Join | Log in

Channel Button
Debate_icon

Education   >

Colleges & Universities (Other)

Get a Widget for this title

Are parents justified in pressuring their teenage children to get a college education?

 

Title endorsed in part by:

Results so far:

Yes
67% 275 votes Total: 411 votes
No
33% 136 votes
Yes

What do parents want for their children? Only the best. Parents really have little benefit in sending wanting their offspring to do well academically, go to college, and get some paper qualifications. Keep in mind that a college education does not come cheap these days. After all, education is not immune to inflationary pressures.

Why then do parents want their children to head to college so badly?

In a society that places ever-increasing emphasis on paper qualifications, one needs a proper education in a reputable college to have a greater chance at leading a more comfortable life. While striking it out on your own and being entrepreneurial is a possible path towards success and a better quality of life, it is nonetheless a risky path to embark on. Even more unconventional careers such as dance and music tend to require long apprenticeships at exclusive and specialized schools that are just as difficult to enter as academic colleges.

In essence, a college education provides the highest probability of leading a better life when the graduate enters the working world.

As I mentioned, parents want only the best for their young, and by wanting their children to take the college route, one can assume that parents want their children to have a successful career in the days ahead.

This desire is amplified by the personal experiences of the parent. The parent that has experienced poverty and hardship as a child refuses to have their young go through the same difficult life. They are convinced that education provides the necessary insurance against financial hardships. This also explains their apprehension over their children embarking on more unconventional career paths, simply because of the uncertainty involved in such career routes.

Similarly, the parent fortunate enough to have enjoyed relatively comfortable growing years know that the stable careers that their own parents had were a direct result of the strong education they received. Wanting their offspring to enjoy the same comfort in life, they wish for their children to take the same path towards academic and job success that of a college education.

Perhaps parents should not be blamed for wanting their young to get a college education. The fault actually lies in the labor market, which places a high demand on paper qualifications, and tends to reward risk and entrepreneurship poorly. Furthermore, careers in fields such as the arts tend to be much less well-publicized than corporate high-flyers.

Until the labor markets actively start to place less emphasis on paper qualifications, parents will continue to pressure their young to get a college education, if only to ensure a better quality of life for their young.

Learn more about this author, Timou.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

Justification? First consider feasibility. Part of my career responsibilities was conducting feasibility studies. Feasibility leads to reality. I had to determine whether or not a project was a realistic endeavor based on facts presented.
Counseling one's teenage children to pursue a college education is commendable whereas pushing or applying pressure to do so might not. Pushing one's child can mean pushing him/her away and often does psychologically. Coaching is often a better approach.

Something that might be considered is means to pay for that education. What will a 4 year college education cost when that child finally gets there? The costs are staggering at this time and is pretty much prohibitive unless one comes from wealth. There are not enough scholarships or grants to pay for those years of schooling. I took out student loans when I was younger and what a pinch they put me in when it came time to pay up. That was years ago and though I didn't borrow $50K or more I know several students will have to.
I worked at a large and well known college laboratory 20 years ago. The younger engineers were attending graduate courses on campus there after work. Some of us learned the costs of that and considered it to be ridiculous. Two years of graduate studies was not worth the price of a house. I think those students are feeling the payback to be a bit steep now given the current financial state of the world as they are surely still in debt.

I am shocked to know households having problems with mortgages are subscribed to satellite or cable television as well as cell phone service for everyone in their households. Most have multiple car notes consuming huge chunks of their monthly incomes.
This is where feasibility comes into play. Most families in America maintain a foothold because of debt. The majority of those are so mired in debt they will never see a tunnel of light meaning relief less they conduct a significant turnaround in life.

The present economy presents something that I have problems with. Interest rates that reward one for saving or investing money don't exist as they once did so people don't. If one is able to save or invest the returns are pittances. Add to that the effects of salary reductions due to scaling back of employers and saving is further removed.
The following is a question I have asked over the past 10 years. If one cannot afford to save money, how can one afford to spend it? I used to enjoy handsome dividends on investments as simple as bank CD's. They have dwindled to handfuls of change over the past few years.

Given the financial air of the nation - if a family cannot fund a child's college education why push the child? The chance of every child receiving a full tuition by way of grants for a college scholarship is unlikely. I don't know the exact percentages of how many scholarships are given out but there are not enough to float the education of every child hoping to attend college/university.

I found this bit of information concerning the disparity of those who have and those who do not have the resources to seek college education. Again, a lot of it is feasibility. This information deals with my topic at hand - I had no need to write the above after finding this information. I was looking for percentages of students and tuition funding.

I see no justification in pressuring a child in light of these figures. Counsel the child before he/she is in junior high school and demonstrate the merits of education so that the child might strive for higher grades which could lead to a scholarship.

Let us only hope that things turn around soon before it is near impossible for none but the very wealthy to attend university. At that point we will be thrown back to a Victorian times and only the wealthy will be educated.

Learn more about this author, Kevin L'dux.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA