Home > Parenting & Pregnancy > Babies > Toddlers
Results so far:
| Good idea | 52% | 317 votes | Total: 611 votes | |
| Bad idea | 48% | 294 votes |
Good idea
Created on: August 13, 2009 Last Updated: April 26, 2010
Experienced parents, especially those who have recently navigated the toddler years, will either smile smugly or burst into outright laughter when someone voices the mantra, "Toddler leashes are degrading...and humiliating!" Of course toddler leashes are a good idea, equivalent to the brainstorm of the first parent who brought a baggie of Cheerios to occupy their toddler in church.
Go ahead: ask a toddler if he feels degraded or humiliated while on a toddler leash. Chances are that he will look at you, puzzled, because he neither knows the meaning of those words nor does he understand the concept; toddlers are notoriously self-centered, and the only reason one would be opposed to a leash is because it will keep him from fully exploring the object of the moment.
A ten-foot toddler leash will allow a child a modicum of freedom - and at his age, that's all he needs. He has no perception of danger, he just knows what he wants, and that he wants it all now, this minute. He will dart and dodge and take off on a whim, his poor parent trailing behind like the tail of a kite.
Fortunately, this toddler is on a leash and so his harassed parent can indeed keep up with him. His parent can prevent untold disasters, while at the same time the toddler has the illusion of freedom. In this manner, the toddler is much safer and, indeed, happier than if he were being confined to a stroller, carried, or hanging constantly onto a sweaty hand - or, hard to imagine, abducted or become seriously injured.
No sane individual would use a toddler leash to stake said toddler out in the yard, or yank him back unceremoniously when he wanders too far - these are things that do indeed make one question the use of a toddler leash. Parents who do these things are likely doing far worse to their children.
Of course, all politically correct parents and yes, even helicopter parents, will avoid the use of toddler leashes like the plague. Why? Because they'd rather their children annoy others, or scare them, or trip them up while in crowd than speak one so-called unkind word to little Johnny or, heaven forbid, actually correct him. Helicopter parents would much rather be constantly correcting little Johnny, talking a blue streak while trying to enjoy their outing and, again, annoying others in the vicinity.
Using a toddler leash is not a negative impression on a child, and it has nothing to do with wanting to keep a child from small, minor injuries - it has everything to do with eliminating the heart-stopping fear that arises when a toddler cannot be found, is perched on the fence at the gorilla pen in the zoo, or to reduce the constant yammering at said child to hang on, be careful, look out, and other unnecessary corrections and deflections.
Parents who use toddler leashes do so merely to employ another tool in their arsenal of child-raising tricks - because staying one step ahead of the kids, literally and figuratively, is the name of the game.
Learn more about this author, Robin Tidwell.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Bad idea
Created on: March 06, 2010 Last Updated: March 09, 2010
There is no replacement for an attentive parent.
Ever.
There are so many different points to make there are the psychological impacts, the false security aspects and the safety of passerby.
I only want to discuss the most important of the three as I have read an article in this debate stating that leashes will keep your child safe, and out of danger, from strangers and abduction.
If you believe that leashing your child will keep them out of harms way, you, are sorely mistaken. Do you think child predators care about a thin piece of nylon attached to a child they wish to abduct?
Everybody say it with me, NO!
Ever heard of scissors? A box cutter or a pocket knife will also make short work of severing a child from a leash. All of these items are readily available and are capable of severing the tenuous (at best)bond attaching you and your child.
Tethers promote false security in parents and should never, ever, be used as any form of garantee that your child is safe from predators. It is irresponsible and has the potential to be lethal!
Safeguard your child by minding them, it is your job, your duty, and your responsibility as a parent, caregiver or guardian.
The definition of a parent is "a protector or guardian." Definition of protector "a person or thing that protects; defender; guardian."And the definition of guardian "a person who guards, protects, or preserves."
Kidnappers have been known to be able to steal a child, completely change their appearance and remove them from the public place they are in, within 3 minutes. There are accounts of child abduction where the child is taken in a department store,hustled into the same department store bathroom with a bottle of hair dye, a pair of scissors, and a change of clothes. The abductor cuts and dies the child's hair, changes their clothes, gives them a cute hat and pair of cartoon sunglasses. Puts them in a stroller or shopping cart with a few toys and something sweet. They walk out the front door of the store before the parent has even had a chance to report that the child is missing from their side.
Don't allow it to happen to your child!
Watch them, hold their hand, put them in a stroller. If they do not wish to obey then take them home where they are safe.
Children must be taught to mind their parent, or caregiver. Children must be taught how to be safe. Leashes do not promote any of these behaviors. Leashes are for parents who want to divide their attention or focus on something other than their child.
Why would you have a child if you are not willing to teach that child how to become a responsible adult? That is a parent's job, to care for their child, to teach them how to function in this world and to keep them safe.
Leashes are for the dogs. Let's keep them in their rightful place!
Learn more about this author, Nicole Randie.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.