Get a Widget for this title
RSS Feed
Should bloggers be held to the same code of ethics as professional journalists?
Should bloggers be held to the same code of ethics as professional journalists?
Title endorsed in part by:
Results so far:
| Yes | 61% | 152 votes | Total: 251 votes | |
| No | 39% | 99 votes |
Yes
Write now
Print
Invite a writer™
Add to FavoritesWe live in a time where it is more important to be the "first journalist out" with a story than being overly concerned about the story's accuracy and sometimes fairness, even though professional journalists operate under a code of ethics and to that end are held accountable for their conduct. Most journalists today would probably not meet Walter Cronkite's form of ethical standards, but in fairness many are simply responding to America's obsession with the "need to know at any and all cost" mentality.
Even so, when bloggers attempt to compete with professional journalists, they need to operate under some legitimate code of ethics that includes a mechanism for disclosure, individual accountability and and parameters that show some regard on how stories will affect their subjects.
The professional journalist code of ethics maintains that journalists are held to certain codes of behavior that range from ensuring the accuracy of the information reported without personal embellishments, supporting others' views even when they find them distasteful, being able to recognize that the information they report may cause others harm, to abiding by the same high standards they should attribute to others. Bloggers should be held to the same ethical standards if they persist in wanting to be labeled journalists.
Cyberjournalist.com offers some guidelines for bloggers to adopt if they want to be considered serious journalists; however, they are under no obligation to adhere to them.
For example, although an extreme case, take the recent case of Carrie Prejean and the controversy that surrounded her response during the Miss California's pageant. Whether one agrees with her is not the issue, it is the license a blogger has to denigrate or disparage with impunity. No professional journalist is able to go on all the major news shows to further insult the subject of a story.
Because many bloggers' work will be read and most likely believed by many, as many folks do not conduct their own critical analyses of what they read or hear, they should be held to the same standards as professional journalists. There should be oversight concerning what they can report and parameters established on the extent they are able to obtain information.
True, there are bloggers who are ethical and principled and adhere to the rules of fair and judicious reporting. They write and report because they are disciples of the art itself, rather than for any fame or fortune they may derive. However, sooner or later there will be instances where bloggers will obtain information that will fall under the First Amendment that will require the Supreme court to settle the matter once and for all. Perhaps, this is what is needed in order to establish bloggers' place in the world of news reporting. Are they bona fide journalists? What are the rules and laws under which they operate?
As with any job, there is a certain amount of responsibility and accountability that is inherent in it; therefore, at a minimum, bloggers should be held to those same standards.
http://www.cyberjour nalist.net/news/0002 15.php
Learn more about this author, Dossie M Terrell.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
No
Looking at the state of journalism today, it is hard to see any code of ethics at all. However, the issue of whether bloggers should be held to that supposed code of ethics is a double-edged sword.
It all boils down to professionalism. But are all bloggers professional journalists? No, they are not. If we were to expect a blogger to submit to a professional's code of ethics, we must also allow the blogger all the benefits that come with being a professional journalist. Professional Journalists have a code of ethics they are supposed to respect because they are professionals. Professionals have been trained and taught to write with their code of ethics in mind. Bloggers have not. Professional Journalists have schooling. In many cases, they work for an editor that will be held responsible for any damage done for writing that does not adhere to the code of ethics. Most bloggers do not answer to anyone but their readers.
Certainly, it would be nice if the average blogger paid attention to a code of ethics, but then again, many of us enjoy a blog post that is opinionated and not held back by a code of ethics. It is certainly reasonable to say that plagiarism is a crime, professional or not, and not even a blogger shall be exempt from prosecution. However, a journalist tells a story and let's the reader decide. A blogger often tells his opinion and let's his readers reply. Sarcasm, spin, and humor bring you to a blog. A common interest or opinion keeps you coming back to that blog. If a blogger were held to the journalism code of ethics, we would not have any use for blogs. We can get news anywhere, but a good opinionated, sarcastic or heartfelt blog by a fellow citizen is both enjoyable and informative.
Any decent writer, blogger or professional journalists should naturally abide some ethical practices. Plagiarism is one of those things. However, I would not want to read a blog that stuck to the professional journalism code of ethics and stayed neutral in its views. I want to know what my fellow citizens feel about the issues. Professional journalists can follow their code of ethics and deliver a neutral news article reflecting none of their personal views. Bloggers should be free to say what is on their mind. That is, after all, the main reason for the popularity of blogs among non-professionals.
Learn more about this author, Belinda Long.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Difference of opinion? Debate now.
- Internet Writing & Blogging
- Is using an academic ghost writer dishonest?
- Should you quit your day job to blog?
