Get a Widget for this title
RSS FeedWhich is larger: Yankees Nation or Red Sox Nation?
Results so far:
| Yankees | 59% | 77 votes | Total: 131 votes | |
| Red Sox | 41% | 54 votes |
Yankees
Write now
Print
Invite a writer™
Add to FavoritesWhich "Nation" is larger: The Institution of The New York Yankees or Red Sox Nation? According to Hank Steinbrenner, The Yankees organization is less a baseball club than an American institution and that Red Sox Nation is a bit of a joke.
So, a company named "Compete" took a look at tracking metrics and consumer behavior at both the Yankees and Red Sox websites.
It would seem that throughout most of the year, the Yankees garnered more of the attention than the Red Sox even though the Red Sox had the best record in baseball most of the season, the only time they edged out the Yankees' traffic was in October leading up to and after the World Series through December.
I hate to argue with guys who get paid to do this stuff, particularly when my team would seem to benefit from their analysis, but they seem to miss a couple of things:
1) The Red Sox had the best record in baseball throughout most of the year and the Yankees swooned through most of the first half, yet the Yankees data suggests visitors were flocking to the Yankees site. There's no analysis of what people were looking at, perhaps it was the train wreck on the side of the road everyone wants to see, but clearly the Yankees were the more popular using Compete's metrics.
2) While they note that the post season had a direct impact on site traffic and Sox traffic steadily increased from August on, what they fail to mention is that between July and August, traffic dipped, and the numbers from September look an awful lot like July, June and May.
3) I would have liked to have seen a third line representative of "the Average" team measured against the Sox and Yankees.
They note that the Red Sox have won two World Series championships of the last four series and the Yankees haven't won a championship in eight years, commenting that "we are in the golden age of Red Sox baseball" and conclude that "at least during the post-season, Red Sox nation is BIGGER than Yankee nation."
Right, but it's taken two series wins to even COMPETE with the Yankees as far as these numbers go AND the Sox don't match up well there. If it takes a "golden age" of Red Sox baseball to be competitive on the basis of unique web site visits with the Yankees, then I have to say that the conclusion is just wrong. Hate to say it, but I'm not sure I want these guys giving me analysis.
REFERENCE:
Y ou can find the Compete data at http://blog.compete. com/2008/03/18/yanke es-red-sox-nation/
Learn more about this author, Mo Morrissey.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Red Sox
Before I begin to elaborate whether the Yankee faithful is stronger than the Red Sox Nation I feel a strong desire to say I am neither a fan of the Yankees or the Red Sox. I am a Philly boy for every sport. I have long endured heartbreak and despair. Seasons end with words of encouragement like well just wait for spring training" or "let's see who we get in the draft." Year after year waiting, wishing and flat out wanting a championship to no avail.
Ok enough of that. Well, first of all, I have never heard of Yankee fans being called Yankee Nation. Maybe I have my head stuck too far up the National League's high ERA and low batting average butt; who knows. The Red Sox Nation groupies are some of the most faithful fans in the sporting world. Aside from the Green Bay Packers, can you tell me a longer list for season tickets? The Yankees are winners. There is no argument about that. Year after year they are playing in, and more times than not, deep into October. They have talent. But where does that talent come from? Aside from Derek Jeter and Robinson Cano most of their players do not come from their farm leagues, but rather they are paid for. Now, obviously this has been working but it's not the answer. Yankee fans go into the off-season expecting big money players to be brought, or bought, in. The Red Sox are building players in the minors or trading for young guys with bright futures. It allows fans to get to know these guys. It allows them to feel connected and to see them rise up through the ranks. The fans almost feel like they made it too.
Again not the point.
Red Sox fans paint their faces, wear their favorite player's jersey and paint their living room walls red and blue. But so do Yankee fans. Except they use blue and white. There are married couples where the husband is a Sox fan and the wife cheers for the Bombers and they don't speak on game days. These teams have incredibly passionate fans. So passionate that just the other day an older woman who happened to be a Yankees fan allegedly ran over and through two Red Sox fans. Now she is being charged with second degree murder and aggravated driving while intoxicating.
Is this more passionate than the Bronx construction worker, and Red Sox fan, who was on the crew helping to build the new Yankee Stadium and put a David Ortiz jersey in the cement foundation? Maybe it is, I don't know. I do know the first is a lot more extreme.
All of these fans are very passionate. I feel Red Sox nation, backed against the wall, is going to come out on top. They have prospects in their farm systems who they know where they went to college. They know the names of their high school sweethearts and that they lettered in basketball as well as baseball. The Yankee faithful know how much money they spent getting a player who just had a break out year and now will get a superstar paycheck for a more than likely mediocre season.
Learn more about this author, KC Productions.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Difference of opinion? Debate now.
- Baseball
- Could today's MLB teams beat the teams of baseball's yesteryear?
- Who will have a better 2010 season, the Mets or Phillies?
- Should baseball's Cleveland Indians change their "red man" MLB team logo?
- Is Alex Rodriguez the best player in baseball?
- Should player violence against umpires be a league matter or criminal?
- Will the Cleveland Indians ever win the World Series?
