Results so far:
| Yes | 14% | 3 votes | Total: 21 votes | |
| No | 86% | 18 votes |
Modern-day people are as smart as their ancestors of old. As smart, not more so or less so. For there have been, are, and always will be those who are smart and those who are less so. The very nature of the human brain and of society dictates as much. Mental ability can be measured in two ways, that of intelligence, or the efficiency, number and complexity of mental operations, and of knowledge, that of measuring the amount of data contained in a brains memory, or more correctly the amount one can access, as much of a typical humans memory can not be readily accessed.
The amount of ones memory's data that one can access at any time one wishes to is a good indication of knowledge levels and intelligence levels with a single measurement. It shows how efficient ones brain is and also how much information one can retrieve. Thus it can be seen that knowledge and intelligence are closely linked, if not the same entities. When deciding whether or not humans are smarter than their ancestors it must be remembered that whilst society has changed much in recent years, the structure of the human brain, and the way society functions, have not.
Whilst the car did not exist in 1 AD, for instance, the wheel did. And both a horse drawn vehicle and a car serve the same purpose. Thus it can be seen from this simple example how whilst society is a constantly evolving entity, the way it operates and the reasons why it operates in those ways remain much the same. The human brain unlike society has had little change of any sort, like much of our structure, and is largely influenced by nurture, not nature.
The human brain must be thought of as an organic computer. It has evolved over time to handle 'calculations', and in many respects is similar to its electric cousin. However it differs in a number of important areas. Firstly it is not built to be programmed by a human. It has evolved to handle primitive conditions and whilst it is on a higher level of complexity than most animals it is still not designed to be used in the way one would a desktop computer. One can, for instance, not access any file one wants merely by using an efficient search mechanism, nor can one store files in folders.
Well, actually one can, but as Sherlock Holmes proves, it requires dedication and persistence, not to mention energy and stimulation, that most humans lack and do not require. Thus most peoples brains operate on a very instinctive and predictable fashion. For instance, if one feels thirsty, one's brain tells one to get a drink. In most ordinary circumstances even though one is capable of far more complex abstract thoughts one chooses only to exercise this to a limited degree.
However some individuals choose not to be, or are forced or influenced not to be, constrained by these limitations. Most people with a career, that is not a string of barely connected jobs but a profession, apply themselves to this profession and show what human brains are capable of if one tries hard enough to control them. A physicist, for instance, or an astronomer, will be able to amaze one with their knowledge on various complex things. But if one were in their situation one would know as much.
Society has always had individuals of a higher intelligence than others. Society is not constructed of a single class of human, and as such there will always be, whilst society has anything similar to its present system in operation, those of a higher intellectual level and those of a lower level. Thus one's ancestors were not smarter than one, and one not smarter than them, but, if one combines all the intelligent people in the world today, due to today's higher population figure, society itself is smarter on the whole.
Learn more about this author, Mark Waybill.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Are we smarter than our ancestors?
A ten year old child today knows how to access the computer and get information about any subject. Most of them are taught to use various computer programmes and they become adept at applying this skill to other computer related activities. The same child will also be capable of browsing the television channels and connecting up the DVD player. Many of them may have handled a video camera, digital camera and navigating their way about a mobile phone. They are all familiar with the electrical gadgets around the house and with the technical terms associated with them.
A ten year old child living in 1823 would have had to occupy him or herself with wooden toys. If they were curious to know about something they would have had to rely on their parents or some other adult's knowledge to tell them. They would have had access to libraries only much later as adults. Handling cameras and other electrical gadgets was out of the question since these weren't around or not so easily available to everyone.
Is it any wonder that we tend to think we are smarter than our ancestors? But what kind of smartness are we talking about. Doesn't the present day child impress us because of the technological advances around us? An eighty year old person observes a ten year old handling a computer with confidence and is impressed because he/she is comparing the child with his/her own capabilities at that age. But is the eighty year olds lack of capability because of a lack of smartness? Isn't it because our ancestors lacked these devices to impress us by?
Human beings were always smart. Because pre-historic man was smart he was able to survive living in the jungles along with the wild animals. It was his smartness that helped him shape stones into spear heads and use it to protect himself and his species. They discovered the existence of metals and how to put them to use which we now take for granted. Some of the discoveries by our ancestors have been so revolutionary that if it hadn't happened life for us would have been very different. One such discovery is that of silicon. This substance is part of almost everything especially the microchip which is the most important part in a computer. The computer which has revolutionised the way we live is a product of various discoveries by our ancestors. The properties of numbers discovered by our mathematical ancestors led to computer programming which has made computers accessible to even the common man.
We definitely look smart going through live so ably supported by the various mechanical devices but it wouldn't have been so if not for the contributions of our ancestors and let us never forget that.
Learn more about this author, Veena Krishnan.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.