My Helium | Join | Log in Where Knowledge Rules

Society & Lifestyle:

Morals, Values & Norms

Debate_icon

RSS RSS Feed

Get a Widget for this title

If someone dropped a dollar, would you give it back to them?

Results so far:

Yes
88% 258 votes Total: 294 votes
No
12% 36 votes
Yes

It is better to give than to receive for the Bible tells me so. How can anyone justify keeping what clearly is not their money because the small but meager bounty fell from the owner's possession onto public property. This inadvertent transaction was an error not an intention of lost, but as usual the ability to do the right thing depends on ones personal morality. Some people might justify keeping the money by considering to the victor goes the spoil or may even have the audacity to consider it a blessing, perhaps they will blame the person for being careless and figure it's a lesson learned about the ups and downs of life.

Returning the money is a blessing, I remember two incidents in particular when I was really impressed by someone's honesty, both of the incidents happened many years ago. I'd just walked out of a department store when a young man came up behind me, tapped on my shoulder and said,"excuse me Miss you dropped something." I immediately noticed that he was the same young man who was behind me in line so he had to have seen me pull out the pouch I was using instead of a wallet. I loved that cute little pouch that once held a present I received, for some reason I started using it to store my money.

When I saw the pouch in his hand I was surprised and very pleased to receive it, I had a lot of money with me that day for school shopping with my children. My heart began to beat rapidly at the possibility of the money being lost, my children would have been deprived of new clothes, shoes and school supplies. I was extremely grateful, I gave him a high compliment and thanked him more than was necessary. I also used the situation to point out to my children that there are good and honest people in the world.

Another event that was memorable happened June 1997 when we were in the process of moving from Seattle, Washington to Jacksonville, Florida our hometown. My husband at the time thought it would be a good idea for us to make a last minute trip to the grocery store to get extra snacks, drinks and whatever else was needed to help make the long travel across the country as comfortable as possible. I was a little skeptical about leaving the money I'd withdrawn from my personal account behind so I stuffed it in my black wallet.

I remained in the van while everyone else went inside the store. I remember sitting there counting the hundreds of dollars I managed to hold onto and was quite proud of my savings. After I finished counting the money I put it back in the wallet and set it on my lap instead of putting it back in my purse. On the way home my husband thought of something else we might need, he made another stop. The rest of us stayed in van until a couple of my children got restless and asked if they could wait outside of the van. I didn't blame them it was getting a little hot in there.

Without thinking and totally forgetting about the wallet on my lap, I stepped out to catch the breeze as well. After returning home we loaded up the van and double checked everything. Just before we were about to leave I checked my purse to see if all was accouted for, and that is when I noticed the wallet was missing. My heart literally missed a beat, I experienced a mild shock, some kind of blind oblivion, and disbelief all rolled up into one. I emptied my pocketbook hoping the wallet was buried somewhere beneath the other items, but it wasn't there.

I began to look under every nook and cranny, that's a term I learned from my mother. As I was franticly looking around my husband and children noticed I was panicked, they asked what was wrong. I informed them that I couldn't find my wallet, everyone began to help me search. Within the same hour I received a call from a police officer, he identified himself and asked what was my name, I told him my name. Then he asked me if I lost a wallet, I said, "yes I did." He preceeded to get more information and details about the wallet, the location it was lost, the contents and amount of the money. After he was satisfied that I was the recipient of the lost property he brought it to our home.

The officer was a life saver, for the first time in my life I thought of someone as a hero and a role model for the good in the world. I wanted to give him a big hug when I saw him but I decided against it, of course I thanked him beyond belief. I explained to him that we were leaving town which explained why I had so much cash in my wallet, he was truly a blessing. Our trip would have been somewhat effected without the extra cash on hand, it was surely needed. I'll never forget these two incidents and will always treasure them because of the honest nature of individuals who sought to do the right thing.

I have given back wallets, credit cards, pens or whatever a person has left behind or dropped. Even my effort to help a lady find a dime she dropped which was needed for the completion of a purchase. You'd think I'd helped to find a precious heirloom judging her appreciation for the kindness of a stranger. The key word is give it's rewarding in it's on right. Now, as some people like to quote, I said that to say this. I would definitely give the dollar to the person who dropped it. I must pass on to others what has been given to me. Good deeds don't go unrewarded they're returned to you in kind by making you a blessing to others as well as yourself.

Learn more about this author, Barbara Griffin.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

If someone dropped a dollar would I give it back to them? The short answer, no. The long answer, no, because it's a dollar. What is a dollar to that person? Unless they are homeless or poor a dollar is most likely small change to them, and they probably don't need it if they are careless enough to drop it.

Think about it, we have pockets, wallets, etc, so many safe places to keep coins. If we are careless enough to drop a coin it is our own fault unless we are impaired or insane or overworked etc. And as I already said, it's just a dollar.

We live in a competitive capitalist society based on money. We must be resourceful to survive. Thus one can think of a person dropping a dollar as being synonymous with a beast dropping part of a carcass. We are another predator or scavenger, and pick up and digest the carcass piece. It's only human nature to be resourceful, and it is also logical.

And of course, it's just a dollar. The person is probably in possession of a lot more money than a dollar. If I dropped a dollar I wouldn't expect you to give it back to me. That doesn't mean I condone stealing money, but I don't consider scavenging and resourcefulness as stealing. "Finders keepers" applies here, methinks.

However the morality might be different if this was a fifty dollar note, a mobile phone, etc. After all, it's just a dollar.

The only circumstance in which I would say 'yes' is if the individual who dropped the dollar was poor or homeless or what have you. Also let us not forget that they most likely wouldn't give you a dollar back if you dropped one. Then again everybody acts differently.

But the fact remains that there is no law stating we must return it. Once money is dropped or lost it is legally not that person's money any more, or if this is not the case I have a price on my head as do many other resourceful people. It is not stealing to pick up somebody's dropped money. It is being resourceful and intelligent, which is what separates us from the other animals and makes us civilized.

Indeed if somebody dropped a fifty dollar note I'd keep it for myself. Or a hundred. Or if it was physically possible a house, train, nation. It isn't stealing because that person has, whether by their own choice or not, relieved themselves of ownership by relinquishing grasp of the object physically. Perhaps officially it may still be theirs, but it is hard to imagine how a law would go about defining the exact point at which property becomes public.

For objects such as mobiles they are given to the police station and if not claimed given to the finder, why not the same with coins? Indeed I believe it is the same with money, but it's not as if somebody is going to go to the trouble of visiting the police station to inquire as to the whereabouts of a missing dollar, let alone be able to prove it is theirs!


Learn more about this author, Mark Waybill.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA