Search Helium

Home > Politics, News & Issues > Political & Economic Theory

Would you rather be born rich or intelligent?

Results so far:

Intelligent
80% 1153 votes Total: 1439 votes
Rich
20% 286 votes

Intelligent

by Lucius Trae

Created on: June 04, 2010

Perhaps the most "intelligent" answer to this question would be "it depends." However, humans develop their sense of self throughout their life, and it's usually somewhat in place by the time one is writing articles online. That said, intelligence is often a core part of one's identity, and the "praise" and "recognition" from friends and family is normal. People are used to be considered intelligent and valued for that trait, and it seems strange to think of things otherwise. So "of course," we wouldn't want it any other way.

However, we aren't in a position free from bias. In most cases, I would choose to be born intelligent because through intelligence, you can improve your life, secure your happiness, and accomplish a variety of other things. If you're rich, you can do these things, but it's less in your own control. You have to rely on the intelligent people you're paying, so to speak, to actually work in your interests. This doesn't always happen, of course, and many rich people live unorganized lives that lead to unhappiness or poverty.

There are many jokes involving this question. A person asks for intelligence or wisdom when given a choice between that and "wealth." After they receive the intelligence, they explain that they wish they'd taken the riches. In other words, it's implied that intelligence involves the realization that wealth and power bring more happiness than personal abilities. In some ways, this is true. However, you can gain wealth with intelligence directly. At the moment, the opposite is not true.

Having intelligence allows people to experience and appreciate a variety of things. Many people are unable to enjoy great literature, film, or appreciate the complexities of nature. They don't think with the depth required to do so. That isn't intended to be an insult. Rather, it's part of reality that many people view Shakespeare as "garbage" and Jerry Springer as "awesome." In some ways, it might be elitism that causes me to find this disturbing. In another light, it seems quite tragic. Plato argued that as someone who can experience both higher and lower pleasures, the philosopher (in this case intellectual) is best able to judge the better life. One might also observe someone who is intelligent without an education. They usually switch their interests to Twain and Dickens rather than continuing to read supermarket magazines. Many people keep a few of their roots close to them, but they certainly expand their horizons.

Living an intellectual life allows you to recognize ways to be satisfied with less. A rich person can indefinitely buy more and more, but this won't guarantee they are happy. Contrastingly, an intelligent person can recognize that another 5" inches to their television won't make them happier, and a new car isn't necessary when the old one still works. We all make exceptions to these rules, but intelligence also allows us to determine when these exceptions are warranted. Is a car on sale, will it create reputation and job opportunities, etc? Intelligence allows us to better evaluate situations in order to succeed. One might conclude that in terms of human happiness, intelligence is simply "more likely" to increase it than wealth.

Learn more about this author, Lucius Trae.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

Rich

by Perry McCarney

Created on: September 27, 2008   Last Updated: April 02, 2010

The belief that if you are born intelligent you can make yourself rich if you wish, merely demonstrates a lack of understanding of intelligence; or wealth-generating techniques for that matter. Yes, you may be able to become rich through invention, but far more often it's a matter of manipulating others. That requires social skills more than intelligence.

In fact, intelligence is likely to get in the way, as it is hard to not realize you are doing evil if you are sufficiently intelligent. Those with an average intelligence can readily believe their actions acceptable, on the basis of conforming to the apparent standards of society; those with above average intelligence are far more likely to recognize such actions as ethically reprehensible.

From the intelligence quotient (IQ) tests I have taken during my life, mine rates somewhere between 136 and 142. I readily admit that that is not genius level, but is generally considered within the top five percent of people. The average these days seems to be accepted as 100, although when I was an adolescent it was my belief that it was 110. I don't have the statistics to verify that, maybe I was mistaken; then again the world's population has doubled since my childhood. And the reality is that most intelligent people have fewer children than those with lower IQs. Recognition of economic realities and social disharmony is naturally more apparent to the more intelligent. Although some with a higher IQ will have more children because they do recognize this disparity.

In the past civilizations have risen and fallen in their local geographical areas. We now have a global civilization that effectively includes even the indigenous cultures that would, quite understandably, prefer to be separate from it. Anyone with even a modicum of intelligence might be able to perceive that the far more likely when, rather than if, of our global civilization's fall, will result in humanity, as the specialized species it is, becoming extinct. Joining the multitude of other species we are already killing off with our stupidity; whether that stupidity is driven by greed, desire for power over others or short-sightedness.

Our civilization is dominated by an economic system based on growth rather than sustainability. An economic system that evolved during the period of empire building and colonialism of a Europe that perceived the rest of the world as savages to be ignored or conquered, rather than having any rights to the lands they occupied. The economic system of Europe prior to this was based on sustainability; their technological superiority gave them the ability to conquer and expand, setting the trend for a belief in economic growth.

The world is a limited area, but still we are afflicted by those who dominate our societies insisting that economic growth can continue. Most of the environmental problems we face are due to the rapid growth of the world's human population, a growth encouraged by capitalist economic policy so as to stimulate economic growth. According to economic attitudes, it is "cheaper" to pollute our environment while manufacturing goods and services, rather than attempt to minimize our harmful effects. Modifications to this are limited, provided by legal constraints implemented by politicians only because of public demand, and often bypassed to produce employment in economically deprived regions.

Being born wealthy gives you two options. You can spend your life enjoying hedonistic pleasures, without concern for the future. This may well be the most logical option, because all said and done, human civilization is far more likely doomed than not. Saving us from ourselves is an unlikely possibility, even if all politicians suddenly became altruistic.

Alternatively, you can make use of the wealth, and the influence and power having it provides in our society, to at least attempt to improve the way things are. You are gifted with the ability to do so from the start. You do not need to dominate and manipulate and harm others to first accrue the wealth that can let you influence the world and strive towards a society that lives with nature in harmony, rather than one that destroys it. We are manufacturing our own species suicide; the rich have more influence than the intelligent, so it is better to be born rich in this world so that, just maybe, you can do something about it. You can always seek the advice of the intelligent, sadly the intelligent have far less chance of obtaining the assistance of the wealthy.

Learn more about this author, Perry McCarney.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA