Search Helium

Home > Politics, News & Issues > Politics, News & Issues (Other)

We should end the practice of daylight saving time

Results so far:

Agree
62% 63 votes Total: 102 votes
Disagree
38% 39 votes

Agree

by SLLawson

Created on: November 03, 2009

The original intention for altering the time on our clocks was to give us the impression that there were actually more hours in a day than there really are. An extra hour of daylight during the summer gave farmers more time to do their harvesting while the sun was still shining. I think it also had something to do with war time as well.

The need for that extra sunlight is long gone, so why does this inconvenience still persist? Why are we left with having to adjust our internal clocks twice a year; which for me, wreaks havoc on my body, as well as my brain. And recently, not only was this disruption validated, but someone thought it a good idea to extend Daylight Saving Time.

Rather than changing the clocks in April and October, we now change them March and November. "Why?" I screamed, when I heard that first news report. Whomever came up with that idea must be suffering from sleep deprivation from a lifetime of biological clock disruption.

On Sunday, my daughter complained that even though she thought she could take advantage of that extra "fall-back" hour, her three young boys had different ideas. After all, they didn't know the clocks had changed; their bodies just told them, it's time to wake-up, so mommy and daddy were robbed of that coveted extra hour of sleep they had dreamed about.

Animals don't know the difference either, so their biological clocks were telling them (and they were barking it to their masters) "it's time for a walk - it's time for a walk." So not even pet owners get that extra hour back. In a few months, when it's time to "spring-forward" another hour will be lost once again, never to be recovered.

There have been calculations that the time change twice a year may actually cost about half a billion dollars, or more. Additional electricity is necessary in the morning hours because the clocks have been moved forward to say it's 6:00 a.m. but it's really only 5:00. And then the reverse happens when we fall back. The sun says it's 6:00 pm, but the clock only says it's 5:00, so there's more electrical use in the evenings.

Not to mention productivity loss due to people forgetting about the time change and showing up late to work, or not performing up to par because of the inability to adjust to the change. Arizona got it right when they became the only state in the contiguous U.S. that chose not to observe DST.

These man-made disruptions may have started out to boost commerce and industry, but at what cost to our mental and emotional health? Our natural rhythms flow with the sun. If we don't feel good, balanced, or rested, how much could industry actually be losing instead, because of this warp in time we are forced to endure twice a year? Time is always relative.

We are each given, purportedly, 24 hours in a day to make the most of our lives. What happens when we have to shift those hours against our will? Who is it that really benefits by the time change? Can anyone answer that question? I think we should end the practice of Daylight Saving Time and see.

Learn more about this author, SLLawson.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

Disagree

by Jim Snyder

Created on: November 02, 2009   Last Updated: November 03, 2009

It seems as though every year when it's time to turn my clock back, I think how ridiculous it is that we still adhere to this archaic time-honored tradition. Even though many of my clocks adjust themselves, it still irks me that I yet have to change the time on several, the car's being the worst.

I can never remember how to change the infernal device in the first place, so I end up not watching the road as I maddeningly push and hold buttons that do almost everything but adjust my clock. And you know what, even with the time change, it's still fairly dark out in the morning, and there are deer and Amish running wild on the streets.

But aside from the mild inconveniences and another impetus to be crabby about something, I think I would miss the subtleties inherent in the ritual. I can guarantee that I would bitch and moan about its being gone. For one thing, aside from those in the alcohol distribution arena, it is not an overly-consumerized function.

How many societal ritualized traditions do we have left that can boast this lack of crass commercialism? And then there's that little saying: spring forward, fall back. I'd hate to see that relegated to Trivial Pursuit questions that those born after a certain date can't fathom, like according to Hoyle or not worth a plugged nickel.

As you might guess, I live in a rural agricultural area that has a large Swartzentruber Amish population and abundant wildlife. Obviously neither the Amish nor the deer benefit nor lose anything because of the construction of the seemingly arbitrary time change ritual.

Nor, I suppose do most agricultural folk for whom this bizarre practice was ostensibly intended. But, honestly, are those good enough reasons to abandon it altogether.

I like the romance of it. Autumn in Ohio is an amazing occurrence, especially for those of us who still can feel the awe of the turning, falling and burning leaves, the harvest activities, the apple cider, the pumpkins, the hay rides, the Halloween rituals, and on-and-on.

Even surrounded by all this rustic beauty and charm, there is no time of the year that brings me closer to the workings of Nature and Man's eternal struggle to exist within it. I don't want to lose any of it; including asking my wife every week in October when we need to turn the clocks back.

Learn more about this author, Jim Snyder.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA