Personal Finance >
Personal Loans
Get a Widget for this title
RSS FeedAre payday loans consistent with the free market?
Title endorsed in part by:
Results so far:
| Yes | 44% | 108 votes | Total: 247 votes | |
| No | 56% | 139 votes |
Yes
Write now
Print
Invite a writer™
Add to FavoritesA free market is by definition one that is unregulated by any factors other than supply and demand, so in that sense, payday loans are indeed consistent with the free market. There is a demand for short-term loans that carry few credit restrictions; payday loan companies supply the loans to meet that demand. The implication of the question, however, is that "free market" is necessarily a good or desirable state, and that is not always the case. Things like illegal drugs and child pornography also are consistent with the free market, strictly speaking.
A payday loan is a very simple transaction. Usually, the only requirements are a job and a checking account. Once a loan-seeker's employment is confirmed, he then writes a check payable to the loan company, post-dated for the due date of the loan. The total amount of the check is for the loan amount and the interest, which is generally very high, 25 to 30 percent or more. In other words, for a post-dated check in the amount of $200, the borrower will typically receive $150 in cash. On the date the loan is due, the loan company deposits the borrower's check, and if everything has gone according to plan, the loan is automatically repaid when the check amount is deducted from the borrower's account and paid to the loan company's account.
There are obvious pitfalls in receiving a payday loan. If a person has already run short of funds between paydays, receiving an advance against the next paycheck will most likely only aggravate that deficit cycle. And even though they are loans, the manner in which payday loans are made puts them into a sort of legal gray area in case of default. The only way a payday loan can be defaulted is if there are insufficient funds in the borrower's checking account to honor the post-dated check when it is presented to the bank. From a legal standpoint, a bad check is a bad check regardless of the reason it was written. Depending on what state the loan company is doing business in, it has wide latitude in charging additional fees in pursuit of collection, and the borrower is usually subjected to additional penalty fees from his bank. Passing a bad check is also a criminal offense. Realistically, most jurisdictions will not pursue a case against an offender for a single incident, especially if it is likely that it was an honest mistake or the result of uncontrollable circumstances. But there is nothing to prevent them from doing so if they choose, and this can be a powerful threat to use against a borrower.
Ironically, the payday loan companies can actually make more on borrowers who default than on those who do not, thanks to the civil court system. Rather than pursuing a criminal charge, the loan company can instead file a civil case in small-claims court; given the circumstances under which the loan was made, they are almost guaranteed to win the case. Typically, the borrower is ordered to repay not only the original check amount, but also a penalty to cover court costs that effectively doubles or triples the amount. And payment is guaranteed, because the court can order that the borrower's wages be garnished to satisfy the judgment. In essence, one bad customer is worth as much as two or three good ones to the loan company.
Are payday loans a bad deal for consumers? In most cases, they probably are. Are they unethical? Perhaps, but that is a matter for debate. Are they consistent with a free market? Absolutely. Payday loan companies are free to take full advantage of the law in order to do business. And since the law prohibits the loan companies from deliberately withholding or misrepresenting the terms of the loan or its repayment, consumers are free to make a choice no matter how inadvisable it may be. A free market is not necessarily a safe or a wise market; it is up to society to decide where to find a balance.
Learn more about this author, John Stall.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
No
Payday Loans are not consistent with a free market. In a free market both the seller and the buyer have the opportunity to walk away from the deal no worse for wear. In the typical transaction between payday loan makers and folks who need some immediate cash, the need for the cash far out weights any reasonable assessment of the terms and conditions of the loan. It is highway robbery, legalized in a number of states through graces of the banking and credit card lobby.
The almost humorous part of the whole transaction is that for less than $75,000 you too could become a payday loaner. These entrepreneurs simply act as a broker, taking the loan request to the legitimate financial world who discounts it back to the loaning agent. This transaction is done about once a week, or whenever the loan volume reaches a certain level - say $100,000! The banks, or other legitimate financial center simply accepts the package of securities and pays a set percentage back to the loaning agent. The loaning agent will collect the fees, split the interest with the house, and make a ton of money in the process.
If you are charging 2-300% for the money loaned, plus fees for processing the loans and everything else that can legally be piled on, it doesn't take long to make up the discount you will suffer when you take the securities to bank. A sickeningly large percentage of payday loans never get paid off and result in collection efforts, small claim court actions, loss of cars and other pledged items.
Many states have found so many abuses of the law and common sense they have (or are) enacting consumer protections, limiting the the types of fee's and capping the interest rates. I was delighted to read in our local paper that many closures in the pay day loan business followed Oregons' enactment of an interest cap. A local loan merchant was quoted as saying that without the 300% interest he was charging, he would go broke! Couldn't happen soon enough!
And of more recent interest is the effort of some of the local banks to cut into this business. Despite the rigorous interest caps and state/federal regulations in the personal loan field for organized banks, they seem determined to cut themselves into some of the interest gravy. An ad appeared in the local paper very deliberately informing folks that the bank could quickly make loans to "qualified" customers who could secure them with a paycheck or car title.
In my opinion, payday loan makers are despicable merchants with no redeeming values for the business, financial or related worlds. They should be banned.
Learn more about this author, Fred Tolleson.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
