Search Helium

Home > Food & Drink > Cooking > Cookware & Cutlery

Is a bread machine worth the investment?

Results so far:

Yes
52% 384 votes Total: 737 votes
No
48% 353 votes

Yes

by Dianna Hillman Haller

Created on: October 03, 2010   Last Updated: October 05, 2010

As a traditionalist in the kitchen, I had dismissed bread makers as an unnecessary waste of valuable counter space. I began baking bread under the watchful eye of my grandmother when I was still a child. I learned to knead the soft dough thoroughly, and how the dough should feel under the palms of my hands. I learned the best ways to proof the dough in the winter, and how to check if the dough had risen properly. Gram and I made fresh breads everyday, from the occasional sandwich and hot dog buns to daily loaves of soft white bread to serve with supper and sweet sticky rolls to go with coffee at breakfast.

As I started my family I continued to make all the bread we used. There were of course those times when the dough wouldn't rise properly, I may have added a bit too much flour, or the yeast may have been a bit too old. Occasionally the hot dog buns might turn out too dense. Still, I dismissed the bread machine as a convenience for busy career people, or for those who weren't fortunate enough to have had my gram as a teacher.

Then a couple of years ago, I was looking for a specific recipe I had misplaced, when I quite accidentally came across an article on the "King Arthur Flour" web site addressing the positive characteristics of owning a bread machine. I could hardly believe my eyes, a company like this advocating bread machines. Well, I was shocked to say the least, but I read every word. Their reasons were sound and quite logical. It seems, much to my chagrin that bread machines offer a controlled environment, that would be quite impossible to recreate on a counter top. This perfect environment creates a perfectly proofed dough with each and every batch. The bread machine calls for instant dry yeast instead of the live variety. This can be stored, and used directly from the freezer, eliminating yeast problems.

Many recipes made for the bread machine needs little or no tweaking in regulating the amount of liquid to dry ingredients. So for those who would like to make a loaf or two by hand, the bread machine gives one the opportunity to experience the texture of properly mixed, kneaded, and proofed bread dough, so every loaf turns out. With the help of a bread machine even a novice cook can turn out beautiful, fragrant, flavorful breads of all types with little practice. I have found even typically denser breads, like rye or whole wheat prepared in a bread machine comes out lighter, with a tender crumb. Although, other than the hottest of summer days I rarely bake the bread in the bread machine, I always end up with perfect dough. A dough ready to be formed into rolls, pretzels, pizzas or anything else you can dream of. No more dense hot dog buns, or heavy dry sweet rolls, I can be confident that my breads will come out perfectly every time.

Learn more about this author, Dianna Hillman Haller.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

by Kate Flaxx

Created on: November 09, 2010

My bread machine sits in a cupboard.  When I think about my nice silver and black large loaf bread maker sitting by itself, lonely and in the dark, I feel a little bit sad.  Do I ever use it?  No.  Will I ever use it?  No.

My bread machine will continue to sit in the dark right next to my pie maker, another time saving and supposedly money saving item that ends up sitting alone and being forgotten about when the novelty has worn off.

It’s true that a bread maker fills your house with the lovely smell of bread baking.  It’s true that they do produce really soft and mouth-watering bread for you or your family. But does a bread maker save you money?

Unfortunately, it doesn’t and it will probably end up costing more.  Have you got a bread maker that is so clever that it makes dough for bread rolls and scrolls and even jams?  Hey, me too! Did I ever make rolls or scrolls or jams?  No. But why didn’t I do that?  Because it works out a lot cheaper if I buy already made rolls and jams and bread for that matter.

The ingredients for making bread vary so you could end up buying already made bread mixes that only allow you to add a little yeast and water or you can buy the whole list of ingredients to bake a loaf of bread in the bread maker. Buying bread mix is not a cheaper option and neither is buying the whole ingredients list to make a loaf of bread.  Both could end up costing more.

A bread maker, just the same as my poor pie maker means you have to constantly spend money on it. There is no return for this type of investment because you’re constantly paying out for its usage. The bread maker does have benefits like the lovely smell and the knowledge of exactly what ingredients are going in your bread.  But that’s where it stops for these types of machines. They don’t give any kind of return and there is no clear evidence that they save you money.

For example, I used to buy a pack of bread mix for around $17.50. Then I bought yeast at a cost of $6.00. The total cost for this was $23.50. The pack plus the yeast was enough to make around 5 loaves of bread in a bread maker. This left the cost of each loaf of bread I was making to be $4.70.  The cost was much higher when buying all the ingredients separately for the bread maker.

So back to cost, the bread maker cost $4.70 per loaf of bread using bread mix.  Meanwhile the supermarket I shop at has bread for $2.99 per loaf.   5 x $2.99 = $14.95.  That’s a saving of $8.55 in addition to the time saving process of making bread in a bread maker.  This saving represents enough money to go out and buy almost three more loaves of bread.

Will my bread maker continue to sit in the dark?  It sure will; it’s more effective as well as time saving to purchase bread.

Learn more about this author, Kate Flaxx.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA