Join | Log in

Channel Button
Debate_icon

Parenting & Pregnancy   >

Teen Challenges

Get a Widget for this title

Should parents buy a teen's first car?

Results so far:

Yes
47% 159 votes Total: 339 votes
No
53% 180 votes
Yes

Since the 1920s, getting behind the wheel has been THE symbol of the rite of passage to adult responsibility and also to independence. Venturing the highways and byways of our land is romanticized in movies, in video games, and certainly with kid's toys, but driving is a privilege and not a right.

If your teenager is involved in positive activities, has a (somewhat) helpful attitude around the house, is making good grades, etc, then perhaps such a kid deserves a break. Of course that depends on your finances as well as your philosophy.

It feels great to be Santa Claus, but kids stop believing in ol Saint Nick long before they are driving (hopefully!). Giving a youth such an expensive gift as a car, especially a new one without any effort on their part is paving a dangerous road to expectation.

For instance, a comparison of your own childhood with a feeling that "I want to give my kid a new car because I drove an old piece of junk" should not be a factor in the decision. You survived that experience or you would not be reading this.

So, what's the solution? Holding the teenager accountable to acceptable standards of trust, and a good work ethic is a great start.

If they have demonstrated effort towards becoming a mature person, why not help them out if you can?

A reliable (used) vehicle can easily cost five to ten thousand dollars. Kids are unlikely to make that much even in a whole year unless they are selling drugs, or are a great entrepreneur. But maybe they can kick in a thousand. Make them save up for a while. Perhaps they should share the cost of insurance. You have an opportunity here to be creative and reasonable.

Above all, let them know what's expected for rewards and restrictions. They will try to wear you down and work around whatever answer you give, so be resolved to follow through.

Selecting a vehicle is an area where you should exercise parental guidance. If you're allowing the sixteen year old to choose whatever they want, even with their own money, you are likely doing them a disservice. Kids need help whether they admit it or not.

A good first car should be safe, mechanically decent, practical (good on gas, etc.) and with a little luck, not the ugliest one on the block.

So, when your travel-minded daughter or young man comes to you about buying that car or truck, a recommended answer is "maybe: what are you willing to put towards it?"

Learn more about this author, Cameron Foster.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

I look outside in my parent's driveway and see my '89 Dodge Omni sitting there. Sanded down to the metal, the paint, scoop, and spoiler sit in my back seat. In the kitchen lays the new hatch lifts that I need to install so I can stop carrying around a board to prop open my trunk. The battery's dead so it won't even start. But when she does, she glides as if I'm riding on air. And the stereo's pretty good too. But best of all, she's mine.

I'm 17 and I have had my license for almost eight months now. My first car is still not done, but I have one. I payed a total of $50 for my baby, and what better deal. Yes, I have had to replace just about everything; from spark plugs to brake lines to fuel lines. The paint was peeling and there were many spots that were rusted through. But I put the money into it to fix her up, and although she may not be done, there is a pride I have over the fact that I did not run to mommy and daddy to help me get my freedom. I did that on my own.

One day, driving down the road, my reliable piece of crap car may fall right off the wheels and crumble into a million pieces from all of the rust, but it doesn't matter. I'm working on her, with blood, sweat, and tears (all are quite literal). I don't have enough money to take her to a shop so I'm relying on what little I know and what help I can get from others to fix her up.

I do not believe that parents should buy a teen's first car. It is like a coming of age in my opinion. For their entire life, the teen has had mommy and daddy (step, guardian, etc, whatever word fits their familial situation) buy their clothes, make their dinner, make sure they had what they needed to survive. A car represents growing up and freedom. In order for this to really sink in, I believe the teen needs to dive into the real world and fork over the cash for the vehicle. Yes, this requires getting a job and saving up the money; not going out and spending it on movies and video games. Thus, another lesson is learned in the process. The teen learns what hard work is and how to manage money.

By the parent buying the car, these life lessons can be postponed or even lost all together. I also believe that, when the car is a gift, they do not take care of it as well as they should. If they had to put the money in it, and know what it takes to have it, the teen will be more prone to keep the car in good shape and be more cautious. When they have to pay the bill, the teen will not want to dent, let alone wreck their car.

When the car is not given to them, the teen also learns to not take things for granted. They worked for that car, and can understand how hard it is to get one. This will humble them when they see someone taking the bus because they cannot afford a vehicle of their own. They also learn that you don't need the nicest or best thing out there. Yes, as I said above, I have a crappy car. But it's mine and it gets me where I have to go. Some of my classmates are not so lucky to have a car. They have to rely on others or try and hitch a ride with someone else whenever they need to get somewhere.

All in all, when parents buy the car, the teen loses life lessons. So, as a teen, I am telling all parents: make your teen buy their own car! It's for their own good, and you'll thank me in the end.

Learn more about this author, Caitlyn Jones.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA