Search Helium

Home > Society & Lifestyle > Cultures > Cultural Relations

Should President Obama have bowed to the Emporer of Japan?

Results so far:

Yes
59% 70 votes Total: 119 votes
No
41% 49 votes

Yes

by Sandi Crain

Created on: January 11, 2010

Although the United States and her leaders are well known for their arrogance, it is proper etiquette for President Obama to bow not just before the Emperor of Japan but before any Japanese elder while visiting their country  There's an old saying that is still relevant today:  When in Rome, do as the Romans do.  And, in Japan, bowing to one's elders is a sign of respect for the wisdom that comes with age.  The leader of any country that has ever had a friendship with Japan knows this.  They also know that not bowing to the Emperor will be seen as an insult and will not benefit the relationship between the two countries. 

Japan is a very old civilization that has kept many of its ancient traditions through some very difficult times.  Whether it was the invasion of China or the nuclear attack from the U.S., the code of honor  from the era of the Shogun remains.  They may have had to readjust  a few things so it translates from the battlefield to the boardroom but this code is still strong today.  For example, if you are attending a Japanese business meeting, don't just sit anywhere.  Unlike American tradition, the guest is not in a place of honor.  Wait until you are seated.  The head of the meeting will always be seated at the head of the table with everyone else placed next according to their importance to the company.  Also, it is polite if you bring a gift from your hometown that will help them understand where you are from.  If, for example, you come from a coastal community in Maine you might bring some lobsters.  Or, if you're from Philadelphia you might bring an accurate replica of the Declaration of Independence.  If they like you, they might give you a gift, too. 

Eating with the Japanese family is a true lesson in etiquette.  The elder male sits at the head of the table and the elder female serves all the food.  There is no grabbing your own food in a traditional Japanese household.  (The most interesting thing is how they decide importance in the family.  There is the eldest, the head of the family.  The eldest son is next in line.  The eldest son of the eldest son, regardless of age, comes third).  The guest never eats before the head of the household takes his first bite.  He may nod to let the guest know when it's OK  to begin eating. 

Everyone, not just President Obama, should learn how to bow before meeting anyone in Japan.  Bowing is not only a way the Japanese greet others but also expresses thanks, an apology, precedes a request, or before asking a favor.  A person of high social status (which includes being older and wiser) requires a deep, longer bow while an informal greet with a peer only requires a slow nod.  Although the Japanese are tolerant of a foreigner's lack of knowledge of the culture and will usually not be slighted by a quick nod, they know that leaders of foreign countries are taught  Japanese etiquette in advance of a first meeting and are less likely to forgive a slight such as not bowing.   

The President of the United States is charged with the job of representing every American abroad.  If Obama does not bow to the Emperor of Japan he not only makes us all look bad but can even ruin our business relationships in the future.  This, we cannot afford.   







Learn more about this author, Sandi Crain.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

by Elizabeth A. Marion

Created on: May 24, 2010   Last Updated: May 26, 2010

President Obama bowing to the Emporer of Japan was obviously a gesture of respect, both for the Emporer and for his culture. Most of the criticism for this bow, and his bow to other leaders, has come from conservatives. The conservatives have been accused, predictably, of not caring about other cultures and even hating other cultures.

As a conservative, I can say that I do have respect for other cultures, but I also believe that American culture deserves the same respect. This viewpoint often gets a glazed over look from liberals who that all cultures should be respected and honored except for America's.

Anyone who visits or decides to live in a different country should respect the culture, learn their customs, and learn their language. For the most part this is common sense, except in America.

If you're an American who expects this effort from immigrants and tourists then you are labeled hateful by those who think American culture should never be respected.

People with the "blame America first" attitude think that all of the effort for showing cultural respect should come from Americans and never criticize other leaders who disrespect us.

Learning the language and showing respect for the culture is simply common decency. It is not an outrageous request or an uncommon expectation.

The case of Barack Obama bowing to the Emporer of Japan is a little different. President Obama did not go to Japan as a tourist and he was not moving there. He was meeting with the leader of the country as the President of the United States, as a representative of America.

It is not that an American President should show no respect for other countries, but he does represent America and should represent the American culture and the American way of life.

When leaders and ambassadors from other countries come to America, they are often seen wearing clothes that is common for their culture. There is nothing wrong with that.

There is nothing wrong with a leader of a country representing their own culture and way of life. Why, then, is it so wrong for an American leader to represent their own culture and way of life in other countries?

Why the double standard? Being the leader of a country traveling to another country to meet with other leaders is much different than being a tourist traveling to other countries for sight seeing.

It is not disrespectful for a leader of a country to value and represent their own culture in other countries. And it is not disrespectful to expect an American president to represent America when in Japan, just as it would not be disrespectful for a Japanese leader to represent Japan when in America.

Learn more about this author, Elizabeth A. Marion.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA