Home > Society & Lifestyle > Ethnicity & Gender > Immigration Issues
Results so far:
| Helpful | 59% | 106 votes | Total: 179 votes | |
| Seperates | 41% | 73 votes |
Helpful
Created on: October 05, 2009 Last Updated: October 10, 2009
Why can't we all just simply be "American"? This is a question that's frequently asked when one has been curious about the practice of referring to some one by their ethnic / cultural heritage then adding American. It's this social practice that has in a way made America a more open society for immigrants than any other society. It has become a place were one could continue practicing their own traditions while living in a new society.
Before attempting to defend this practice, it's fair to first examine multiculturalism in other parts of the world. Western Europe in last 50 years has begun to embrace multiculturalism as a way to unite the continent in the aftermath of horrendous atrocities committed during World War II (like the Holocaust). Governments in Europe have now attempted to protect the rights of immigrants and ethnic minorities by enacting hate crime laws and criminalizing hate speech or speech that promotes inner community violence.
However ethnic communities are still constantly under attack by right-wing extremist groups, despite the efforts of law enforcement and the government. While hate crimes among minorities of European origin may not be so high, immigrants from the Middle East, Africa, and Asia are constantly under attack.
Yet the ethnic-based violence in Europe is only minimal compared to other parts of the world. Race-riots have become too common in Third-World Democracies where ethnic majorities are in poverty while an ethnic minority holds economic power. Hate crimes in such nations are also high while the law chooses not to act.
Other nations however have attempted to brutally suppress other cultures while governments have contributed to pogroms. Such policies have led to some of the worst human rights violations of our time. These minorities have always been cast aside and labeled as "traitors of the state" by the government. It's because of such actions that so many have immigrated to the United States.
When America was established as a nation, the principles of free speech and freedom of religion were radical ideas, yet it attracted millions of people who were fleeing religious or ethnic persecution (like the Catholic-Irish from British ruled Ireland or Jews from Russia). These people accepted their new American heritage yet preserved their traditions as well.
One thing that made the culture of America so unique is that new elements have been added to it over time. Cuisine, music, stories, and style from one culture could overtime be infused with the culture of America. There so many everyday words used in America that originated from another language.
Yet these people still wish to maintain their cultural heritage but still want to be recognized as Americans. For this reason it has become an acceptable practice for an individual to identify themselves by their heritage then add "American" to the end of it. This allows a person to be able to pass on their heritage while recognizing themselves as an American.
So while it may seem trivial to add an ethnic prefix to American to an immigrant or first generation individual it is a way to preserve their proud heritage and also identifying themselves as a proud American.
Learn more about this author, Stan Rezaee.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Seperates
Created on: August 12, 2010
Black. White. Red. Yellow. Are these colors of the rainbow or are these people? The only colors that should matter are red, white and blue. America should be unified in spite of ethnic, religious or political differences. The generic title “American” should suffice to make any citizen proud in a country that was founded on equality for all. The use of “American” as a suffix only further divides this country into cultural subgroups according to minority. However, you will never hear someone being referred to as an “Anglo-Saxon-American” or a “Caucasian-American.”
On the other hand, I have been called an Asian-American in the past, but I believe the title is fitting for me personally because I was born in Seoul, South Korea. Therefore the suffix should only logically be given toward people with dual citizenship or nationalized immigrants. Attaching a suffix to the country of a person’s ancestors is, in my honest opinion, utterly ridiculous. If a black man is born and raised as an American citizen and has never so much as watched a Discovery Channel show about Africa, it seems thoroughly unreasonable that he should have the title “African-American.”
America is famous for being a melting pot. We are a nationwide bag of Skittles and the unifying factor between every person in every state is the country in which we all reside. Americans have a tendency to divide themselves based on their ethnic background. Italians, Greeks, Germans, etc. frequently identify themselves by their “mother” country even though America is the mother of us all.
Political correctness should ideally not even exist in a tolerant nation. It is a fickle part of our culture whose terms are never defined and are constantly changing. It was politically correct not too long ago to call people of African descent by “negro” or “colored.” In our day and age, it would be unheard of to refer to someone in that way. How long will it be before “African-American” becomes an outdated and unfamiliar term? The division of ethnic groups is one part of our culture that needs to come to an end. If minorities did not feel treated unfairly by other members of their community, political correctness would not even be present in our society.
There is nothing wrong with taking pride in our heritage, but it should not become our sole identity. We should be Americans first and Puerto Rican, Albanian and Japanese second. Pride in our ancestry should never surpass our love and loyalty to our home.
Learn more about this author, Bethany Johnson.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.