love than receiving it, more the result of selflessness than selfishness.  Where there is jealousy, yes, there may also be genuine love; however, given time this love will eventually dissipate and disappear.  Why?  Because of the never-ending disruptive effects that toxic jealousy injects into a relationship.

 
A friend once confided, “I love my husband, but when he goes into a jealous fit, there is nothing in that moment I dislike more than my very own husband.” “I swear,” she added,  “that in such occasions there is nothing I want more than to just get it over with and leave him, but I don‘t because I love him.”


Jealousy is no more a proof of love than physical abuse is proof of caring for the one abused.  They who assert that jealousy is an integral part of a healthy relationship delude themselves.  Sadly, such individuals do not realize the venomous, destructive nature of jealousy, nor do they truly understand the correct definition of love.  Perhaps to these individuals jealousy and love are but two sides of the same coin, the yin and yang of relationships.

 
But this is not so.  Jealousy is a fungus that continues to spread and grow until it eventually chokes out the life of a relationship, bringing it first to its knees and eventually to its final end-stage as well.  Further, not only is jealousy not proof of genuine love in any relationship, it is instead the clearest precursor, evidence, that such relationship will in time crumble.

 
Jealousy has been called the “green monster.”  Let us now take this monster a step further and say that jealousy is the vine, the rope that will eventually choke the life of the relationship in which it had the unlucky misfortune of embedding itself into.  
Jealousy is destructive and selfish.  Jealousy, along with infidelity, has destroyed more marriages and relationships than anything else in our lives.  Jealousy is no proof whatsoever that you love someone or that someone loves you.  They who believe this do indeed delude themselves.

 
Finally, remember that the “green monster” that is jealousy is like a vine, a rope that in time will choke the life out of our relationships.  The only way to rid ourselves of such a monster is to stop it in its tracks whenever it appears.  When we do this, only then will our relationships have a chance to bloom to their full potential.  Is this not what we want from our relationships?


The answer is obvious.  Are we ready to heal our relationships?  Then let us get to it.  For now is the moment to begin the healing process; it is entirely in our hands.   

Learn more about this author, Roman Del Bosque.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA