Home > Health & Fitness > Pharmaceuticals > Pharmaceuticals (Other)
Results so far:
| yes | 58% | 38 votes | Total: 65 votes | |
| no | 42% | 27 votes |
yes
Created on: August 05, 2010 Last Updated: January 18, 2011
Resveratrol may well be a wonderful supplement and has the potential to soon be proven a "wonder" compound in several different areas of human health. In an odd public relations reversal, studies proving that resveratrol has remarkable affects on animals, insects and in vitro cells have been dismissed and belittled because they do not involve human research. Actually, such is the normal, usual course of research and it makes literal scientific sense. Recent studies, however, have begun to test resveratrol on humans.
The Institute of Pharmacology and Therapeutics, Faculty of Medicine, University of Porto, Portugal, recently established that dosages of the compound called "trans-resveratrol" are safe at several levels up to 150 mg per day. This also side-steps the issue of people drinking red wine as the standard source of resveratrol and risking the side-effects of alcohol consumption. People who choose not to drink wine can ingest safe doses of the supplement. Other common natural sources are grapes, peanuts, blueberries and cranberries, which are clearly unmeasurable amounts, although it is possible that the protective and positive effects may be available in the natural state. A previous study at Leicester University demonstrated that high dosages of resveratrol up to 5,000 mg per day are acceptable for humans.
Well controlled human studies are now underway. The Brain, Performance and Nutrition Research Centre at Northumbria University demonstrated that high doses of resveratrol increased blood flow in the brain, which can have important effects on brain health and various therapies. The State Univ. of New York at Buffalo reported that resveratrol "appears to suppress inflammation in humans, based on results from the first prospective human trial of the extract conducted by UB endocrinologists." It is also clear that other beneficial effects that were not part of the initial hypotheses for the studies have suggested further lines of research. The Albert Einstein College of Medicine investigated the effects of resveratrol on Type 2 Diabetes, and the positive results indicate that further studies with many more participants are necessary and warranted.
The initial interest in resveratrol was based on anecdotal claims and inferences from the perceived effects of red wine on the overall heart healthy contradiction known as the "French paradox." French people who eat rich, fatty foods, and also smoke, seem not to have the heart and lung disease(s) common to other populations. It appears as if one important factor is that they drink red wine.
The inferences led to actual research which substantiated many of the opinions about resveratrol as a phytoalexin prevalent in red wines. As the research became more and more positive, human clinical trials developed from the cellular, insect and small mammal studies that tended, generally, to be very positive. The initial human studies also appear to indicate that resveratrol does provide some of the healthy benefits attributed to the compound, whether as a nutritional supplement or from one of the natural sources.
It seems reasonably clear that resveratrol is a very useful dietary supplement. And it may become increasingly clear that the compound has the potential to be a "wonder" supplement that contributes substantially to human health.
Learn more about this author, W. H. Lindgren.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
no
Created on: January 06, 2010
Writing about health research usually falls into two categories – new hope and no hope. Resveratrol has been firmly seated in the new hope category since some early clinical research had found some promise in the phytoalexin. It can lower blood sugar, prevent cancer, extend life and reduce risk for cardiovascular disease. It’s in red wine, peanuts and mulberries. What’s not to love?
Well, first of all, most of these “miracles” happened to rats or in Petri dishes with cooperative yeasts. The last time we looked, rats and yeasts were not human, though Bernie Madoff and a few others have proved that humans can be rats. Also, the folks at quackwatch.org also note that one fluid ounce of red wine contains 160 micrograms of the substance, which is approximately 1/100 of the dosage the rats got. Assuming a four ounce pour of red wine, you’d destroy your liver before you saved your heart or fought off cancer. Without liver function, you die quickly and painfully, which pretty much negates the life extension theory.
Also, food safety proponent Marion Nestle has pointed out that few antioxidants, amino acids and other potentially beneficial substances are consumed by themselves. “The last time I looked, we ate food, not nutrients,” Nestle told the Association of Food Journalists in Houston in October 2008. Nestle suggests that most of the compounds that are being touted for good health don’t operate on the body in a vacuum.
Furthermore, popular media often demonizes or praises substances beyond reason. People who battle celiac disease have every reason to avoid wheat and gluten, as do people with identifiable gluten intolerance. However, whole-grain wheat is not evil. The rise in the use of high fructose corn syrup does correlate with the rise in obesity, but the folks at the Pennington Medical Research Center in Louisiana point out that large amounts of any form of sucrose, including cane sugars and honey, are not good for you. A few years back, a lot of people chowed down on oat bran before various studies proved it might be a good source of fiber, but it probably wouldn’t do much to lower your cholesterol.
So, after years of various substances being touted as new lifesavers or seats on the Unhealthy Express, resveratrol comes along as the latest substance promising a curse or a cure. Take it from those of us who have seen these food fads come and go. Don’t believe the hype.
Learn more about this author, Claudia Perry.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.