Search Helium

Home > Politics, News & Issues > Politics, News & Issues (Other)

Do the rich pay their fair share in taxes?

Results so far:

Yes
44% 90 votes Total: 204 votes
No
56% 114 votes

Yes

by Sam Patterson

Created on: August 18, 2009   Last Updated: August 21, 2009

This question may be difficult to answer. What constitutes a 'fair share' is certainly subjective! However, if one takes a look at the numbers the answer becomes clear: the rich pay their fair share of taxes, and then some.

The statistics show that a small minority of the wealthiest pay a large percentage of our income taxes. According to IRS data, the wealthiest 1% of taxpayers pays a whopping 40.4% of our country's income tax. The top half of taxpayers in America pays 97% of all the income tax, meaning the bottom half pays only 3%. In fact, nearly 40% of all Americans pay no income tax at all, and many of those will actually receive money because of tax credits.

Obviously the rich take home far, far more revenue than those at the bottom, but because of their higher income, and the fact that they are in higher tax brackets, they pay the vast majority of the income taxes in our country. It can be said unequivocally that the rich carry the tax burden of the United States.

This leads to the question of whether or not this is a fair share. As I said earlier, 'fair share' is subjective. Some would contend that three million Americans at the top paying more than the rest of the 133 million taxpayers combined is not enough. They should pay it all. After all, 'they can afford it'. I have often heard this argument for increasing taxes on the rich.

However, I question who is able to make such a judgment. Perhaps the government should simply determine what everyone can comfortably live on (I propose $150,000 annually for a single individual), and then take any amount which they earn on top of that.

This would satisfy the 'they can afford it' argument easily. My argument against my own proposal is that the government has no right to do so, just as they have no right to disproportionately tax one segment of the population more than another. Additionally, the more heavily taxed the wealthy are, the less incentive they have to earn so much money, and they will earn less, meaning less products and services, higher unemployment, and less tax revenue.

The rich do more than simply provide the majority of taxes for our country. Many of the rich own small to medium size businesses, employing many other American citizens. They are rich because their businesses are successful, and with that success their employees benefit, as well as those consumers who use their products or services.

Anyone who is fair would instantly recognize the rich are paying their dues. It would be quite a stretch for anyone to propose forcing the rich minority, who already bear the tax burden for the majority, to pay any more than they already do, and still call it 'fair'. Forcing the rich minority of this country to bear the cost for the majority's expenses is indeed unfair. Do the rich pay their fair share? Yes, and then they pay much more.

Learn more about this author, Sam Patterson.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

by Robert Heston

Created on: March 19, 2010   Last Updated: March 20, 2010

The poor and middle class in the U.S. are being figuratively raped by the rich, who don't pay their fair share in taxes. The richest 1% of the people in this country own 42% of the wealth, roughly the same amount that's owned by the poorest 90%.

In 2007, maverick billionaire Warren Buffet said that he paid 18% in taxes, while his staff paid 33%, or close to double as a percentage of what he paid.  He challenged his fellow billionaires to crunch their own numbers and prove him wrong, to date none have.

Whenever there's talk of adjusting the tax rates, inevitably there's a heated discussion over who is and who isn't rich. At one time President Obama was talking about a top tax rate for all those making over $250,000 a year. 

Those in the top 1% financially must love how this relatively low figure lowers what would otherwise be their fair share of taxes. Let's keep in mind that this top 1% are big contributors to political campaigns. While most income earners would be happy to earn $250,000 a year, that's a drop in the bucket when compared to what the richest 1% of Americans earn. 

Divide and rule has long been a favored tactic used by the ruling elites, and that's exactly what's happening here. As long as the majority of people are fighting among themselves over trivial matters, the elites have nothing to fear.

When discussing taxes we need to keep in mind the different ways that we're taxed. The highest tax rates are on "earned income", another name for jobs, and the main source of income for most people. "Capital gains" are profits from investments, and are taxed at a considerably lower rate than earned income. 

Capital gains are the major source of income for the richest 1% of Americans.  In addition, the amount that's currently paid into Social Security and Medicare is based on earned income, not capital gains. Then there's "user fees", which in many ways appear to be taxes hiding under a different name.

Whenever there's talk of changing the tax rates on the rich, we're predictably met with a flood of crocodile tears and a sob story about the evils of income redistribution. Here's a cold, hard, fact. Income redistribution is already taking place, and it has been for several decades now. 

In many ways it's even fair to say that class warfare was declared, and the poor and middle class are losing. The bailouts are the most blatant act of thievery by the rich to date.

In December 2006, Gerald Celente, editor and publisher of the Trends Journal was interviewed by Linda Moulton Howe. Celente said that in the late 1960's the income differential between C.E.O.'s and their average workers was about 25:1. By December 2006, that ratio was over 400:1!

Presently, the gap between rich and poor is wider in the U.S. than any other major developed country, with the exception of Mexico and Russia. Income redistribution is already taking place, and there's no question that the richest people in this country don't pay their fair share in taxes. They're not only on a free ride, they're being paid to take that ride.    

Learn more about this author, Robert Heston.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA