Home > Society & Lifestyle > Morals, Values & Norms > Morals, Values & Norms (Other)
Results so far:
| Support | 78% | 36 votes | Total: 46 votes | |
| Oppose | 22% | 10 votes |
Support
Created on: October 11, 2010
The USA has one of the highest incarceration rates in the world. 75 in every 100,000 people in the USA are in prison, and 1 in every 31 adults are on probation or in jail. That is a huge chunk of the countries adult population - the working population. The loss of these healthy and often smart people to a life that is funded by taxes is a massive economic loss.
On top of that, prison often fails to stop people from committing further crimes once they are out. By taking them out of employment, prisoners often lose work experience, skills and the self-discipline to hold down a job. A prisoner who successfully fights off a drug addiction, may emerge from prison completely unemployable despite their hard work and hopes for change. It doesn't take long before poverty and rejection send them back to prison.
Since working is therefore good for the economy and good for the prisoners, it stands to reason that letting them earn a wage - one that they can save up and help them to make a better start when they leave - can only be a good idea. Many jobs can be performed from home, and it would not take much tweaking to set up a system to help prisoners participate. Answering support calls could be a cheap way of stopping companies from shipping their call-centers abroad. Stuffing envelopes, packing boxes - the list of possible jobs goes on. Provide limited internet access, and prisoners could do even more jobs. Prisoners that were considered safe could be sent on day release to dry cleaners, warehouses, factories and so on.
Safety concerns would have to be addressed, but we already have systems in place for tracking people on probation, and these could easily be extended to prisoners on day release. A close-by factory could even have some minor security features added to make it ideal for prisoners to work there. Calls are monitored in every call-center, and one based in a prison would be no different.
The benefit for companies would a be a cheap workforce. The benefit for the state would be additional tax revenue to help off-set the cost of prisons. The benefit to the prisoner would be an income they could save or send to family on the outside, and employment for when they were released. Not to mention the less obvious but no less important benefits such as self-respect and a feeling of being a part of society.
Overall, it is easy to see why prisoners should be permitted to work and earn an income whilst in prison. The benefits far outweigh any negatives, and safety concerns can be easily addressed. Isn't it time to let this part of the population start earning a living and contributing to the country? Perhaps not all of them would take the opportunity, but enough would to make it worthwhile.
Learn more about this author, Julie Dancer.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Oppose
Created on: November 03, 2010
Really, it would be impossible for me to go along with the idea of a prisoner, who is fed and housed with my tax dollars, to earn a wage while in prison.
He/She has free food, clothing, housing, all the amenities of home and does not have to pay for a single item.
This is not in saying that there would be resentment if they wanted to learn a trade. This would most certainly help them when they are released. However, the reason for their prison term is to serve out a sentence for a crime that was commited - not earn money.
I am sure there are deals of all kinds being made in prison which constitutes the exchange of cash and money is being made every day by someone. Maybe, for a cigarette, a reefer or some other something that is needed by an in-mate that I would know nothing about.
During my work life, there were projects going on that earned money for the workers other than what they were hired to do. Nobody said anything since their salaries were nothing to holler about to begin with. Even I took on extra jobs, using company printers and computers but, using my own supplies that cost the company nothing. However, at that time, I was paying my own way - food, transportation, clothing, and whatever else was needed, plus, trying to keep the children in school. However, I was not in prison and for that I am thankful.
Even if I had gone the other way and said that I thought it was okay for a prisoner to earn money in prison, how long could that prisoner hide his money from the others to keep them from stealing it from him? It would just mean extra stress and cause fights and dissension among in-mates.
Of course, they do it but, what is there to do about it other than protest?
So, no. Let the prisoner wait and if he has extra time in prison, maybe he could help others catch up with their work and then have time for a garden or so.
We have to remember that the reason the person is in prison is pay his dues to society. If he wasn't there in the first place, he could be on the outside making true money.
Learn more about this author, Volecia Plafcan.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.