Join | Log in

Channel Button
Debate_icon

Relationships & Family   >

Acquaintances & Co-Workers

Get a Widget for this title

Should you be friends with an ex-girlfriend?

Results so far:

Yes
55% 45 votes Total: 82 votes
No
45% 37 votes
Yes

You are in love. You will be with her for the rest of your life. You have talked about marriage and all the goodies that go with that. You are even that guy, the one that holds her purse at the mall while she looks at clothes or uses the restroom. Then in the midst of all this happiness, reality rears it's ugly head. A fight breaks out (let's be honest guys, usually it is something that we have or haven't done), it spirals out of control and before you know it, you are single again.

Should you still be friends with your ex-girlfriend? Why wouldn't you. Obviously you have a lot in common or you wouldn't have been in a relationship. Many times I have found myself in the position that a girl and myself make wonderful friends but lousy lovers.

There are two basic ways that you can look at this very common situation. The first one is the pessimistic and paranoid view. Since you were in a relationship with this woman, especially if you lived together you will know a lot about each other. If you don't happen to be the poster child for the ideal citizen and humanitarian in general, you may not want to have a jaded woman with this knowledge. The old saying that Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned can really come into play at this point. The obvious answer to this is to not be a shady person. Follow the rules and you won't have anything to worry about. Unfortunately, most of us break a few small rules here and there. It is much easier to stay friends and not have to worry about it. Like I said this is the paranoid reason, not by any means the correct reason.

The more important reason is you were in a relationship with this woman. This means that you had feelings for her. More than likely very strong emotions, or they would not have been a girlfriend (I am not referring to High School 2 week romances here). Just because the intimate part of the relationship didn't work out, this doesn't mean that all the feelings are gone. If you remain friends you can still care for this person. If they need help or support in any way, even emotional, you can be there for her. After all, you do know her. You would be surprised how much it will help a friend if you just lend an ear for them to vent and to be a confident. You have to hold up your end of this bargain as well. If they want it kept as secret then go with their wishes.

It has been my experience that you can't break up on Friday and still be friends on Sunday morning. Like anything else, you will need closure. The deeper the emotional bonds, usually the longer you will need for the closure to be complete. I completely practice what I preach with this. Of all my serious relationships (those that lasted for at least 2 years) I am friends with all but 3 of the girls. As a matter of fact, my best friend in the world is an ex girlfriend. We dated for almost 5 years before we broke it off for good. We talk every couple of days. We vent to each other, give each other advice (yes even on current relationships) and it works out fine. She has a special place in my heart.

Take the time apart that you both need. Unless the breakup was really bad, don't write a good thing out of your life forever. Keep a friendship that is beneficial to both parties. You will be surprised at how much it can approve your quality of life in general.

Learn more about this author, T. Scott Randolph.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

Yes, I responded in the 'no' category but hear me out. I'm not saying you can't under any circumstances be friends with your ex. However, you should seriously consider why you broke up with him/her in the first place. Do this before placing yourself in a potentially emotionally painful situation. The whole 'can't we just be friends' idea is complicated by the fact you once had romantic feelings for that person. It would be difficult after crossing that line to simply return to the 'friends' stage.

Don't begin a new romance without ending the old one

When you break up, you go through at least some unavoidable heartache. After the pain subsides and you can think clearly again, you may decide to begin a new relationship. It would be unfair, however, if you had never got over the ex to carry those feelings into your current situation. If you still constantly think about him/her and wishing things could've been different, you are stalling the healing process. Your current partner will be rightfully resentful if you spend excessive time talking about your ex. Additionally, your ex will be frustrated being second place in your life if you keep leading them on. It's a lose-lose situation.

You can still keep things civil with the ex

While maintaining a close friendship might not be the best idea, civility is an absolute must. Your ex and you should not hold onto the old pain and resentment. Things simply didn't work out for whatever reason, so bury the hatchet and move forward with your lives. Perhaps it would be best if you viewed them as an acquaintance rather than a friend.

If you are uninvolved

Depending on the circumstances surrounding the breakup, you may feel the desire to reconcile with the ex. If you are uninvolved with anyone else, doing so wouldn't be unfair to anyone. This means returning to the romance stage of the relationship. Personally, I would feel weird about trying to just be platonic friends with someone who I had romantic feelings for at one time, but that's just me. You can try to be platonic friends, but those old feelings could still be there and make things awkward. It's funny, it seems like half of the popular songs out there are about falling in love and the other half are about breaking up. Whatever your decision, please factor into account not just your own feeling but those of the others who are involved in this sensitive situation.

Learn more about this author, Net-surfer Dude.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
Difference of opinion? Debate now.
Acquaintances & Co-Workers
Should ex-lovers be friends?

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA