Sports & Recreation >
Wrestling
Get a Widget for this title
RSS FeedShould WWE wrestlers be considered athletes if it's scripted?
Results so far:
| Yes | 44% | 4 votes | Total: 9 votes | |
| No | 56% | 5 votes |
Yes
Write now
Print
Invite a writer™
Add to FavoritesCan WWE wrestlers be an athlete even though it is scripted? Yes, we have lots of sports that are scripted. Just because it is scripted doesn't mean that you still don't take the risk of getting hurt. You can practice a routine over and over again, but you still have a chance of getting injured, or something going wrong. There are plenty of "scripted" wrestlers that have had some very serious surgeries because of injury. You have to be athletic and it takes a lot of practice to do what they do. It is a learned sport, it isn't something you can walk into and just do it. Some are better than others at making it look real or fake, non the less they are still athletes performing in a sport. It's all about entertainment, they practice their routine to make it flawless to put on a good show.
Look at all of the other sports that are scripted and practiced. Ice skating is one of them. Can you ask if they are or are not a sport because they scripted a routine. Then practiced it to get it right, to make it look good so they can put on a great show. It is definitely a sport, they compete in the Olympics. How about the other Olympic sports that are scripted for routine and practiced until the show. You have the parallel bars and the gymnast on the mat that have scripted a routine to practice for a show. Once again it is about the entertainment of putting on a good show. Yes there are rewards for best showman, but to hear the applause from the audience is one of the hugest rewards of all.
Let's take a look at dancing. Some would even question this as a sport, but it is. There are certain kinds of dancing you can learn. Then there are "scripted" routines that are put together to practice to put on a show. There are so many TV reality shows today that honor dancers. America's Best Dance Crew, So You Think You Can Dance, and Dancing With The Stars are three very popular shows for today's entertainment. You have to have an athletic ability to accomplish these routines that are seen on these shows.
One thing that isn't thought about, it's just automatically a sport, and that is football. You know that football players have to learn plays from the play book. Scripted plays that they use out on the field. Yes there are a lot of sports out there that are scripted. Is it right to say that just because it is scripted, your not an athlete? There are many types of athletes, just because some follow a script, doesn't make them any less of an athlete. Each person is different in likes and dislikes. What entertains you? What sport do you like to watch? All in all sports entertain, it is up to you to decide which entertainment you prefer to watch.
Learn more about this author, Michelle Reeves.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
No
Should WWE wrestlers be considered athletes if it is scripted?
Personally, my call is that WWE talent should NOT be referred to as athletes, wrestling is totally scripted, every single move has been practiced previously, (And in actual fact, the success of most moves, success being how real it looks, is 90% the wrestler who is recieving the move's responsability) the outcome of the match is pre-determined and the match itself is a choreography, making wrestling more of a dance or movie scene than an actual sports bout.
Based on this reasoning, WWE wrestlers are closer to being stunt-men, than Sportsmen.
The dictionary definition for Athlete is:
Athlete:A person trained to compete in sports.
Wrestling, Professional wrestling aired on TV has never been acknowledged as sport, and unlike "real" submission wrestling, the performers involved in the matches have no real desire to win the match, a match which doesn't technically even exist, for their purpose is to entertain the audience through their matches, and to "tell a story" through their speeches and matches, contributing to the storylines presented to the audience.
Nevertheless, to be able to perform the moves which are performed through the course of the match, wrestlers DO put themselves through lots of training to not only have an appealing physique for a very commercial industry such as pro-wrestling, but to mantain a physicall condition necessary to execute the various moves we watch in matches. In addition to this, moves are practiced by wrestlers, in order to perfect these, making them as harmless as possible for the other performer.
Even though the moves performed by wrestlers might be "very athletic", what goes on in the ring, simply does NOT fit the definition of a sport.- Wrestling involves choreographed and practiced moves, the result of the event is scripted too, and a wrestler's job is to make the fans entertained by their performance, unlike what we would call "real" sports, where the participant's objective is to actually win, outperform the other participant, team, etc. Sports have become mediatic and draw attention of viewers, and whether or not the personallity of the participant gets a reaction, the objective is to outperform your opponent.
On the other hand, wrestling is designed to draw a reaction from fans attending the live events, "heels", the baddies so to speak, act and wrestle in a certain way to get booed, with the sole purpose of their opponent getting a positive reaction from the fans, which can later be used to commercialize wrestling products, more than ever in these times where the WWE is orientated to children, who create most of the company's revenue by buying products such as bags, pencil cases, toy belts. The character developed by wrestlers are a key factor in wrestling, and wrestling itself, has lost some land to it. Floyd Mayweather might be arrogant and over-confident, disliked by boxing fans, but as long as he is able to box, and win, he will be a good performer, and would still be even if his persona was a little more "humble for example.
As much of a wrestling fan as I am, I must say...NO, WWE wrestlers are NOT athletes, what they do is not technically not a sport, but a show, as an interesting fact, not so long ago, commentators featured in WWE:Monday Night Raw, labeled the show as "the longest running weekly episodic television show in history" comparing the show with the likes of Friends actually saying that the show is a TV show in the same style Friends is.
As much of a wrestling fan as I am, I must say...NO, WWE wrestlers are NOT athletes.
Learn more about this author, Edgar Suarez Lopez.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
Difference of opinion? Debate now.
- Wrestling
- Professional wrestling: What's more important money or health?
- Has the WWE brand extension been a good thing or a bad thing?
- Was WWE Chairman Vince McMahon's limousine explosion real or a publicity stunt?
- Can Scott Hall recover his wrestling career after another rehab for alcohol?
- Is Total Nonstop Action (TNA) Wrestling a thing of the past or present?
- NWA: Can the Traditional System survive?
