Search Helium

Home > Travel > Transportation > Transportation (Other)

Should obese passengers have to pay more?

Results so far:

Yes
56% 407 votes Total: 732 votes
No
44% 325 votes

Yes

by Anthony Megna

Created on: May 04, 2009   Last Updated: October 02, 2011

The ugly truth is that obese passengers pay more, not only in dollars and cents, but in health related costs.  It takes more effort and time to get to where you want to go. Everyone wants to get where they are going as fast as possible with the minimum amount of effort, and there never seems to be enough time in the day to do what we want. What does this have to do with obesity? Read on....

When traveling by air, time is one of the most important factors determining pricing. Airlines need to meet their schedules, passengers need to meet their schedules, and companies need to satisfy their shareholders. Anything that slows the process of traveling down needs to either be eliminated or severely penalized.  Obesity doesn't fit in well in today's society no matter which way you look at it. No one wants to wait for a passenger or passengers that are obese to waddle down the airplane gangplank and then try to fit into a small airline seat. It takes time, it aggravates people, and it slows down the entire traveling day. These people must pay more. Why should the rest of society pay for their right to overeat?

Now there are going to be people that are furious reading this saying that obesity is a disease. And that is partly true, there are people who suffer from perhaps a thyroid problem that slows down their metabolism a great deal so that they can't lose weight that easily. For those people who can prove a disease causes their obesity, an exception should be made. But in our "super-size it" society, a lack of willpower to stop overeating shouldn't penalize the rest of society for some who have no willpower.

We have all heard how obesity is killing us, and are all tired of it. But it's true. There are so many negative health factors that stem from obesity from high blood pressure to diabetes etc. that can be curbed if people just maintained some control and ate right as well as exercised properly. Obesity is an epidemic and if a doctor doesn't scare people into a proper lifestyle than maybe hitting them in the wallet will.

Why should society suffer for those that can't maintain control? It's not only the problem of obesity, it's also happened to our financial credit system. For all those people who defaulted on their credit cards and loans, the people who haven't must pay more for the people who have. But the difference here is that the credit card companies are mostly to blame for pushing credit down the throats of people who shouldn't have the credit in the first place! For all those fast food companies pushing high calorie foods down our throat, the jig is up. There are now regulations in place for companies to list the caloric content as well as ingredients in their food. About time, wouldn't you say?

In summary, since obesity is a national health crisis, and it's a crisis make no mistake about it, something needs to be done fast. In fact, a bunch of "somethings" need to be done, and financially penalizing obese people makes sense. Not only for our economic well-being, but also for the "fat" people's health. While we're at it, let's penalize those companies that are grossly loading up their food products with an extreme amount of unhealthy substances.

Learn more about this author, Anthony Megna.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

by Barbara FeliceHowarth

Created on: April 28, 2009

Obesity has become a wide spread problem in our country as well as others. I could stand to lose a few pounds myself but I'm far from obese. When it comes to travel this can be a sticky situation. While it seems unfair to walk on to an airplane for a ten hour flight just to find yourself in the middle of two obese people making your trip miserable, is it still fair to make those two people pay double for their fare?

The first problem to double charging obese travelers is to prove their weight. Most people make their travel arrangements either on line or over the phone. How many passengers do you think will volunteer this information while booking their flight? Is it up to the travel agent to ask "how much do you weigh" and after asking that question they would also need their height and body type. There are quite a few people including myself that weigh a lot more than they look because of working out and accumulating muscle. In reality the only way to tell if a person is truly obese is at the airport upon check in. Should there be scales and a doctor or nutritionist at each terminal? Getting weighed would be a very humiliating thing to do for anyone let alone someone who is overweight due to conditions beyond their control. There are those who are overweight due to their own neglect but there are also those who cannot help how much they weigh. Does this mean each overweight traveler need to bring a note from their doctor stating why they are overweight? Even if their weight is proven, it doesn't mean it's medically their fault.

Once we find out that the passenger is indeed obese, how is it fair to make an already purchased ticket cost more? Most if not all airlines guarantee their price once the ticket is paid for. In my opinion, there are very few wealthy obese americans based on the simple fact that wealthy people have the money to eat healthier and keep more fit. This leaves middle class and poor Americans paying double for a seat that most likely cost them more than they could afford for a ticket in the first place.

The solution for this problem could be solved by the airlines. I have flown several times in my lifetime and for most part have only seen one or two obese passengers on any given flight I have traveled. Airlines offer First class, Business Class and Coach class. Why not have the last section of the plane equiped with two rows of larger but less seats for the obese instead of charging them more. In leui of 3 seats in a row they could provide 2 but larger seats giving the obese comfort and the non obese peace of mind for the duration of their flight. After all, in reality the American Medical Association considers obesity a disability which means that making a disabled person pay more for a flight would mean discrimination.

Learn more about this author, Barbara FeliceHowarth.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA