Search Helium

Home > Style & Beauty > Style & Beauty (Other)

Do ultra-thin fashion models promote eating disorders in young women?

Results so far:

Yes
75% 172 votes Total: 228 votes
No
25% 56 votes

Yes

by Francesca Grace

Created on: November 07, 2010

Do ultra-thin fashion models promote eating disorders in young women? Yes. Absolutely. Let's get real; ultra-thin fashion models promote eating disorders with other ultra-thin fashion models so why wouldn't a twelve year old in Kansas City get the message that skeletal is the new look? The real question is who is creating the clothing that can only be worn by women who look like they were rescued from a prison camp?

The fashion industry is guided by the hands of fashion designers. To be blunt, there are an overwhelming number of men in the industry who are openly gay men. Their influence on the season's offerings in undeniable. They design the clothes that women end up wearing. When these men design the perfect cocktail dress, whose body do they design for; A- a curvaceous and full busted size 14 woman or a flat chested pencil think girl who could easily be mistaken for a prepubescent boy playing dress up in his mom's closet? My own gay friends are the first ones to tell you that the runway fashion we see today is a direct extension of the drag shows that were formerly underground in the gay community.  There are no curves, no breast bumps, no rear ends in high fashion. The more you look like a ten year old boy, the more money you make as a model, because the clothing is designed for that shape and that shape only. If a very skinny boy could wear it, it will show up on the runways of New York, Milan & Paris with an emaciated young woman stalking like a starving weasel down them wearing the outfit.

Versions of these drag show costumes make their way into fashion magazines that are read by innocent girls everywhere who look into their bedroom mirrors and cry because their bodies don't look the same as the dying women in the pictures. These same young girls will starve themselves, vomit up their meals, take laxatives like tic-tacs and still see their bodes as less than perfect even when their organs fail.

Not only does starving yourself to fit into the dress damage your internal organs, but these girls also damage their mental image of what it means to be a female. They are chastised by designers if their body begins to resemble a female. By starving themselves, they also cause their menstrual flow to stop, which further throws the natural state of their female bodies into a tailspin.

The fashion industry, both clothing designers and the magazines that publish photos of emaciated women must become responsible for the images they promote.  In the same way that violent song lyrics and incendiary speeches can drive people to commit violent crimes, so the fashion industry drives impressionable young girls into dangerous eating disorders and damaged self images. The industry and the magazines that make hundreds of millions of dollars every year from this business should be required to fund programs for young women with eating disorders in the same way that tobacco companies must fund stop smoking campaigns. They should have nutritionists and speakers going into schools, hosting TV programs and leading body image workshops for anyone that has been drawn into the deadly cycle of eating disorders.

Learn more about this author, Francesca Grace.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

by Janet Cipolli

Created on: November 08, 2010

I don't think it's fair to put the blame on ultra-thin models for instigating or perpetuating the affliction of eating disorders in young girls. Bulimia, or binge-eating, and anorexia are emotionally-based disorders that stem from more serious roots than Fashion Week.

We have come a long way since the 1960's when a stick figure girl from England with humongous doe-like eyes hit the magazine covers. Twiggy was the epitome of "swinging London" and with the wave of The Beatles hitting America's shores, many young girls copied her look. My friends and I grew up during that time and I don't remember any of us starving ourselves however. Yes, we copied the popular eye-makeup of Twiggy and her mod clothes but we all thought her body looked freakishly thin. To say that ultra-thin models promote eating disorders in young girls just doesn't fly-nobody walked around with the body of Twiggy, except Twiggy.

Just because designer clothes sometimes look better on a hangar than a curved and shapely body doesn't mean designers expect us to become hangars. Clothing designers prefer ultra-thin models for showcasing their designs. We've all seen a catwalk and it can't be argued that the clothes do look beautiful when worn by ultra-thin models. Designers know who the buyers are-Kate Moss isn't out shopping with young girls from your neighborhood looking for the latest Valentino dress. Those clothes from the catwalk shows are usually sold to socialites and celebrities for premieres, award shows or other red-carpet events and can often be seen wearing sizes far larger than the original.

Thanks to Tyra Banks and other current-day media, where breaking celebrity news is as frequent as local tornado warnings, our young girls see, hear and learn about the dark side of modeling. We hear about the self-abusive world of ultra-thin models and the pressure they feel to retain their stick figure. How many of them have been on television talking about drug addiction, depression and insomnia from taking speed? Many have recently and openly shared in interviews the constant struggle of wanting to freely enjoy food and pushing it away because of a high-paying modeling job.

Let's get real. Young girls who are victims of eating disorders are in need of both family and one-on-one counseling. Their eating disorder can sometimes be a control issue for them because they feel every other area of their life is uncontrollable. Some victims of this illness, and it is an illness, seek to fill an empty void in their life. A loss or deep rejection. Some have anxiety disorder which they have learned to manipulate through the use of overeating to medicate and then purging to rid away the guilt and shame.

Le's give our young girls some credit. I believe that most who suffer from an eating disorder have more serious issues going on other than  wanting to look like the skinny girl on the runway.

Learn more about this author, Janet Cipolli.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA