Join | Log in

Channel Button
Debate_icon

Politics, News & Issues   >

US Law & Justice (Other)

Get a Widget for this title

Is it time for vigilante justice in the US?

Results so far:

Yes
37% 54 votes Total: 145 votes
No
63% 91 votes
Yes

A qualified Yes.

In the U.S. We have the largest number of people and the largest percentage of total population locked up behind bars. We have the highest rate of violent crime per ca-pita in the world and lead in additional categories like drug abuse, sexual deviance and domestic violence. The police and judicial system is overloaded and overwhelmed. In short it is not working.

In most cities and towns if you were to dial 911 and declare an emergency it will take 10 to 20 minutes for the police to respond to the scene. If they were to arrest someone he would more than likely be released on bail, cut a "deal" for reduced sentence or parole or if sent to prison given an early release due to overcrowding. We do not rehabilitate or punish criminals any more we warehouse them. In any event in a violent confrontation you would probably be dead before police arrived.

We have become a society that surrenders our rights and responsibilities and always say,"Somebody should due something about that" This "Somebody", substitute Government, should educate our kids, make sure we have a retirement, health care and above all protection. The sad fact is there are way too many of us and they really were never intended to do these jobs.

We need to go to those meetings at school and really take charge of education and demand that our schools educate. Parents need to take back the job of teaching manners, conduct and the discipline of their kids. We need to take responsibility for our financial well being, our retirement, our lives. Most of all we need to protect ourselfs and families on a personal level. Government, judical and police need to capture, deter and punish offenders. Punish in such a manner as make criminals really fear the consequences.

I am lucky, I live in a state that gives citizens the right to own and carry firearms. I have a concealed weapons permit and my wife as well. We have the right to deadly force if we feel threatened with bodily harm of ourselves or any one close to us. In the event someone were to threaten me or my family the 911 call would be after I had dealt with the assailant. Once at a traffic light late at night three men surrounded my car and one stood in front with a hand on the hood. Simply pulling my pistol and showing it made them see the error of their ways and they ran.

I do not feel a gun is the answer for everybody. Some people not familiar with them or afraid of them would be even more dangerous. However, there is pepper spray, mace, stun guns, batons, or a simple baseball bat. Get a dog that barks at strangers, an alarm system. Make yourself aware of danger and how to avoid it. Talk to your neighbors and keep an eye on each other, do not be afraid to get involved. If you see a stranger hanging around playgrounds or bus stops get some friends and confront them, most will clear out and not return. Ladies do not go jogging in the park by yourself after dark. Look around before you go to the ATM machine. Avoid dark parking lots. We all need to be able to defend ourselves for that first 10 to 20 minutes.

In conclusion I do believe we are responsible for our own safety. I have no problem shooting to kill if confronted with threats to my person or family, within the rules. It is not the individuals job to exact punishment or pass sentence, that I leave to the system. Hence my answer of a qualified yes.

One last thought about the story of the motorcycle guy following the two girls home. If he simply rode by making threats the father did not need to fire. If the assailant came on to his property or advanced towards him or his girls then the father is right to shoot and shoot to kill.

Learn more about this author, Peter Hicks.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

With all the restraint that I have in my soul, the answer is no. All too often, we view on the televisions and read in the newspapers, stories of innocent people that have fallen victim to another's injustice and lack of humanity. We are also bombarded with the fact that today's law enforcement professionals are given less and less latitude with the way criminals are dealt with. Despite all these sobering realizations, we, as a society, should still put our faith in the system of justice we have adopted.

I feel the primary reason people develop the need for "vigilante" justice is from the lack of understanding we have for today's police. It is also inherent in human nature to make right the things we see wrong, even if the law says you can't. The laws that are in place are designed to control and govern our conduct. The problem arises when you see that laws only control those that abide by them, not the few individuals that do what they want and take from the rest of society.

Everyone in the world has, at one time or another, felt rage and anger about the way a criminal was treated, thinking the justice system was too lenient or did not have the power to bring deserved justice. But this unfair awareness is the very heart of what makes it work. It sets boundaries and limits on our conduct. It allows us to call ourselves civilized and modern. It allows us to sleep at night, knowing that justice has limits on the measures it will go to punish a person.

We fight against all our natural instincts as humans when we take personal responsibility to the next level and make the conscious decision to allow the criminal justice system to follow rules of engagement with those that have no rules. We must put our fsith, no matter how undeserving, in the court system, and let them adjudicate according to the rules that govern us, the rules that seperate us from them.

It is not an issue of if we think vigilante justice is right or wrong. It is not an issue of moral turpitude or ethics. It is the the fact that in order for the system to work, the majority of our society has to let the system be. We have to accept the fact that it is imperfect and flawed. We have to embrace the fact that we know justice does not mean every wrong will be made right, but that it means we have accepted the injustice in exchange for the liberty and freedom that the American people have come to need like the air that we breathe. It then becomes an obligation of citizenship, a choice that is readily accepted.

Learn more about this author, John Pope.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA