Search Helium

Home > Society & Lifestyle > Ethnicity & Gender > Racism

Regional bigotry: Are southern white males the last acceptable target for racism?

Results so far:

Yes
44% 20 votes Total: 45 votes
No
56% 25 votes

Yes

by Heidi Peaster

Created on: April 21, 2010

I really like watching American Idol auditions.  It’s the best part of the show to me.  This year, however, there was a segment that was embarrassing to watch, and not just because the singing was not too good. 

The auditions were in Atlanta, my home town, and there was a southern man trying out.  The whole time from one commercial to the next was a spoof of the answer to the usual directive:  “Tell us a little bit about yourself”.  Yes, he talked funny, at least to anyone not from the south.  Yes, he used phrases like:  “I was limp as a dishrag” that were peculiar to our section of the country.

 But, the embarrassing part was that the judges were laughing hysterically AT him, and he knew it.  He didn’t flare up at them, he didn’t storm out ranting that he was so much better than they thought he was….he took it.  He wasn’t so stupid that he didn’t know what was going on. 

And, he did what we in the south are raised to do; he thanked them and left.

Now, I realize that the American Idol auditions have a certain amount of ridicule in them, and to be honest, I don’t think it’s all that funny to have people up in front of an audience just so they can be laughed at, but I never have seen reenactments of a person’s dialogue for fifteen minutes just for that purpose.  And, the show was able to do it because it was perfectly acceptable.  They were ridiculing a southern white male, so it was okay.

Think about it.  When a person on a TV show speaks with a southern accent, don’t we immediately realize that he is the dumb one?  If the character is in a police uniform, we know that he is a bigot and that the hero will be either: a) arrested unfairly or b) beaten up.  Southern white male characters talk about sleeping with their sisters, they wear funny clothes, drink moonshine and have their cheeks full of tobacco.

Would a person of any other ethnicity be cast as that character?  If there had been any other ethnic group consistently cast as the stupid bigot, there would be an outcry.  But if it is a southern white man, nobody minds.

The fact is that, deep in our collective American heart, we believe that southern white males deserve it.  After all, they did try to secede from the country.  They were the ones who owned slaves.  They started the Civil War.  They are the ones associated with the KKK, although that group had clusters all over the continent.  They are the ones who continue oppression and segregation and injustice.  Aren’t they?

Just because now they are in all branches of the military dying FOR that same country, just because a southern white male president signed the Civil Rights Bill into existence and just because racism is rampant in the north just as much if not more than the south these days makes no difference. 

A few weeks ago, when a black social worker wanted to come visit a client up in the hills where I work, I had to reassure her that she would be safe.  If a white person were to ask the same thing before driving into the projects downtown, they would be called a racist for voicing such a fear.

Maybe we just need somebody we can ridicule collectively.  Maybe I’m just paranoid because I live in the hills of north Georgia and know a lot of southern men who will continue to just take the ridicule because they, too, believe that they deserve it.  They will take it because they know that they are not really accepted in this country, and haven’t been for a long, long time.

 And because they know it so well, they don’t really feel a part of the American culture, anyway.

Learn more about this author, Heidi Peaster.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

by Daniel Cloud

Created on: March 21, 2011   Last Updated: March 22, 2011

Racism takes many forms, and it appears that this article is a debate about the stereotype of a white man from the Southern United States. What one would take from this article title is that it is acceptable to stereotype no one, except for southern white men. This is reverse racism, and not only does it hold back an end to racism, it creates more. Say there was a march against southern white men, and then there was a white male pride rally, similar to a black pride rally. Well, according to those who disagree with my point-of-view, it's fine to hate a white man, but it's wrong for a white man to be proud.

I am a southern white male, and according to those on the opposite side of this debate, it is fine to be racist and bigoted toward me because it is "a fact" in the minds of ignorant people that I am without a doubt a racist. Obviously without a doubt, nothing about me matters other than being a white man in a certain region of the United States. Due to my location and race, I must therefore be a racist.

As a Tennessean, I see racism all the time, but most of it is toward Mexicans from whites, blacks, Asians, and Arabs alike. This is an issue that is nationwide due to mass immigration and the belief that the illegal Mexican population are taking "jobs"  from Americans while avoiding taxes, resulting in them taking lower wages. My neighbor is a black man and he despises Mexicans, but apparently that is okay because he is a minority, right?

If I did not like Mexicans, because I am a white male and southern; I must be a racist. That is what this article title is trying to say. A more fitting name would be, "It's okay to be racist against white southern men, but everyone else is exempt." This kind of disgusting reverse racism conjures up more racism. It elevates every white man to some KKK member who is on a quest to cleanse the earth like Hitler. That is a disgusting look, and it is understandable that a white man gets mad at such a stereotype.

Proclaiming all southern white boys are KKK, assault rifle gun-toting-mob-lynch ers is a bigoted and racist view against men from the south. But this is okay, because I'm a white man, not a minority. By 2020, a white man in the United States will be a minority. Does the white man deserve special protection like other minorities then? Will it be okay to hate other races once I reach minority status? Absolutely not, and for anyone to call white men all racists is a fool.

What about the countless number of Mexican immigrants who illegally came to America and began having babies in order for their children to be born citizens. If I am against that, am I a racist against the Mexican population? No, I'd be just as bothered by Canadians doing the same thing, making me a white man racist against Canadian white men, which is ridiculous. According to the folks who believe southern white males are the last acceptable target of racism, once again are fools filled with their own racist hate.

Let's take a look at black men in the south. They comprise a large sector of the population in the Southeastern portion of the U.S. Are they racist when they call me white trash? Yes. Do I care? Not really. It doesn't affect my life in the least bit. However, if the infamous "N" word was shouted, the ACLU would be marching within 15 minutes about the plight of the black man in the south. I see black men call each other the "N" word often, and that is socially acceptable. I never see white men calling each other redneck trailor trash, but if they did, it would equate to a bigoted stereotype by "holier than thou" whites. If blacks and whites both want the illegal Mexican population to leave, then I suppose both races are also racists. However, in this politically correct world, only a white man is the racist.

In fact, since those in the "politically correct world" seem to believe that southern white men are racist, then whoever has made that distinction is now a racist against white men from the south. But of course, that is politically correct and acceptable. What will happen when the white men in the United States are a minority with regard to Latinos, African-Americans, and Asians? If these races all hate white men, is it still okay? These people would be racists, but "politically correct talk" allows for racism against white men.

Anyone who can boldy say, "Southern white males are racists" has effectively labeled themselves as a racist or bigot. So if society continues to hate "white men" for being white, then I suppose racism is alive and well in this country, but by the very people that speak out against it. There cannot be unity, when those who claim to want unity exclude a certain people. In this case, a southern white man is the "victim" of reverse racism.

Learn more about this author, Daniel Cloud.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA