Join | Log in

Channel Button
Debate_icon

Jobs & Careers   >

Starting Out

Get a Widget for this title

Military service is the best option for starting a work career: Agree or disagree?

Results so far:

Agree
34% 215 votes Total: 630 votes
Disagree
66% 415 votes
Agree

This is a very good topic that as I read has brought up some very old memories for me and just reading a couple of paragraphs from both sides has settled some questions in my mind on subjects that have always stirred up debates within myself. However I feel quite compelled to state that I have to agree that military service is the best option for several different reasons which could and have filled volumes of books on the subject.
My career began at the age of thirteen, I was obsessed with wanting to be a chef and everyday in the kitchen culling vegetables made the feeling that much stronger. When I finally decided that I needed to go into the military to get the education I needed to become a chef I found that it was much more than just cooking, it was teamwork to the tenth power and beyond. In the restaurant I had worked in everybody did their own thing even when it was time to go home. If you were on mop duty that day or night, you mopped the floor and others would stand around and watch while you struggled. What made my decision to go into the military was my patriotic side which my father strongly protested, he was a veteran of D-Day and the Battle of the Bulge, he had very strong views about the military and in no uncertain terms told me that I would never make it. He said he was proud that I wanted to do it but, he feared for me because Vietnam was still going on and he said that I wasn't the kind that liked to take orders.
The other mitigating factors were the fact that I had quit school to work, yes I loved it that much, and still do, and my boss told me that if I went back to school and graduated he would pay for me to go to the premier chef school in the nation all I had to do was work for him after I graduated for five years after that I was free to do whatever, I never mad it to the school, I went straight to the army recruiter.
What I found in the infantry was a camaraderie that I hadn't experienced in civilian life, I missed my friends at home but after my first two week leave I realized that I no longer had anything in common with them, nor did I want anything from them. In the unit that I was assigned to I found people from all walks of life that would help me if I was struggling and expected the same from me if they were struggling. When I transfered into the kitchen I found that I was a valuable part of a team also. And nobody that I had worked with in the civilian world kitchen had ever prepared for, cooked and served 850 people two meats, two vegetables, two starches, soup, sauce, several different salads and dressings along with dessert. Once I was assigned to a facility where we had eight cooks to a shift including the supervisor and first cook and we prepared food for 1500 to 1850 people per meal. Plus cleaned our equipment as well as after going in at two a.m. you may have to go to the motor pool or do a physical fitness test, etc.
There were non commissioned officers that taught me how to lead people, they taught me that your people have to respect you because of your ability to lead them, you don't want them to fear you because you're the person in charge. I even had one that taught me how to cook the full menu for 1500 people by myself starting at 4:30 in the morning and being ready with the line set-up at 10:15 a.m.
Since I retired fourteen years ago, I have worked in several different venues with a myriad of individuals from every possible level of experience and knowledge imaginable and I have only found one kitchen that was worthy of the comaradarie, respect, loyalty, honesty, and integrity that I had in the military. It was a kitchen in a french restaurant and the chef-owner was a veteran of the french army. He knew what teamwork was, he was very interested in the complete staff from dishwasher to maitre de, and went out of his way to ensure that you were furnished the knowledge to do the job properly.
The military instills morals and values in you that the civilian job sector does not have time to because of budgetary restraints, and the ever present job security issue. The military teaches you the finer points of working with and individual to train that person to perfection and you don't ever quit on that person, they will quit on you but, you are not allowed to quit on them. In the civilian sector I have watched too many times, young managers terminate an individual for coming to work late three times, even though they've invested thousands of labor dollars in training the individual over the past nine months it's eaier to dump them and find another than spend some time with the individual and find out what the issue is with them and the schedule.
But I think my biggest gripe with the civilian sector is the fact that we have large corporations which I have worked for that put twenty-one and twenty-five year old in the position of manager and expect them to train a staff of individuals to perform. I left food service for five years at one point and worked for a major national retailer. I was very much appalled at what I saw in this company hiring twenty-one year old to lead people from various walks of life. These people had never experienced a diverse group of individuals, I actually on several occasions along with another military retiree intervened to keep a young manager from being taught a lesson so to speak by younger workers. It was because the managers did not have the life experience let alone the diversity experience to deal with a team of individuals that came from Atlanta, Brooklyn, Buffalo, Puerto Rico, and Oklahoma. From the ghetto's and projects, the mansions and farms, each one with a different personality and learning curve, I'm sorry but you cannot convince me that graduating from a major university with a B.A. or M.A. in business will give you the same qualifications as the same age individual that spent four years on active duty in the military.
People who have spent a tour of duty in the military know the fundamentals of leadership and management, yes they may not know how to make a fine sauce the way that's taught in the fine dining restaurants and culinary schools but nine times out of ten a military person has more stamina, loyalty, and leadership ability than the average civilian, and has the drive and desire to learn.
Today I am a very successful chef largely due to the training I recieved in my military career, and I am constantly amazed at the knowledge level of the young cooks in the service industry that cannot handle the pressures of a modern day kitchen because they were not provided with the proper training.

Learn more about this author, Harry D. Sayles.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

Disagree

With some qualifications, I disagree with that premise. The military is a highly structured environment that builds people into the type of people who will meet the military requirement for "success". Now, it should be understood that "success" in the military is not necessarily what success means in the civilian world.

For young people, perhaps just out of high school or college, they are probably at the peak of their life in terms of independence. They have spent the recent years learning and questioning the values that were presented to them in school. The military is not an envirinment to question. In the military, you will be expected to conform and react, not to question. This may present a problem for many people with an independent streak. Depending on the specialty that you are trained for in the military, you may have little to no opportunity to exert any creativity or individualism. The military values conformity and will spend time and money to make you fit the mold, beginning with Basic Training which will remove most issues of individualism from you to begin with.

The US military offers many fine forms of compensation for your service. All your basic needs-of-life will be provided for during your service, and many benefits will last long after, such as educational expense, perhaps some health care and other veteran's benefits. The length of service will determine the benefits.

Another consideration for potential enlistees, is career choice. The military can be a source of great training, some unique to the services. You can sometimes get a recruiter to guarantee the training that you will get after 'basic'. Be sure to try to get them to guarantee that you will actually work in that field. They have been known to give you the training that was guaranteed and then assign people to some other 'grunt' work that has nothing to do with the training. Mismatches of skills and assignment are rampant in the military.

So back to our original question; is the military the best choice? You have to take a long look at yourself and your desires. If you are the kind of person who has no direction and doesn't really know where to turn, it might be a good choice. The military will give you a direction, and provide you a world of skills to use. If however, you know your direction and just want help and experience in getting there, you might think twice. There is also the question of ethics. Are you willing to become a reactive instrument of your senior officers? Do you have deep feelings about the acts of war? Are you dedicated to the military methods of helping to achieve the country's desires? If you have reservations about any of these things you might want to seek some other avenues. Strong personalities are seldom valued in the military until you reach the officer ranks.

Consider carefully what you are signing at the recruiting office. It's a contract to provide service to the nation. It requires your total alliegence and dedication for the duration of the contract. Anything less is cheating the service and yourself.

Learn more about this author, Jason Martin.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

Difference of opinion? Debate now.
Starting Out
Is it ethical to use a company computer to job hunt?

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA