Join | Log in

Channel Button
Debate_icon

Celebrations & Holidays   >

Valentine's Day

Get a Widget for this title

Valentine's Day: Does the expense of the gift equal the amount of love?

Results so far:

Yes
6% 27 votes Total: 459 votes
No
94% 432 votes
Yes

I think that there is a correlation between cost and love but it isn't what the businesses and commercials want you to think.

Someone who feels the need to spend a lot of money on a gift is letting their actions be dictated by business and commercial interests instead of their emotional connection and knowledge of the person they are buying a gift for. The amount you should spend is dependent on the person you are buying for. Let's face it, some of us are very superficial and very material.

If your loved one likes expensive things and expects expensive things, not buying to her/his idea is sending the clear message that you don't know them very well and you don't care about their feelings. If your loved one had "dropped hints" about what she/he wants, you are wise to listen. Not only does this lessen your stress in terms of coming up with something but it also sends the message that you were paying attention. Most people like to feel worthy of your attention especially if you claim to love them. Make sure that you heard these hints correctly and be wary of anyone stating a desire then saying that they really don't need anything. That's an emotional game that is being play, often unconsciously, and while I don't claim it is healthy, it happens.

By the same line of reasoning, if your loved one dislikes expensive things, spending on them will make them think the same thing and, in fact, might make them them think you are attempting to make up for a lack of emotion, commitment or time. How many times in American society do you see the stereotype of the guy who has to buy flowers or some gift to make up to his partner? So if you go overboard, it may raise a red flag in your loved one's mind. You don't want to do that.

There is a fine line between too much and not enough though when you buy presents and again it is a matter of knowing your loved one's tastes and feelings on gifts. Let me use me as an example. I love getting gifts but I'm wary of spending money. So one year for Christmas my husband got me a very nice pair of earrings that cost about $100 (our normal, good year spending limit) and a few other gifts. He knew my feelings but he fell in love with the earrings. So because I could see the love in his eyes, and knew the other gifts were very cheap, I didn't feel like he'd gone too far beyond our agreed budget for each other.

For Valentine's Day I always want chocolate, a card, and a nice dinner/lunch. The dinner/lunch is a breaking from cooking and we eat out rarely so it feels special. The card I keep and plan to look at when I'm 90 and have beautiful memories. The chocolate, oh, that's getting eaten quickly. Anything else is nice but not necessary especially this close to the winter holidays. So a person who loved me would know this and buy accordingly.

By the same token I know that my partners don't care so much about candy, especially chocolates so I buy a new book or game for them - the things they love. It isn't expensive but it takes me time to find them unique things and it may cost a bit more to order them special than simply walk into a store.

So money may matter in terms of sending a message about your love. For most people though it is really about how much attention you've paid to them so you know what to gift them with. If you are lucky, money isn't so important to them.

Learn more about this author, Tammyjo Eckhart.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

The expense of the gift can never equate to the amount of the love expressed, either on Valentine's Day or on any other special occasion, at any time of the year. Love is not something which can ever be measured or stated in monetary terms and therefore it is likely to be other factors which will determine the cost of any and all gifts given.

The easy way to look at this question when determining the value of any gift given or received on Valentine's Day is to look at the financial circumstances of the person giving the gift. It stands to reason that the more affluent a person is, the more they are likely to spend on the gift. It is not of course a written rule, merely a rule of thumb. If we expand on this to consider, however, whether a King giving his Queen a treasure chest full of jewels on Valentine's Day loves her more than the poor man presenting his wife with a bunch of wild flowers he hand-picked from a field, we can quite patently see that this is not the case. The two men may adore their wives equally, or quite possibly, the King is making an empty gesture while the poor man is truly expressing his feelings.

We should also consider at this point the thought which a person puts in in to a gift given on Valentine's Day. If someone chooses to give the person whom they love a fairly inexpensive gift which they know or at least wholly believe that person will love and cherish, as opposed to a more expensive yet less desired alternative, we may say that the lesser expense expresses a greater amount of love. This is simply because the person giving the gift has considered what is likely to please the recipient as opposed to how much money they can afford to spend upon it.

Valentine's Day is about one person expressing their love and appreciation of another. Love is an intangible thing yet far more powerful than any amount of wealth a man may possess. If we try to equate, therefore, to any great extent, the expense spared or otherwise on a gift given at this time, we merely detract from the importance and symbolism of the gift. Instead, anyone giving or receiving a gift on Valentine's Day should focus on their feelings for the other person only, the motivation and consideration behind the gift, and consider the price of same wholly incidental. In this way, both parties can focus on what the gift truly means and not detract from the principal issue at hand.

Learn more about this author, Gordon Hamilton.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA