Results so far:
| No | 79% | 710 votes | Total: 896 votes | |
| Yes | 21% | 186 votes |
Do the laws of Nature no longer mean anything to society? It has become possible to obtain anything we want or need (or in more appropriate terms, it has become possible to obtain anything the "media says" we want or need), with the simple push of a button. What is being suggested here is actually considering we can treat the most beautiful of natural phenomenon as a product obtainable through the most generic of fast food drive thrus!
Let's talk about this, really. If you feel it is acceptable to choose your child's sex, next thing you're going to tell me is it's acceptable to choose your child's eye colour, hair colour, facial bone structure, (future) breast size, height, etc. Ever heard of the Stepford Wives'?! Who are we to say which sex is "better". Much time and energy has been put forth over the last few decades in regards to equality amongst genders. I'm certainly not saying we have cleared THAT hurdle in it's entirety yet, but, progress HAS been made. We might as well have been trying to figure out how to raise the dead with all that energy, both futile efforts in the end.
Is there no desire for the element of surprise? Do we really want to order our children out of a catalog? Do we really think we can handle the responsibilities of being God(dess)? I'm troubled as to why I am even responding to this question, when the more obviously moral and ethical question would be this: Should people be allowed to choose whether or not their child is born, and will remain, healthy? At least a debate that began with that inquiry would have some depth involved, all THIS conversation does is indulge society in their "spoiled brat syndrome". (On a personal note, I DON'T think we should have a say in whether or not our baby is born healthy beyond the natural efforts we put towards that result. Children are born healthy or not, people develop disease or not, all good and bad we experience in this life is meant to be experienced. It's a spiritual issue to me, and I will leave it at that, in order to reduce the risk of typing forever).
I would say it is fairly easy to see which side I am on in this matter. I DO NOT think it acceptable to be able to choose your baby's sex, frankly, I don't think it's acceptable that we live in a world that would even consider such disrespect for the natural cycles of life. In addition to the moral and ethical issues involved, what of the physiological aspects? We all know, on a basic level at least, what the difference between organic and chemically processed is. There is nothing organic about fiddling around with science and "choosing" to include the "y" chromosome or not. How is this type of "manufacturing" going to affect our beloved children on the long run? Sure, you may have your blond haired, blue eyed knock out of a cheerleader daughter or your onyx haired, hazel eyed quarterback of a son, and he/she (or shall we say "it", we ARE talking about sexually manipulation here), may even be rocket scientists or brain surgeons (seeing as you checked THAT box off in the "intelligence column" of your order form), but they are FAKE! I can't help but wonder what kind of side effects may occur when we piece our unborn children together like Frankenstein.
I understand the question which has been stated does not involve all the elements I have touched on. I can't help but think, however, that these things must all be given consideration in this instance. We are talking about a complete lack of faith in Mother Nature. A total ignorance towards the beauty of creation. An absolute arrogance in our thoughts towards what we deserve, and what we can demand.
Learn more about this author, Dawnn Heiliger.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
In saying yes that couples should be able to choose the sex of their baby, I mean by using limited natural methods, and in no way do I support the use of technological science to alter an outcome.
There are already ways in which people of many cultures plan for a baby of a particular sex, and if the baby's sex turns out to be not what they were hoping for it can be accepted as a blessing from God or Mother Earth that the baby they got was the one they needed.
One relatively modern method I know of involves the theory that male sperm swim faster and die off faster than many females, so, in wanting a male baby, the woman would need to be aware of her cycle and ovulation, often by charting, cervical fluid, and temperatures. Then time intercourse with the last day(s) of fertility, thus the female have little chance of reaching the egg before it is fertilised.
There are probably many other cultural practices and beliefs surrounding choosing the sex of a baby, but there will always be the need to allow for natural selection in the long run.
Technological and scientific advances in my opinion have a lot to learn in many areas but the field of gender selection should be left well alone. The trouble with allowing everyone to take a technological approach is that the natural balances of male and female may be outweighed so much that at one point or another there may not be a match. Also there are concerns about where else this kind of technological advance could take our species. Would it be too much to ask for blue eyes? Or black hair? What about darkening the skin? Or modifying the stubborn gene? It might be nice to have a completely compliant child, but what about when peer pressure sets in, or some other negative influence?
Allowing science to be integrated into the production of our babies when it is not entirely necessary may do more harm tan good in the long run, whether we foresee it now or not.
So while we think about the question at hand once more; ''Should people be allowed to choose their baby's sex? ''. Consider that there are natural ways of trying to achieve a particular sex, which you can learn more about (by internet searching or looking into natural fertility control ) and if you feel you didn't get what you wanted, reconsider your role. You will be a parent, a parent of a child you made with Gods, Mother Nature's, or Mother Earth's blessing, and this is your path.
Enjoy your family!
Learn more about this author, Tania Mcloughlin.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.