Join | Log in

Channel Button
Debate_icon

Pets & Animals   >

Animal Rights & Issues

Get a Widget for this title

Is spaying/neutering animals a crucial part of controlling the country’s animal over-population problem?

Results so far:

Yes
89% 167 votes Total: 187 votes
No
11% 20 votes
Yes

Three million: that's the low end estimate of how many companion animals are euthanized every year due to animal shelter overcrowding. For an animal lover, that's three million too many. Two of the major sources of this problem are the stray and feral animal population in our country, and the abandonment of pets by individuals who can no longer handle the responsibility of pet ownership. Unfortunately, many loving, responsible pet owners don't realize that they are unwittingly contributing to the problem by failing to have their pet spayed or neutered.

It's understandable why a pet owner might elect not to have their pet spayed or neutered. After all, it's natural to think that your dog or cat is the cutest/friendliest/b est dog or cat ever- and to want to gift the world with a litter of little copies. Many pet owners also justify not fixing their animals because they keep their pets indoors. However, no one can guarantee that their animal won't slip out the front door or the back gate- and you never know what animal is going to get in your backyard either. Some friends of ours hadn't fixed their female dog, and an unfixed male got under the fence while she was in the yard. They ended up having to raise and rehome six puppies.

While it's possible for a responsible pet owner to rehome a litter of puppies or kittens, it's not an easy task- and many well meaning people have turned to animal shelters in desperation, adding to the overcrowding in these facilities. And for every cute little offspring of your favorite pet that you rehome, there's one less home to adopt an equally cute, friendly, loyal shelter animal in need of a home.

The importance of spaying and neutering is a cause very close to my heart. We have four shelter cats in my house, and one I rescued from an empty apartment. In the year that we've lived in San Antonio (a city with a exponentially larger stray population than I've ever seen before) not a week goes by that I don't see multiple stray animals wandering the roadside and prowling parking lots. Last September we took in a sick, abandoned rottweiler we found, dehydrated and starving, lying under my car one morning. There wasn't room in any no-kill shelter within an hours drive of the city, and a few days later she had a litter of puppies in our garage, which we raised for two months before finding good homes for them all. Not even two months later, I was stopped in the parking lot of the local Walmart by some young girls. They had found two tiny kittens abandoned in the recycling bin at their school, and their mom wouldn't let them keep the cats. The miniscule male kittens were too young to have been separated from their mother; they tried suckling on each other's bellies for nourishment. We fed them milk replacement formula, weaned them onto dry food, and found them a great home.

Unfortunately, I can't rescue every stray animal in Texas. Nearly every day I see dogs wandering into traffic, see forlorn bundles of fur lying by the side of the road. Feral cat packs wander empty parking lots at night at nearby stripmalls, and I can't take them all in and find them loving homes. What I, or any animal lover, can do is be an advocate for spaying and neutering. This is the best way to attack the stray and feral population problem in our country, because spaying or fixing one animal can prevent literally dozens of unwanted animals from abandonment and euthanasia.

Learn more about this author, Sarah Guy.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

Is castrating men or making women infertile a crucial part of controlling the country's human population? No. Then the answer should be no to neutering animals to conrtol the country's animal over-population. How about stop breeding animals for profit and that will eliminate some of the over-population right there.

Animals are meant to be here just as much as humans are meant to be here. No one has the right to control nature in that way. Unfortuantely people are into dollars and cents and therefore they breed animals for profit and that is part of the problem.

We think it's cute because celebrities are toting around their darling animals and then we are horrified when things go wrong. Celebs like Paris Hilton make a mockery out of owning pets and discarding them like last year's manolo's. It's ridiculuos. Recentenly in the news we were horrified when a chimp, housed as a pet, ripped off a woman's face. He wasn't supposed to be kept captive in a home as a substitute for human compaionship. Animals are meant to live free and roam the earth as they please. We as human sure have our freedom.

Hopefully, someday soon, we as humans will realize the dangers we are imposing on the earth by our zoos and roadside shows that are destroying the animals that we supposedly love and cherish.

There are starving kids and children waiting to be adopted but yet we don't regulate how many children people can have. Case in point, Nadya Suleman, the now infamous Mom that just gave birth to eight, yes eight, children that she can not afford. She did not even conceive them naturally. She used science to add to the human consumption and population. Yet, no one is forcing her to tie her tubes.

Human beings need to get over ourselves. We try to control everything around us, supposedly, for the good of man. Please, let's stop trying to spay and neuter everything around us so that we can bring more people into the world to pollute it and ruin it. These animals are not the ones destroying the earth so why should we destroy their ability to do what is a part of nature.

Let's wake up world and face the reality of the things that we are trying to do. WWJD. This is not our world to destroy. These are not our animals to neuter and spay. These creatures are here, trying to survive, just as we are. When will we wake up and see the truth? I just hope everyone will stop this nonsense about eliminating the ability for animals to procreate because we feel there are too many. Who are we to judge? I just hope that in man's quest to control everything on and around earth that we don't end up destryoing earth itself.

Learn more about this author, Charlene C.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA