Get a Widget for this title
RSS FeedShould magazine covers feature women breastfeeding?
Results so far:
| Yes | 58% | 181 votes | Total: 311 votes | |
| No | 42% | 130 votes |
Yes
Write now
Print
Invite a writer™
Add to FavoritesTo put the question in perspective, it is first necessary to understand the larger context and intention for featuring women breastfeeding on magazine covers.
If the magazine targets the female market, is a medical journal, or focuses on parenting, caring for babies and bringing up children, it is perfectly appropriate to have such a cover photo. After all, there is nothing obscene about breastfeeding one's child - It is the most natural thing for mothers to do, with great health benefits for both child and mother. Such a photo also conveys a very strong message of motherly love and bonding between mother and child.
Even if the focus of the magazine is not on females or parenting specifically, a cover photo of women breastfeeding is still relevant and appropriate if there is a special feature or editorial being done by the magazine on this or a related subject. An example is a current affairs magazine doing a special story on new medical discoveries relating to the benefits of breast milk.
Another appropriate use is that for a cover story highlighting the possibility of transmission of the Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) through the breast milk of a HIV+ mother to her baby.
As for an insightful study of famine and hunger in countries of the African continent, for example, what can be more powerful an image than a cover photo of a mother trying to breastfeed her new-born baby, but failing to do so because her body is too weak and malnourished to produce the life-nourishing milk?
Even for magazines specialising in non-related topics such as finance and economics, there can be occasions when the usage of a cover photo of women breastfeeding is entirely relevant. A topic that comes to mind is the economic impacts of the increasingly-prevale nt trend globally of breast-feeding on the dairy industry and companies that produces milk products, and how the share prices of these companies (if listed on the stock exchange) have been affected.
If it has been decided that the usage of a cover photo of women breastfeeding is relevant and appropriate, editorial discretion should still be exercised to ensure that the image conveyed by the photo is a beautiful one, rather than one which is meant to titillate.
Not all mothers breastfeed their child by totally baring and exposing their breasts. Most of them wear specially-designed and -tailored blouses that allow their babies to suckle on the exposed nipple, without them having to disrobe or unbutton half of their blouses.
If mothers were not wearing blouses that facilitate breastfeeding, most of them carry an extra piece of cloth or towel that they drape over their shoulders when breastfeeding, especially in public, so that their modesty is protected and no one can accuse them of obscenity or indecency. In any case, the breast being suckled upon is usually covered by the baby's head in the first place.
In terms of the photographic angle, there are many ways to convey the image of breastfeeding in a natural and beautiful way. As long as the photographer captures the right mood and image, and the magazine's editor is satisfied with the appropriateness and relevance of the cover photo, there is absolutely nothing wrong with featuring women breastfeeding on magazine covers!
Learn more about this author, Kris Lee.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
No
by Candy Jules
Breast feeding has always been a miracle to me. God produces milk in the body of a new mother to feed her child. It's also a very private bond between mother and child. That's the closest bond and the first bond that you will ever have with your child.
Breast feeding is not to be exploited for all the world to observe. What's the point? It's definately nothing to be ashamed of. I was proud to be able to breast feed all three of my children. It's better for their immune system. It gives them a good start because breast milk is mother's natural milk.
Now, I can't understand why a magazine would want to put a mother, breast feeding her baby, on the front of a magazine. There are enough women out there that will gladly flash their breasts just for the fun of it.
While I was nursing my children, and I was out in public, I would always drape myself with a receiving blanket so as not to exploit what I was doing. It makes some people very nervous and anxious to have to watch this. Even though it is a natural process, It it not to be done for show. I felt blessed that I was able to do this for my children.
Life use to be so simple, so natural. No one thought anything about things like this. It was a world where good thoughts were still around, and people saw the miracles of God's gifts. Now, everytime a baby is born, half the town is in the delivery room. The baby is put to the breast while the doctor is sewing the mother up. What has our world come to? Some things should be only between husband and wife, or between mom and baby.
What is natural before God should stay natural, not to become front page news, or centerfold. I'm always glad to hear about a young mom that wants to breast feed her baby. She will never regret it. Some may not be able to do it for very long, but it gives the baby a good start in life. It's better than not wanting to at all.
I have a friend that refused to let his wife breast feed any of there three children. He said those, meaning her breasts, were his toys. Sorry, but I called him a pig. He just laughed. But the sad thing is, there are a lot of men out there that feel the same way. A lot of women won't attempt to nurse because they are afraid it will ruin their figure.
If a magazine wanted to write an article on the benefits of breast feeding, that would be great. It would be a learning experience. But to exploit it on the front cover. That is rude, crude, and unacceptable to me.
Learn more about this author, Candy Jules.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
