My Helium | Join | Log in Where Knowledge Rules

Education:

Colleges & Universities

Debate_icon

RSS RSS Feed

Get a Widget for this title

Are parents justified in pressuring their teenage children to get a college education?

 

Title endorsed in part by:

Results so far:

Yes
67% 281 votes Total: 421 votes
No
33% 140 votes
Yes

The wording of this question is misleading. However your feelings about the word pressure, insisting a child attend college would hardly be considered a negative concept. Compel, drive, and insist are all synonyms of the word pressure. If I ask instead, Are parents justified in insisting their teenage children to attend college, does it sound the same? Then there is the teenage children part. Does anyone expect the average teenager to go to college before graduating high school? I think not. When you graduate from high school, that is the appropriate time to attend college. However, some students entering college happen to be teenagers. For example, I was seventeen when I graduated high school and entered college, in which case I guess I was still considered a teenager. Now that I've addressed semantics, lets address reality.

Some people may argue, not everyone is cut out to go to college. That is complete bologna. No one ever said you have to be a top of the list high school graduate, or have to go to an Ivy League school to get a decent education. There are a myriad of colleges out there that accept, and even seek out, students who didn't make the grade in high school. In Colleges That Change Lives, by Loren Pope, he highlights 40 colleges that do just that. He writes, They change lives of A students, B students, C students, people with learning difficulties, late bloomers, the handicapped or disabled, or almost anyone with the desire to learn and grow. In short, they make winners because they exert a special magic, intelligent caring, and tough love (p.14). Pope writes about a business professor from St. Andrew's in Lauringburg, NC, who proudly states that We take kids who haven't done well in high school, but we turn out people who compete with the Ivies. I'd put them up against the Ivies (p.148).

Next, let's talk about the cost of college. Should one push a child to get into an Ivy League college with the costs to match if the pocketbook doesn't afford? Hardly. Parents and children need to be realistic about tuition costs and how it will affect them down the road. It makes no sense to get a degree, then not be able to make loan payments and support a life simultaneously. Students can get a decent education at a smaller, less expensive school and sometimes it can be a more rewarding experience to boot. A student who attended a University wrote, I was in classes of 2,000, sitting in the balcony; I could have gotten my degree without ever getting out of bed except to take an exam. I could have hired note-takers to do the rest (Colleges That Change Lives, by Loren Pope, p.22). It's worth mentioning that two-year colleges and other institutions, such as those that teach a specific trade, are advantageous. Obviously, research needs to be done when considering the future of your child.

What is the hype about education right after high school? Many recent high school graduates are unprepared to go out into the great yonder. Can it be done? Sure, but not without a struggle. We've all heard of the statistics, but I'll throw some out there anyway. As reported by www.Ed.gov, in 2006, the median income of a full-time salary worker ages 25-34 with a Bachelor's degree or higher was 50,000 for a male and 41,000 for a female. For a person with a high school diploma or GED, it was 30,000 for a male and 24,000 for a female. Is it only about money, though? No, but isn't it harder to support yourself and a family on $24-$30,000? Go to www.bls.gov and you will see for yourself many statistics related to this topic as well as occupations as it relates to income. One can conclude, possessing a college degree is more beneficial that not having one.

Some people argue that many youngsters don't know what they want to do with their lives after graduating high school. Well, join the club. I was unsure of what I wanted to do for the rest of my life, but college helped me sort that out. College is a time where students are introduced to various fields of work and study. It broadens their proverbial horizons. Also, many colleges don't require a major declaration right away. Most college students change their major at least once, reports www.college.gov. Even people in their forties and beyond are making career changes. People and times change. Does that mean a college education is worthless? Hardly.

College is a time where students learn how to live independently and become self-sufficient. Still a community of rules and consequences, a college campus is a more forgiving environment than the real world if one makes a mistake. It is a place of learning and growing in every sense. Also, college is a place where people of many different backgrounds converge, therefore, tolerance and understanding is essential. The college experience extends to many areas of life and learning.

In 2006, the number of adults age 25 and older enrolled in college was an estimated 6.7 million (National Center for Education Statistics, 2006). Why would so many adults feel compelled to go to college when the challenges they face as an adult is ten-fold, compared to when they were fresh out of high school? As an adult student, one must juggle a full time job, family, and commitments to their community, for example. Wouldn't it have been easier to go to college right out of high school? Adults are going to college in record numbers because they have opened their eyes to the reality that a college degree has benefits ranging from a better job and more money, to personal growth and accomplishment and so on. Of course there are circumstances where people couldn't go to college until they were older, but there are many people who had the opportunity when they were younger, but chose not to go.

Are parents justified in pressuring their teenage children to get an education? Absolutely!

Learn more about this author, Heather Huff.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

There are many arguments in favour of pressuring children into getting a college education. There are statistics that show that a college education can lead to a higher average annual income. There are arguments for the social and even political interaction that attending college can provide. It simply cannot be ignored however, that there are many successful people who walked their journey without following a path through tertiary education.

Michael Dell, founder of Dell Inc, one of the world's biggest computer hardware manufacturing companies, is reputed to have dropped out of college at the age of 19. John D. Rockefeller - arguably the richest man in history - famously dropped out of high school, before even having the opportunity to attend college. And Henry Ford - responsible for bringing the first commercially produced car to the world, and establishing one of the biggest automotive companies of our time, the Ford Motor Co. - didn't even graduate from high school either.

Social stigma has a lot of repsonsibility in adding to this pressure that parents often put on their children. What's more, children forced into this kind of education not only study it at a compromised level, but they waste precious time and precious money that could surely be better utilised elsewhere in their upbringing.

A child seeking fulfillment outside of the realms of their parents beliefs will also feel like they are rebelling against what they have been taught - whether they agree with it or not. The implications of this can become far greater than the implications of, for example, not attending college.

Needless to say, college can be a path to a career of a higher standard. It can also empower our children with an unmatchable knowledge and allow them to challenge themselves to a higher degree, and help them to grow and learn in positive and unique ways. But it simply isn't the only way to achieve this.

Furthermore, college is an expensive way to embark on a journey of discovery in order to find out just where you fit in in the social structure of our society. It is an expensive way to find out where your interests and passions lie (which is often a reason for parental pressure) and what career will make you happy.

And who says that happiness ultimately comes from a higher education? The clearest arguement here is for the fact that parents shouldn't be putting unecessary or biased pressure on their children for any reason. Parents must understand that guidance is the key, not insistence.

Learn more about this author, Carlos Hurworth.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA