Join | Log in

Channel Button
Debate_icon

Health & Fitness   >

Medical Concerns & Issues

Get a Widget for this title

Should the diet and weight-loss industry be held financially liable for people with eating disorders?

Results so far:

No
80% 98 votes Total: 122 votes
Yes
20% 24 votes
No

Responsibility is the key word; each person being responsible for their own actions and their own behavior. The trend to seek monetary compensation for bad choices is running rampant in today's society. An example are the lawsuits against the tobacco companies; everyone knows cigarettes are bad. If people choose to smoke despite the warnings, it is their own choice. Choosing to smoke and then suing the tobacco company for providing the product borders on the ridiculous.

Magazines portray the ideal body as ultra slim. Should magazines be sued because people have eating disorders after they view pictures of skinny models? Many teens go through a spell of terrible eating habits after reading magazine after magazine filled with the "beautiful people". What about TV shows? The stars are almost always slender. Should TV shows be sued because people develop eating disorders after watching the skinny actors and actresses?

The same goes for holding the diet/weight loss industry responsible for eating disorders. Following a diet or taking a diet pill does not cause an eating disorder. Making irresponsible choices does, however. Blame should be placed where it is truly deserved; on the concept that skinny people are good people and the rest of us are nobodies.

One of the first things one finds out when they start researching fad diets is that they rarely, if ever, work. And after the diet, more weight seems to be packed on than was there in the first place. Excessive dieting results in up and down weight and a general unhealthy situation for the person involved in it. This is not new information; this is common sense.

Like many people, I have tried the "diet of the week." I have not had any success on any of them, and I doubt many people have. But; is following the fad diet or using diet pills an excuse for me to start participating in an eating disorder? No. And if I do, that is my problem; not the problem of the diet companies or weight loss industry.

The best way to lose weight - and the only real way to keep it off - is to eat a healthy, well-balanced diet and couple it with an exercise program. Since that takes time and effort, many people are not willing to go that extra mile. Instead, they want magic in a bottle or diet chart. And when the magic doesn't work, some may resort to eating disorders such as anorexia and bulimia.

It is important to recognize that the diet industry didn't cause the person to make the bad choice, however. The person needs to be accountable for his or her own behavior and not try to place the blame on someone else.

Monetary compensation for personal bad choices may be the "in thing" in today's society, but it will ultimately do nothing other than hurt society on the whole. We have to get over the idea that we can sue for everything we don't like or for personal choices with unpleasant consequences and start living responsible lives.

People who do develop eating disorders should see a doctor and perhaps seek mental health counseling as well, as those eating disorders can be next to impossible to break without outside assistance. They are nothing to fool around with and can easily be life-threatening.

Learn more about this author, Rebecca Dyson.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

Yes

Article: Yes, because many will write one article after another that will stress that beauty is achieved only if one is slim.

First of all most of their models must be and remain a under size two or else they are never hired at all or out of jobs.

Secondly, they display a full line of clothes for the fuller figure, but, the models who making the money are not the full figured men or women, but men and women who are smaller sizes so their clothes more enticing. They are using double standards, because they want to make their money on the heavier people, but do not want heavy people to make any money in return. They pick the models who wear the smallest size in the merchandise, i.e. pants, jackets, shirts, etc.

They should design clothing that compliments the fuller figure and show how by wearing different outfits one can look thinner.

Many full figured men and women who know how to dress correctly look as handsome and lovely as the slim man or woman standing next to them.

Many magazines have brainwashed us into believe that if we do have a full figure we are not attractive and we then always find ourselves make excuses as to why we are built the way we are; are afraid to eat in front of others because they will be watching us; and stay quiet whenever others talk about their diets. This insecurity then escalates and as soon as we get home we are overeating because something in our bodies is not functioning as it should be.

Many will advertise exercise machines; diet pills; one diet plan after another; this diet book written by this famous star detailing the quick and easy way to become pencil thin and that group that has all the answers. Many of them are only money makers that promise to shed the pounds, but don't produce the results that they claim to produce and the cycle continues over and over again.

They do not say that a lot of the people who buy their products are like yo-yos with weight going up and down, and the weight they lost last year will be back on with more pounds in six later, or how many of these people develop health and/or mental problems because the products do not work.

Why even Princess Diana and her sister-in-law Fergie were constantly made to feel insecure because they may have had a few extra pounds on from time to time.

Why don't we as a society realize that people who have everything aren't able to enjoy the world we live in because of what we read, hear and see from the weight loss industry.

Many of the diets are very harmful to our health, and many times we are not even made aware of the damage that is being done to our bodies because of popping pills, going on liquid and/or water diets and or overexercising until we drop.

Regardless of knowing how much damage is done, many people still continue to get rich on false advertisements concerning that their food has the magic ingredients. Their exercise machines will keep us thin, however, they fail to state that we must exercise six hours a day to remain as thin as they want us to be or they will not work at all.

Medical Science is starting to realize that we are healthier if a few pounds are added as we grow older; we look better and younger than many older people who are too thin.

Medical Science also states that it is better for us if we stay one weight than to go up and down every six months; it is less draining on our bodies.

History has also proved that people live to one-hundred year of age regardless of the size just as people die at a young age regardless of their size. The same applies to the quality of life people have, whether they are heavy, wealthy and/or in good shape or not.

Unfortunately we never learn as a society, that there are some people who will never be thin just as there as some people who no matter what they do will ever gain a pound.

Insurance companies also bear some of the responsibility because of the weight tables they set. I am sure if their records were checked, thin people as well as heavy people have high blood pressure, sugar diabetes and other health problems.

However, they themselves do not accept that responsibility of causing people to constantly diet because they claim being slim is healthier than being heavy. At the same time they will refuse to pay the cost of treatment in hospitals and/or clinics where the patients are treated for either problem, be it overeating or under eating. They refuse even if it is a matter of life and death that is caused by someone being Anorexia.

Again, I ask, should we be allowed to sue these organizations and people who constantly make billions of dollars on false promises concerning people who become Anorexic?

What about those of us who lose loved ones because others have decided what the perfect human being should look like?

I would imagine that everything in our society comes in various sizes, be it God made or man made, trees, flowers, houses, buildings, cars and/or animals. Why should it be any different with Humans and why shouldn't those who try to convince us that we should all be the same size, not bear some of the responsibility when their false advertisements cause damage and death to our loves ones.

Why do we keep giving them our money and keep buying their products?

We would never let them tell us that we should all live in the same color house, have the same color hair, drive the same make automobile. Why do we allow them to dictate what size we should all be and destroy our confidence?

Learn more about this author, Frances Ruocco.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA