Search Helium

Home > Arts & Humanities > Writing > Writing Process > Writing Tips

Is being a good speller critical to being a successful writer

Title endorsed in part by:

Results so far:

Yes
68% 444 votes Total: 652 votes
No
32% 208 votes

Yes

by Daniel Cloud

Created on: May 15, 2011

I fail to see how this is even a debate. Of course a writer must be good at spelling. Some quick comparisons: Is knowing what tool to use important for a mechanic? Is understanding a person's rights important for a police officer? Is knowing how to count money important for a cashier? If you answered "no" to any of these questions, then God help your soul.

Each job, trade, or skill has foundational and codependent skills. A writer must know how to spell, the mechanic must know what tools to use, the police officer must know the law, and a cashier has to be able to count money.

Some would argue that it is the content that makes you a good writer. You are very correct in that assumption. You are also failing to see the entire picture. Spelling is a foundational skill for writers. If your spelling reeks of a 6th grade level spelling test with an "F" on it, then I would venture to say your content most likely has some issues as well. That is an assumption for the reader. It is human nature. If you cannot grasp a foundational skill for the job, then you are in the wrong line of work.

Writing should be thought of as a job. Some people write for fun, others for money, and many for both. I write for both reasons. I consider writing to be a fulfilling occupation.

A lack of spelling on a writer's part immediately catches a reader's eye. When a reader sees that you cannot spell, particularly when there is a spell check to fix your errors, then your writing is seen as substandard. This is how the human mind works. If your foundational skills are lacking, then there's a good chance your main skill is lacking. Think back. Do you trust the mechanic who doesn't know a screwdriver from a hammer? Do you want him working on your car? I would think not.

Hypothetically, if I owned Helium and you submitted content with spelling errors, then I would delete your article and ask for a resubmission. Helium does that. If you are off-topic, misspell words left and right, or cannot form complete and logical sentences, then your article goes in the deletion bin and you get an e-mail saying so. If you desire, you can resubmit a new article. However if your spelling is bad, I doubt a rewrite will help your cause.

The main point of this debate is that any major skills or occupations have a set of lower foundational skills that must be understood in order to success in the given area. If you write, you must be able to spell. If you cannot spell, you are not going to get far in writing without some educational help in the area of spelling.

You may be able to have people rewrite articles for you through freelance websites, but that just shows that you are even less of a writer. Having a ghostwriter when you claim to be a successful writer is an oxymoron. Unless you wrote the article yourself, it is never truly your own work or writing.

Learn more about this author, Daniel Cloud.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

by Gavin Wyatt

Created on: October 09, 2009   Last Updated: October 14, 2009

Being a good speller has always shown professionalism in writing, but is the ability to spell mandatory to be a good writer? The ability to spell without using an aid and the completion of a good finished product need to be addressed as two separate parts. The finished product is what is read and graded. The writer's ability to spell is not directly tied to the finished product if writing programs are used as a writing aid. This is why spelling is not a prerequisite to good writing. This is why new ideas are being heard. New writers are breaking onto the scene everyday.

The thought process has been in the past that the ability to spell shows writing knowledge. Knowledge is the true key to great writing. You can't have great writing without the proper knowledge of spelling and grammar. Editing with a pen or re-typing a page on a typewriter can be time consuming. Writing programs have come to the rescue with spell check! Word by misspelled word, it moves through the paper pointing out spelling and grammar errors, and giving helpful suggestions. The fixes are usually fast and painless, changing very little. If the writing is poor, the spelling will not matter. If the spelling is poor and the writing is great, the story will be bought and edited.

To the reader, attention to detail shows the writer spent time editing. The reader is not distracted by errors. The finish product is the final goal and should be the only yardstick to measure competent writing. Does it matter that one writer sat, and in one shot, went from blank page to a finished product in hours? Another might have spell checked his paper to death after multiple reads over multiple days. Either way, they will achieve their final destination, and a final product.

These days, ideas are written through the internet at break finger speed. It is the quality of the idea that will truly make the writing successful in this new environment. If the writer is good and the idea is complete, they will succeed. If the writing lacks and the idea are poor, it will not succeed. Proper spelling will not move the needle in either direction. Poor spelling cannot sink a good article, just as great spelling cannot save it. Worry about the structure quality before the writing quality is putting the cart in front of the h-o-r-s-e.

As my wife and I cheered our daughter through a spelling bee just recently, I made the comment that I thought spelling didn't really matter anymore, and a spelling bee could in fact be a waste of time because of computers and writing software. My wife did not care for this idea, and she told me if I said anything around the kids, it would be the last thing I would say at all. I would ask her about this side point if we were talking! I think she would agree with me in this one aspect, computers have made it much easier for the immature writers to write proficiently.

In looking at a few of the writing programs, the price range can range from $29.99 to $269.99. Some of the options include: Structure templates, import and export, brainstorming, reviews, story illustrations, outline, spell check, word count, word processor, and story development. The top three writing programs as reviewed by www.toptenreviews.co m show that Dramatica Pro, Power Writer, and Story View are their highest rated writing software. Choose wisely and get the options that help you the most.

I say, throw the physical act of writing directly out the window, and speak every golden thought into existence. Use Dragon Naturally Speaking 10 as it is the top reviewed voice recognition software. It works will with Microsoft. It transcribes spoken words into printed words. This completely nullifies spelling concerns. The program cost about $85.00. Macspeech Dictate works well with Macintosh. It runs on the same Dragon Speak platform and costs around $150.00. This is a great way to write if you can't write!

As we do not write with quill pen anymore, the amount we are able to edit writings before they have reached perfection is helpful to successful writing. If you were unlucky enough to read the first versions of this article, I am sorry. www.helium.com You would have given me the rating version of a middle finger. Understanding that, I edited, and ran a few more spell checks. I double checked my grammar (I probably need a quadruple check)! I made the finished product better than it was at the start with the different tools available to me. Now if I were more professional, I would have done this before I published the first time! You live and you learn. The main point is that even without the ability to spell, a writer can be successful. Writing programs will give a writer the basics when it comes to format and spelling. The creativity and the use of the language are still up to the writer. The actual words and information is the reason for critique and not any miscellaneous spelling errors. The depth of the writing should be the focus of the new writer. Spell check helps keep the spotlight on just that!






Learn more about this author, Gavin Wyatt.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA