Get a Widget for this title
RSS FeedShould we blame genetics for the obesity epidemic?
Results so far:
| Yes | 17% | 142 votes | Total: 812 votes | |
| No | 83% | 670 votes |
Yes
Write now
Print
Invite a writer™
Add to FavoritesScientists in Aberdeen have found that people with a variant of the FTO gene (which was linked to obesity last year) are literally compelled to eat more food, consuming almost 300 calories more each day than the average person.
They claim that their findings uphold the view that some people definitely find it harder to lose weight than others.
The team from the Rowett Research Institute and Aberdeen University studied 150 people from North-east Scotland. Aged between 21 and 60, a fifth was obese and 34% overweight.
Their research has shown evidence that a link to the "at risk" variant of the gene causes an increased food intake in humans. They suggest that their data clearly shows that people are literally driven to eat more food and because they have the variant gene, it may be harder for them to lose weight.
Dr Colin Waine, the chairman of the National Obesity Forum, welcomes the new findings and says that it helps us to understand why some people who successfully lose weight still have trouble, saying "There must be millions of people who have successfully lost weight but could not sustain it over the long term", and adding that, "Over weeks, months and years, 300 extra calories a day is going to make you balloon."
I find this interesting information from a personal point of view because I have a good friend who suffers from morbid obesity. It certainly would help to explain why over the years he has slowly become bigger in size yet eaten, (as far as I know) ordinary meals, and very often hardly anything at all.
He will be able to have an operation to help him control his eating habits, but as his wife tells me helplessly: "What eating habits? All the operation will mean to him is that he will be able to starve himself much easier." The irony is that the operation can only go ahead if he is willing to lose three stone first.
He can't want to lose weight that much, if he finds it hard to lose just three stone, do I hear you ask? Well perhaps you would like to tell him that yourself. He will then be able to give you graphic details of his five attempted suicides, tell you about his four children that have not had a "proper" father for the last five years and break his heart over his failing marriage. He can tell you about the shame that he feels when he has to go out in public, and the misery he feels when he sees the looks of disgust from other people. He can barely walk the length of his front room and has been classed as disabled for the past two years.
He is an ex-army man with an intense feeling of pride for his family and a deep and abiding love for his wife. But he feels that for his sake and his family's sake, he would be better off dead.
Does this sound like a man who is deliberately stuffing his face because he is simply greedy? Do you think that he has a choice in how much he can eat, or how little?
Obesity is a worldwide problem. It will not go away simply by providing people with a better education, an encouragement to eat healthily and adequate exercise.
It needs sorting out at a much deeper level, and our scientists are so close to finding out what the real problem is. At last, obese people may have a chance to turn their lives around. We just need to know for sure, that's all.
So the very next time you come into contact with an obese person. Please don't look away with disgust or point and make a comment. He will see you, he is not blind, he will hear you, he is not deaf, he will understand what you are saying because he is not stupid.
He is a human being like anyone else.
Learn more about this author, Jane Allyson.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
No
Blame is a highly emotive term, is it appropriate in the defining question of this debate? Does a person's genotype have an impact on their becoming obese, yes it does. Can it be "blamed" for the end result, not at all. People have free will and the ability to learn; succumbing to temptation or even addiction is a matter of choice, even if it is extremely difficult to resist, rather than genetic inevitability.
Our genotype, the genes in every diploid cell in our bodies - which is all of them except for our haploid reproductive cells, spermatozoa in men and ova in women - defines the range of possibilities that our interaction with our environment may produce as our phenotype, how we end up being physically. While that may influence whether we can become obese, it does not cause us to become so.
People, in our modern Western societies in particular, have become appallingly ready to blame external factors for problems, rather than face the reality of personal responsibility. Understandably so. Political parties encourage such attitudes to promote their political ambitions for control, commercial multi-nationals do so to promote their supposed "cures" for commercial gain and advertising repeatedly tells us of external remedies for problems that they tell us we have in the first place.
We need to accept just one basic and obvious truth!
Body mass can only increase if you consume more food than your body needs to meet maintenance requirements and energetic output. Although your body will primarily use carbohydrates, specifically glucose, for energy, it will metabolize and use fats and proteins if necessary. You quite simply cannot become overweight unless you over-consume.You need to ascertain the metabolic realities of your body, it varies for all of us, and then supply your body with the diet appropriate to it. Please realize that I use the word "diet" here in the context of its actual meaning, rather than the commercialized version multiple "health" companies and "specialists" try to sell us. Our diet is quite simply what we eat, no more or less. Specific diets are just that, a specific diet, but every single person in the world is "on a diet", unless they are in one of those areas where famine prevails. My apologies, but I find the constant misuse of this term in Western society, purely for commercial profit, to be extremely annoying!
Our modern society provides the opportunity to over-indulge our appetites, appetites that have evolved over millenia where most people in human societies have struggled to meet their personal dietary needs. Consuming what is available is indeed a genetic imperative because of this evolutionary history, resisting such an imperative is dependent on the will of the individual.
Blaming genetics is simply a way of absconding our responsibility for our own well-being. We do so because being able to determine the elements of our lives that actually are within our control, and those that are not, has become exceedingly difficult. Governments legislate intrusions into our personal lives that are far beyond their purview, because they are dominated by people that desire to control others, even though, or perhaps because, their own lives are such a mess that they are totally incapable of controlling them to their own satisfaction. Businesses have reached such large scales that they no longer have a human component mitigating their social impacts, they are purely profit driven, desiring consumers that believe anything they say rather than a discerning populace capable of making their own decisions. Capitalist economics has resulted in a world where many have large bellies because they overeat; unfortunately it is a world where far more do because they are malnourished or literally starving.
Recognize that there are still many components of your life that you do still have control over. Your weight is one of them. Diet does not mean starving, we all have diets, even those who are obese. Consider your consumption behaviors and make some choices for yourself. Seek help, people make changes more successfully when supported by others. Change your dietary habits and accept that it will take a considerable amount of time. We seem to expect quick fixes, even for problems that have developed over many years. This is unrealistic, if we want a permanent change. It can be done, but it takes time and determination. Recognize this from the start and you can make the changes resulting in a healthier, fitter and more satisfied you.
I have donated the advertising profits from this article, that Helium provides its writers, to the charity "Food For Everyone" because that seems particularly fitting.
Learn more about this author, Perry McCarney.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Difference of opinion? Debate now.
- Weight Issues
- Is the obesity epidemic real or hype?
